Text of MO SB 699 (2022)
Establishes the "Abolition of Abortion in Missouri Act"
Legislative text is a public record. Where LegiScan supplied it, the CC BY 4.0 credit applies.
Source: LegiScan. Bill data and text from LegiScan (legiscan.com), licensed CC BY 4.0 and used in modified form. LegiScan does not endorse the Trans Data Initiative. License: CC BY 4.0(opens another site). Source page(opens another site)
As introduced
316,465 characters
EXPLANATION-Matter enclosed in bold-faced brackets [thus] in this bill is not enacted
and is intended to be omitted in the law.
SECOND REGULAR SESSION
SENATE BILL NO. 699
101ST GENERAL ASSEMBLY
INTRODUCED BY SENATOR MOON.
3753S.02I
ADRIANE D. CROUSE, Secretary
AN ACT
To repeal sections 1.205, 170.015, 188.010, 188.015, 188.017, 188.018, 188.020, 188.021,
188.023, 188.025, 188.026, 188.027, 188.028, 188.030, 188.031, 188.033, 188.035,
188.036, 188.038, 188.039, 188.043, 188.044, 188.047, 188.052, 188.055, 188.056,
188.057, 188.058, 188.060, 188.065, 188.070, 188.075, 188.080, 188.100, 188.105,
188.110, 188.115, 188.120, 188.125, 188.160, 188.200, 188.205, 188.210, 188.215,
188.220, 188.230, 188.250, 188.325, 188.335, 188.375, 191.211, 191.320, 191.724,
191.831, 191.923, 191.975, 192.665, 192.667, 194.390, 196.1127, 197.150, 197.152,
197.158, 197.160, 197.162, 197.165, 197.200, 197.205, 197.215, 197.220, 197.225,
197.230, 197.235, 197.240, 197.285, 197.287, 197.289, 197.293, 197.295, 197.315,
208.655, 334.100, 334.245, 376.805, 376.1199, 491.060, 556.061, 562.031, 562.071,
563.026, 565.300, 574.200, 595.027, and 595.120, RSMo, and to enact in lieu thereof
forty-six new sections relating to abortion, with penalty provisions and an emergency
clause.
Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Missouri, as follows:
Section A. Sections 1.205, 170.015, 188.010, 188.015,
1
188.017, 188.018, 188.020, 188.021, 188.023, 188.025, 188.026,
2
188.027, 188.028, 188.030, 188.031, 188.033, 188.035, 188.036,
3
188.038, 188.039, 188.043, 188.044, 188.047, 188.052, 188.055,
4
188.056, 188.057, 188.058, 188.060, 188.065, 188.070, 188.075,
5
188.080, 188.100, 188.105, 188.110, 188.115, 188.120, 188.125,
6
188.160, 188.200, 188.205, 188.210, 188.215, 188.220, 188.230,
7
188.250, 188.325, 188.335, 188.375, 191.211, 191.320, 191.724,
8
191.831, 191.923, 191.975, 192.665, 192.667, 194.390, 196.1127,
9
SB 699
2
197.150, 197.152, 197.158, 197.160, 197.162, 197.165, 197.200,
10
197.205, 197.215, 197.220, 197.225, 197.230, 197.235, 197.240,
11
197.285, 197.287, 197.289, 197.293, 197.295, 197.315, 208.655,
12
334.100, 334.245, 376.805, 376.1199, 491.060, 556.061, 562.031,
13
562.071, 563.026, 565.300, 574.200, 595.027, and 595.120, RSMo,
14
are repealed and forty-six new sections enacted in lieu thereof,
15
to be known as sections 1.205, 170.015, 188.010, 188.015,
16
188.020, 188.023, 188.125, 191.211, 191.320, 191.724, 191.831,
17
191.923, 191.975, 192.665, 192.667, 196.1127, 197.150, 197.152,
18
197.158, 197.160, 197.162, 197.165, 197.200, 197.205, 197.215,
19
197.220, 197.225, 197.230, 197.235, 197.240, 197.285, 197.287,
20
197.289, 197.293, 197.295, 197.315, 334.100, 376.1199, 491.060,
21
556.061, 562.031, 562.071, 563.026, 565.015, 595.027, and
22
595.120, to read as follows:
23
1.205. 1. The general assembly of this state finds
1
that:
2
(1) The life of each human being begins at conception;
3
(2) Unborn children have protectable interests in
4
life, health, and well-being;
5
(3) The natural parents of unborn children have
6
protectable interests in the life, health, and well-being of
7
their unborn child.
