{"found":true,"summary":{"name":"Defending Education v. Olentangy Local School Dist","court":"6th Cir.","docket":"23-3630","level":"Circuit","circuit":"6th","issue":"Schools & education","issues":["Schools & education","Speech & religious objections"]},"cite":"*Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist*, No. 23-3630 (6th Cir. filed July 31, 2023)","proceedings":[{"court":"6th Cir.","year":2023,"n_docs":101,"docket_id":"67649788","cl_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"*Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist*, No. 23-3630 (6th Cir. filed July 31, 2023)","citeNote":"the case itself; cite a decision in it where there is one"}],"dockets":[{"docket_number":"23-3630","nature_of_suit":"3440 Civil Rights: Other","date_filed":"2023-07-31","date_last_filing":"2025-12-02","date_terminated":"2025-11-06"}],"counsel":[{"party":"DEFENDING EDUCATION; PARENTS DEFENDING EDUCATION","role":"party","names":["Cameron Thomas Norris","Emmett Robinson","James Hasson","John Michael Connolly","Taylor A.R. Meehan"]},{"party":"BRANDON LESTER, In his official capacity as a member of the Olentangy Board of Education; KEVIN DABERKOW, In his official capacity as a member of the Olentangy Board of Education; KEVIN O'BRIEN, In his official capacity as a member of the Olentangy Board of Education; LAKESHA WYSE, In her official c","role":"party","names":["Bartholomew Thomas Freeze","Christopher J.C. Herbert","Jaime Santos"]},{"party":"OLENTANGY LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD OF EDUCATION","role":"party","names":["Jessica Kathryn Philemond","Mitchell Stith","Sandra R. McIntosh"]},{"party":"AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION FOUNDATION; AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION OF OHIO FOUNDATION","role":"amicus","names":["Amy Gilbert","David Joseph Carey","Freda Levenson"]},{"party":"OHIO ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL BUSINESS OFFICIALS; OHIO SCHOOL BOARDS ASSOCIATION","role":"amicus","names":["Daniel Shisler","Scott C. Peters","Sherrie Clayborne Massey"]},{"party":"ALLIANCE DEFENDING FREEDOM","role":"amicus","names":["John J. Bursch","Mathew Hoffmann","Tyson Charles Langhofer"]},{"party":"COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY; COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA; ST; STATE OF; STATE OF ALABAMA; STATE OF ALASKA; STATE OF FLORIDA; STATE OF GEORGIA; STATE OF IDAHO; STATE OF INDIANA; STATE OF IOWA; STATE OF KANSAS; STATE OF LOUISIANA; STATE OF MISSISSIPPI; STATE OF MISSOURI; STATE OF MONTANA; STATE OF NEBRASKA; STATE OF NORTH DAKOTA; STATE OF OHIO; STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA","role":"amicus","names":["Joseph David Spate","Mathura Jaya Sridharan"]},{"party":"FOUNDATION FOR INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS AND EXPRESSION; MANHATTAN INSTITUTE","role":"amicus","names":["Robert L. Corn-Revere","Ronald Gary London"]},{"party":"EQUALITY OHIO","role":"amicus","names":["Mark P. Herron","Paul Giorgianni"]},{"party":"60 PLUS ASSOCIATION; ADVANCING AMERICAN FREEDOM, INC.; AFA ACTION; AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF SENIOR CITIZENS; AMERICAN PRINCIPLES PROJECT; AMERICAN VALUES; AMERICANS FOR LIMITED GOVERNMENT; CATHOLICS COUNT CENTER FOR POLITICAL RENEWAL; CENTER FOR URBAN RENEWAL AND EDUCATION (CURE); EAGLE FORUM; INTERN","role":"amicus","names":["John Marc Wheat"]},{"party":"AMERICA'S FUTURE; CONSERVATIVE LEGAL DEFENSE AND EDUCATION FUND; FREE SPEECH COALITION, INCORPORATED; FREE SPEECH DEFENSE AND EDUCATION FUND; PUBLIC ADVOCATE FOUNDATION; PUBLIC ADVOCATE OF THE UNITED STATES; U.S. CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS LEGAL DEFENSE FUND","role":"amicus","names":["William Jeffrey Olson"]},{"party":"AMERICAN HINDU ASSOCIATION; COALITION FOR JEWISH VALUES; ISLAM AND RELIGIOUS FREEDOM ACTION TEAM; JEWISH COALITION FOR RELIGIOUS LIBERTY","role":"amicus","names":["Kayla Toney"]},{"party":"GLBTQ LEGAL ADVOCATES & DEFENDERS; LAMBDA LEGAL DEFENSE AND EDUCATION FUND, INC.","role":"amicus","names":["Karen Loewy"]},{"party":"INDEPENDENT WOMEN'S LAW CENTER; MANHATTAN INSTITUTE","role":"amicus","names":["Ilya Shapiro"]},{"party":"MARTIN S. LEDERMAN; PAMELA S. KARLAN","role":"amicus","names":["Ruthanne Mary Deutsch"]},{"party":"MOUNTAIN STATES LEGAL FOUNDATION; SOUTHEASTERN LEGAL FOUNDATION","role":"amicus","names":["Benjamin Isgur"]},{"party":"DEFENSE OF FREEDOM INSTITUTE FOR POLICY STUDIES, INC.","role":"amicus","names":["Donald Albert Daugherty, Jr."]