8
2. [Effective January 1, 1988,] The laws of this state
9
shall be interpreted and construed to acknowledge on behalf
10
of the unborn child at every stage of development, all the
11
rights, privileges, and immunities available to other
12
persons, citizens, and residents of this state[, subject
13
only to] in accordance with the Constitution of the United
14
States[, and decisional interpretations thereof by the
15
United States Supreme Court and specific provisions to the
16
contrary in the statutes and constitution of this state].
17
SB 699
3
3. As used in this section, the term "unborn children"
18
or "unborn child" shall include all unborn child or children
19
or the offspring of human beings from the moment of
20
conception, as defined in section 188.015, until birth at
21
every stage of biological development.
22
4. Nothing in this section shall be interpreted as
23
creating a cause of action against a woman for indirectly
24
harming her unborn child by failing to properly care for
25
herself or by failing to follow any particular program of
26
prenatal care.
27
170.015. 1. Any course materials and instruction
1
relating to human sexuality and sexually transmitted
2
diseases shall be medically and factually accurate and shall:
3
(1) Present abstinence from sexual activity as the
4
preferred choice of behavior in relation to all sexual
5
activity for unmarried pupils because it is the only method
6
that is one hundred percent effective in preventing
7
pregnancy, sexually transmitted diseases and the emotional
8
trauma associated with adolescent sexual activity, and
9
advise students that teenage sexual activity places them at
10
a higher risk of dropping out of school because of the
11
consequences of sexually transmitted diseases and unplanned
12
pregnancy;
13
(2) Stress that sexually transmitted diseases are
14
serious, possible, health hazards of sexual activity.
15
Pupils shall be provided with the latest medical information
16
regarding exposure to human immunodeficiency virus, acquired
17
immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS), human papilloma virus,
18
hepatitis and other sexually transmitted diseases;
19
(3) Present students with the latest medically factual
20
information regarding both the possible side effects and
21
health benefits of all forms of contraception, including the
22
SB 699
4
success and failure rates for the prevention of pregnancy
23
and sexually transmitted diseases; or shall present students
24
with information on contraceptives and pregnancy in a manner
25
consistent with the provisions of the federal abstinence
26
education law, 42 U.S.C. Section 710;
27
(4) Include a discussion of the possible emotional and
28
psychological consequences of preadolescent and adolescent
29
sexual activity and the consequences of adolescent
30
pregnancy, as well as the advantages of adoption, including
31
the adoption of special needs children, and the processes
32
involved in making an adoption plan;
33
(5) Teach skills of conflict management, personal
34
responsibility and positive self-esteem through discussion
35
and role-playing at appropriate grade levels to emphasize
36
that the pupil has the power to control personal behavior.
37
Pupils shall be encouraged to base their actions on
38
reasoning, self-discipline, sense of responsibility, self-
39
control, and ethical considerations, such as respect for
40
one's self and others. Pupils shall be taught not to make
41
unwanted physical and verbal sexual advances or otherwise
42
exploit another person. Pupils shall be taught to resist
43
unwanted sexual advances and other negative peer pressure;
44
(6) Advise pupils of the laws pertaining to their
45
financial responsibility to children born in and out of
46
wedlock and advise pupils of the provisions of chapter 566
47
pertaining to statutory rape;
48
(7) Teach pupils about the dangers of sexual
49
predators, including online predators when using electronic
50
communication methods such as the internet, cell phones,
51
text messages, chat rooms, email, and instant messaging
52
programs. Pupils shall be taught how to behave responsibly
53
and remain safe on the internet and the importance of having
54
SB 699
5
open communication with responsible adults and reporting any
55
inappropriate situation, activity, or abuse to a responsible
56
adult, and depending on intent and content, to local law
57
enforcement, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, or the
58
National Center for Missing & Exploited Children's
59
CyberTipline;
60
(8) Teach pupils about the consequences, both personal
61
and legal, of inappropriate text messaging, even among
62
friends; and
63
(9) Teach pupils about sexual harassment, sexual
64
violence, and consent:
65
(a) For the purposes of this subdivision, the term
66
"consent" shall mean a freely given agreement to the conduct
67
at issue by a competent person. An expression of lack of
68
consent through words or conduct means there is no consent.
69
Lack of verbal or physical resistance or submission
70
resulting from the use of force, threat of force, or placing
71
another person in fear does not constitute consent. A
72
current or previous dating or social or sexual relationship
73
by itself or the manner of dress of the person involved with
74
the accused in the conduct at issue shall not constitute
75
consent;
76
(b) For the purposes of this subdivision, the term
77
"sexual harassment" shall mean uninvited and unwelcome
78
verbal or physical behavior of a sexual nature especially by
79
a person in authority toward a subordinate;
80
(c) For the purposes of this subdivision, the term
81
"sexual violence" shall mean causing or attempting to cause
82
another to engage involuntarily in any sexual act by force,
83
threat of force, duress, or without that person's consent.
84
2. Policies concerning referrals and parental
85
notification regarding contraception shall be determined by
86
SB 699
6
local school boards or charter schools, consistent with the
87
provisions of section 167.611.
88
3. A school district or charter school which provides
89
human sexuality instruction may separate students according
90
to gender for instructional purposes.
91
4. The board of a school district or charter school
92
shall determine the specific content of the district's or
93
school's instruction in human sexuality, in accordance with
94
subsections 1 to 3 of this section, and shall ensure that
95
all instruction in human sexuality is appropriate to the age
96
of the students receiving such instruction.
97
5. Before providing any course materials and
98
instruction relating to human sexuality and sexually
99
transmitted diseases to any student, regardless of the
100
course title or description, a school district or charter
101
school shall notify the parent or legal guardian of each
102
student enrolled in the district or school of[:
103
(1)] the basic content of the district's or school's
104
human sexuality and sexually transmitted diseases course
105
materials and instruction to be provided to the student[; and
106
(2) The parent's right to remove]. After receipt of
107
such basic content, the parent or legal guardian of each
108
student shall indicate in writing whether the parent or
109
legal guardian desires to allow the district or school to
110
include the student [from] in any part of the district's or
111
school's human sexuality and sexually transmitted diseases
112
course materials and instruction. No school shall provide
113
any course materials and instruction relating to human
114
sexuality and sexually transmitted diseases to a student
115
until the district or school has received such written
116
indication from the student's parent or legal guardian that
117
SB 699
7
the student may receive such course materials and
118
instruction.
119
6. A school district or charter school shall make all
120
curriculum materials used in the district's or school's
121
human sexuality instruction available for public inspection
122
pursuant to chapter 610 prior to the use of such materials
123
in actual instruction.
124
[7. No school district or charter school, or its
125
personnel or agents, shall provide abortion services, or
126
permit a person or entity to offer, sponsor, or furnish in
127
any manner any course materials or instruction relating to
128
human sexuality or sexually transmitted diseases to its
129
students if such person or entity is a provider of abortion
130
services.
131
8. As used in this section, the following terms mean:
132
(1) "Abortion", the same meaning as such term is
133
defined in section 188.015;
134
(2) "Abortion services":
135
(a) Performing, inducing, or assisting in the
136
performance or inducing of an abortion which is not
137
necessary to save the life of the mother;
138
(b) Encouraging a patient to have an abortion or
139
referring a patient for an abortion, which is not necessary
140
to save the life of the mother; or
141
(c) Developing or dispensing drugs, chemicals, or
142
devices intended to be used to induce an abortion which is
143
not necessary to save the life of the mother.]
144
7. (1) Violation of this section is a class C
145
misdemeanor.
146
(2) In any legal proceeding related to a violation of
147
this section, no entity directly or indirectly receiving any
148
taxpayer funds shall provide any legal advice, counsel, or
149
SB 699
8
representation to any person or entity that violates this
150
section.