},{"party":"FOUNDATION FOR MORAL LAW, INC.","role":"amicus","names":["Talmadge Butts"]},{"party":"HAMILTON LINCOLN LAW INSTITUTE","role":"amicus","names":["Adam Ezra Schulman"]},{"party":"INSTITUTE FOR FAITH AND FAMILY","role":"amicus","names":["Deborah Jane Dewart"]},{"party":"INSTITUTE FOR FREE SPEECH","role":"amicus","names":["Brett Robert Nolan"]},{"party":"LONANG INSTITUTE","role":"amicus","names":["Kerry Lee Morgan"]},{"party":"NATIONAL LEGAL FOUNDATION","role":"amicus","names":["Steven W. Fitschen"]},{"party":"NEOLA, INC.","role":"amicus","names":["William M. Deters, II"]}],"recentUpdates":[],"oral":[{"audio_id":96656,"url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/audio/96656/defending-education-v-olentangy-local-school-dist/","cl_case_name":"Defending Education v. Olentangy Local School Dist","date_argued":"2025-03-19","duration":1886,"n_chars":23677,"bluebook":"Oral Argument, *Parents Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist*, No. 23-3630 (6th Cir. Mar. 19, 2025)","citeNote":"the recording; a transcript of it cites as “Transcript of Oral Argument at [page], …”"}],"scotus":[],"filings":[{"doc_id":"d82d364db973d","docket_id":"67649788","description":"AMICUS BRIEF filed by Mathew W. Hoffmann, without parties' consent. Certificate of Service:10/02/2023","doc_type":"Amicus Brief","filing_date":"2023-10-02","dkt_no":51,"pages":31,"docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Brief of Mathew W. Hoffmann as Amicus Curiae, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist* (6th Cir. Oct. 2, 2023), ECF No. 51"},{"doc_id":"d992413a91cc4","docket_id":"67649788","description":"AMICUS BRIEF filed by Mathew W. Hoffmann, without parties' consent. Certificate of Service:10/02/2023","doc_type":"Amicus Brief","filing_date":"2023-10-02","dkt_no":51,"pages":31,"docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Brief of Mathew W. Hoffmann as Amicus Curiae, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist* (6th Cir. Oct. 2, 2023), ECF No. 51"},{"doc_id":"d2a5328d2c53f","docket_id":"67649788","description":"AMICUS APPEARANCE filed for Equality Ohio by Paul Giorgianni. Certificate of Service: 10/31/2023. [23-3630] (PG) [Entered: 10/31/2023 01:06 PM]","doc_type":"amicus appearance","filing_date":"2023-10-31","dkt_no":68,"pages":1,"doc_url":"https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca6.148587/gov.uscourts.ca6.148587.68.0.pdf","docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Amicus Appearance, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist*, No. 23-3630 (6th Cir. Oct. 31, 2023), ECF No. 68"},{"doc_id":"d140a0845b737","docket_id":"67649788","description":"***LOCKED - filed using incorrect attorney's account*** AMICUS APPEARANCE filed for Equality Ohio by Mark P. Herron. Certificate of Service: 10/31/2023. [23-3630]--[Edited 10/31/2023 by REO] (PG) [Entered: 10/31/2023 01:08 PM]","doc_type":"amicus appearance","filing_date":"2023-10-31","dkt_no":69,"pages":1,"doc_url":"https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca6.148587/gov.uscourts.ca6.148587.69.0.pdf","docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Amicus Appearance, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist*, No. 23-3630 (6th Cir. Oct. 31, 2023), ECF No. 69"},{"doc_id":"d0cec072eadd5","docket_id":"67649788","description":"***LOCKED - filed using incorrect attorney's account*** AMICUS APPEARANCE filed for Equality Ohio by Robert S. Chaloupka. Certificate of Service: 10/31/2023. [23-3630]--[Edited 10/31/2023 by REO] (PG) [Entered: 10/31/2023 01:11 PM]","doc_type":"amicus appearance","filing_date":"2023-10-31","dkt_no":70,"pages":1,"doc_url":"https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca6.148587/gov.uscourts.ca6.148587.70.0.pdf","docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Amicus Appearance, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist*, No. 23-3630 (6th Cir. Oct. 31, 2023), ECF No. 70"},{"doc_id":"d1e755404cbaf","docket_id":"67649788","description":"AMICUS APPEARANCE filed for Equality Ohio by Mark P. Herron. Certificate of Service: 10/31/2023. [23-3630] (MPH) [Entered: 10/31/2023 03:16 PM]","doc_type":"amicus appearance","filing_date":"2023-10-31","dkt_no":73,"pages":1,"doc_url":"https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca6.148587/gov.uscourts.ca6.148587.73.0.pdf","docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Amicus