151
188.010. In recognition that Almighty God is the
1
author of life, that all men and women are "endowed by their
2
Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these
3
are Life", and that Article I, Section 2 of the Constitution
4
of Missouri provides that all persons have a natural right
5
to life, it is the intention of the general assembly of the
6
state of Missouri to:
7
(1) Defend the right to life of all humans, born and
8
unborn;
9
(2) Declare that the state and all of its political
10
subdivisions are a "sanctuary of life" that protects
11
pregnant women and their unborn children; and
12
(3) [Regulate] Abolish abortion [to the full extent
13
permitted by the Constitution of the United States,
14
decisions of the United States Supreme Court, and federal
15
statutes] in this state.
16
188.015. As used in this chapter, the following terms
1
mean:
2
(1) "Abortion":
3
(a) The act of using or prescribing any instrument,
4
device, medicine, drug, or any other means or substance with
5
the intent to destroy the life of an embryo or fetus in his
6
or her mother's womb; or
7
(b) The intentional termination of the pregnancy of a
8
mother by using or prescribing any instrument, device,
9
medicine, drug, or other means or substance with an
10
intention other than to increase the probability of a live
11
birth or to remove a dead unborn child;
12
SB 699
9
(2) ["Abortion facility", a clinic, physician's
13
office, or any other place or facility in which abortions
14
are performed or induced other than a hospital;
15
(3)] "Conception", the fertilization of the ovum of a
16
female by a sperm of a male;
17
[(4) "Department", the department of health and senior
18
services;
19
(5) "Down Syndrome", the same meaning as defined in
20
section 191.923;
21
(6) "Gestational age", length of pregnancy as measured
22
from the first day of the woman's last menstrual period;
23
(7)] (3) "Medical emergency", a condition which, based
24
on reasonable medical judgment, so complicates the medical
25
condition of a pregnant woman as to necessitate the
26
immediate abortion of her pregnancy to avert the death of
27
the pregnant woman or for which a delay will create a
28
serious risk of substantial and irreversible physical
29
impairment of a major bodily function of the pregnant woman;
30
[(8) "Physician", any person licensed to practice
31
medicine in this state by the state board of registration
32
for the healing arts;
33
(9) "Reasonable medical judgment", a medical judgment
34
that would be made by a reasonably prudent physician,
35
knowledgeable about the case and the treatment possibilities
36
with respect to the medical conditions involved;
37
(10)] (4) "Unborn child", the offspring of human
38
beings from the moment of conception until birth and at
39
every stage of its biological development, including the
40
human conceptus, zygote, morula, blastocyst, embryo, and
41
fetus[;
42
(11) "Viability" or "viable", that stage of fetal
43
development when the life of the unborn child may be
44
SB 699
10
continued indefinitely outside the womb by natural or
45
artificial life-supportive systems;
46
(12) "Viable pregnancy" or "viable intrauterine
47
pregnancy", in the first trimester of pregnancy, an
48
intrauterine pregnancy that can potentially result in a
49
liveborn baby].
50
188.020. No person shall perform or induce an abortion
1
[except a physician].
2
188.023. Any licensed health care professional who
1
delivers a baby [or performs an abortion], who has prima
2
facie evidence that a patient has been the victim of
3
statutory rape in the first degree or statutory rape in the
4
second degree, or if the patient is under the age of
5
eighteen, that [he or she] the patient has been a victim of
6
sexual abuse, including rape in the first or second degree,
7
or incest, shall be required to report such offenses in the
8
same manner as provided for by section 210.115.
9
188.125. 1. It is the intent of the general assembly
1
to acknowledge the right of an alternatives to abortion
2
agency to operate freely and engage in speech without
3
governmental interference as protected by the Constitution
4
of the United States and the Constitution and laws of
5
Missouri, the right of a person not to be compelled by the
6
government to participate in abortion contrary to his, her,
7
or its religious beliefs or moral convictions, and that the
8
Constitution of the United States and the Constitution and
9
laws of Missouri shall be interpreted, construed, applied,
10
and enforced to fully protect such rights.