Appearance, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist*, No. 23-3630 (6th Cir. Oct. 31, 2023), ECF No. 73"},{"doc_id":"d4d9c9c29567a","docket_id":"67649788","description":"RESPONSE in opposition filed regarding a motion requesting leave to appear at oral argument, [82]; previously filed by Mr. David Joseph Carey for ACLUF and American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio Found","doc_type":"Motion","filing_date":"2023-12-29","dkt_no":83,"pages":4,"docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Response in Opposition, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist* (6th Cir. Dec. 29, 2023), ECF No. 83"},{"doc_id":"debe9ba17ea41","docket_id":"67649788","description":"PETITION for en banc rehearing filed by Mr. Cameron Thomas Norris for Parents Defending Education. Certificate of Service: 08/26/2024","doc_type":"Petition","filing_date":"2024-08-26","dkt_no":92,"pages":79,"docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Petition for En Banc Rehearing, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist* (6th Cir. Aug. 26, 2024), ECF No. 92"},{"doc_id":"de697e275888e","docket_id":"67649788","description":"MOTION to file AMICUS BRIEF filed by Mathew W. Hoffmann for Alliance Defending Freedom. Certificate of Service: 08/30/2024","doc_type":"Amicus Brief","filing_date":"2024-08-30","dkt_no":94,"pages":10,"docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Motion to File Amicus Brief, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist* (6th Cir. Aug. 30, 2024), ECF No. 94"},{"doc_id":"dda04b3101c84","docket_id":"67649788","description":"TENDERED brief in support of rehearing en banc. Received from Attorney Mr. Mathew Hoffmann for Alliance Defending Freedom. (BLH)","doc_type":"Brief","filing_date":"2024-08-30","dkt_no":96,"pages":19,"docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Tendered Brief in Support of Rehearing En Banc, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist* (6th Cir. Aug. 30, 2024), ECF No. 96"},{"doc_id":"d0cdd1989798a","docket_id":"67649788","description":"AMICUS BRIEF filed by Mr. Mathew Hoffmann for Alliance Defending Freedom in support of the petition for rehearing en banc. Certificate of Service:08/30/2024. (BLH)","doc_type":"Amicus Brief","filing_date":"2024-09-09","dkt_no":119,"pages":19,"docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Brief of Alliance Defending Freedom as Amicus Curiae, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist* (6th Cir. Sept. 9, 2024), ECF No. 119"},{"doc_id":"d43067a06e382","docket_id":"67649788","description":"AMICUS BRIEF filed by Mr. Mathew Hoffmann for Alliance Defending Freedom in support of the petition for rehearing en banc. Certificate of Service:08/30/2024. (BLH)","doc_type":"Amicus Brief","filing_date":"2024-09-09","dkt_no":119,"pages":19,"docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"Brief of Alliance Defending Freedom as Amicus Curiae, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist* (6th Cir. Sept. 9, 2024), ECF No. 119"},{"doc_id":"df7417b34c55e","description":"AMICUS APPEARANCE filed for Alliance Defending Freedom by Jo","doc_type":"Amicus Brief","filing_date":"2026-06-03","dkt_no":48,"pages":1,"bluebook":"Amicus Appearance, *Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist* (6th Cir. June 3, 2026), ECF No. 48"},{"doc_id":"d07041a1e9309","docket_id":"67649788","description":"OPINION and JUDGMENT filed : AFFIRMED. Mandate to issue. Decision for publication. Alice M. Batchelder (DISSENTING), Jane Branstetter Stranch (AUTHORING), and Stephanie Dawkins Davis, Circuit Judges.","doc_type":"Opinion","filing_date":"2024-07-29","att_no":2,"pages":55,"docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"*Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist*, slip op. (6th Cir. July 29, 2024)"},{"doc_id":"d5339173c7ad3","docket_id":"67649788","description":"OPINION and JUDGMENT filed : REVERSED and REMANDED. Mandate to issue. Decision for publication. Jeffrey S. Sutton, Chief Judge; Alice M. Batchelder (CONCURRING), Karen Nelson Moore, Eric L. Clay, Rich","doc_type":"Opinion","filing_date":"2025-11-06","att_no":2,"pages":112,"docket_url":"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67649788/","bluebook":"*Defending Educ. v. Olentangy Local Sch. Dist*, slip op. (6th Cir. Nov. 6, 2025)"}]}