11
2. A political subdivision of this state is preempted
12
from enacting, adopting, maintaining, or enforcing any
13
order, ordinance, rule, regulation, policy, or other similar
14
measure that prohibits, restricts, limits, controls,
15
SB 699
11
directs, interferes with, or otherwise adversely affects an
16
alternatives to abortion agency or its officers', agents',
17
employees', or volunteers' operations or speech including,
18
but not limited to, counseling, referrals, or education of,
19
advertising or information to, or other communications with,
20
clients, patients, other persons, or the public.
21
3. Nothing in subsection 2 of this section shall
22
preclude or preempt a political subdivision of this state
23
from exercising its lawful authority to regulate zoning or
24
land use or to enforce a building or fire code regulation;
25
provided that, such political subdivision treats an
26
alternatives to abortion agency in the same manner as a
27
similarly situated agency and that such authority is not
28
used to circumvent the intent of subsection 2 of this
29
section.
30
4. [A political subdivision of this state is preempted
31
from enacting, adopting, maintaining, or enforcing any
32
order, ordinance, rule, regulation, policy, or other similar
33
measure that has the purpose or effect of requiring a person
34
to directly or indirectly participate in abortion if such
35
participation is contrary to the religious beliefs or moral
36
convictions of such person.
37
5. A political subdivision of this state is preempted
38
from enacting, adopting, maintaining, or enforcing any
39
order, ordinance, rule, regulation, policy, or other similar
40
measure requiring a real estate broker, real estate
41
salesperson, real estate broker-salesperson, appraisal firm,
42
appraiser, as such terms are defined in chapter 339, a
43
property owner, or any other person to buy, sell, exchange,
44
purchase, rent, lease, advertise for, or otherwise conduct
45
real estate transactions for, to, or with an abortion
46
facility or for, to, or with a person for the purpose of
47
SB 699
12
performing or inducing an abortion not necessary to save the
48
life of the mother, if such requirement is contrary to the
49
religious beliefs or moral convictions of such real estate
50
broker, real estate salesperson, real estate broker-
51
salesperson, appraisal firm, appraiser, property owner, or
52
other person.
53
6. A political subdivision of this state is preempted
54
from enacting, adopting, maintaining, or enforcing any
55
order, ordinance, rule, regulation, policy, or other similar
56
measure requiring an employer, employee, health plan
57
provider, health plan sponsor, health care provider, or any
58
other person to provide coverage for or to participate in a
59
health plan that includes benefits that are not otherwise
60
required by state law.
61
7. In any action to enforce the provisions of this
62
section, a court of competent jurisdiction may order
63
injunctive or other equitable relief, recovery of damages or
64
other legal remedies, or both, as well as payment of
65
reasonable attorney's fees, costs, and expenses. The relief
66
and remedies set forth shall not be deemed exclusive and
67
shall be in addition to any other relief or remedies
68
permitted by law.
69
8.] In addition to a private cause of action by a
70
person whose rights are violated contrary to the provisions
71
of this section, the attorney general is also authorized to
72
bring a cause of action to defend the rights guaranteed
73
under this section.
74
[9.] 5. Nothing in this section shall be construed to
75
prohibit a political subdivision from enacting, adopting,
76
maintaining, or enforcing any order, ordinance, rule,
77
regulation, policy, or other similar measure to assist
78
pregnant women to carry their unborn children to term or to
79
SB 699
13
assist women in caring for their dependent children or
80
placing their children for adoption including, but not
81
limited to, by funding or otherwise assisting an
82
alternatives to abortion agency to provide services to such
83
women and children.
84
6. An employee of an alternatives to abortion agency
85
shall not voluntarily disclose information communicated to
86
the employee relating to and in connection with an
87
individual who has presented themselves to the agency for
88
the purpose of seeking an alternative to an abortion, except
89
by permission of the individual. The information shall be
90
considered privileged and confidential; provided, that such
91
information may be shared with other employees of the agency
92
for purposes of providing services to that individual.
93
[10.] 7. As used in this section, [the following terms
94
mean:
95
(1)] "alternatives to abortion agency" shall mean:
96
(a) A maternity home as defined in section 135.600;
97
(b) A pregnancy resource center as defined in section
98
135.630; or
99
(c) An agency or entity that has the primary purpose
100
of providing services or counseling to pregnant women to
101
assist such women in carrying their unborn children to term
102
instead of having abortions and to assist such women in
103
caring for their dependent children or placing their
104
children for adoption, as described in section 188.325,
105
regardless of whether such agency or entity is receiving
106
funding or reimbursement from the state for such purposes[;
107
(2) "Participate in abortion":
108
(a) To undergo an abortion; or
109
(b) To perform or induce, assist in, refer or counsel
110
for, advocate for, promote, procure, reimburse for, or
111
SB 699
14
provide health plan coverage for an abortion not necessary
112
to save the life of the mother].
113
191.211. State expenditures for new programs and
1
initiatives enacted by sections 103.178, 143.999, [188.230,]
2
191.231, 191.825 to 191.839, 208.177, 208.178, 208.179 and
3
208.181, 211.490, 285.240, 337.093, 374.126, 376.891 to
4
376.894, 431.064, 660.016, 660.017 and 660.018, and the
5
state expenditures for the new initiatives and expansion of
6
programs enacted by revising sections 105.711 and 105.721,
7
191.520, 191.600, 198.090, 208.151, 208.152 and 208.215, as
8
provided by H.B. 564, 1993, shall be funded exclusively by
9
federal funds and the funding sources established in
10
sections 149.011, 149.015, 149.035, 149.061, 149.065,
11
149.160, 149.170, 149.180, 149.190 and 149.192, and no
12
future general revenue shall be appropriated to fund such
13
new programs or expansions.
14
191.320. The department may contract with tertiary
1
genetic centers to provide genetic diagnostic and counseling
2
services, to initiate and conduct investigations of the
3
causes, mortality, methods of treatment, prevention and cure
4
of genetic disorders and related birth defects, and to
5
develop and administer programs and activities which aid in
6
the prevention or treatment of a particular genetic
7
disorder. It may establish outreach clinics to be located
8
throughout the state. The department may divide the state
9
into regions for this purpose. The boundaries of such
10
regions, to the extent practicable, shall be contiguous with
11
relevant boundaries of political subdivisions and health
12
service areas. These centers and clinics may provide
13
genetic diagnostic evaluations, treatment, counseling and
14
follow-up for families with or at high risk for a genetic
15
disease, such as sickle cell anemia, cystic fibrosis,
16
SB 699
15
inherited cardiovascular disease, inherited forms of mental
17
retardations, or hemophilia, provided that such evaluations,
18
treatment, and counseling shall not include referral for
19
abortions [unless such abortions are certified in writing by
20
a physician that, in his professional judgment, the life of
21
the mother would be endangered if the fetus were carried to
22
term].
23
191.724. 1. The rights guaranteed under this section
1
are in addition to the rights guaranteed under section
2
376.805, relating to health plan coverage of abortion, and
3
section 376.1199, relating to health plan coverage of
4
certain obstetrical and gynecological benefits and
5
pharmaceutical coverage.
6
2. No employee, self-employed person, or any other
7
person shall be compelled to obtain coverage for, or be
8
discriminated against or penalized for declining or refusing
9
coverage for, [abortion,] contraception[,] or sterilization
10
in a health plan if such items or procedures are contrary to
11
the religious beliefs or moral convictions of such employee
12
or person.
13
3. No employer, health plan provider, health plan
14
sponsor, health care provider, or any other person or entity
15
shall be compelled to provide coverage for, or be
16
discriminated against or penalized for declining or refusing
17
coverage for, [abortion,] contraception[,] or sterilization
18
in a health plan if such items or procedures are contrary to
19
the religious beliefs or moral convictions of such employer,
20
health plan provider, health plan sponsor, health care
21
provider, person, or entity.
22
4. No governmental entity, public official, or entity
23
acting in a governmental capacity shall discriminate against
24
or penalize an employee, self-employed person, employer,
25
SB 699
16
health plan provider, health plan sponsor, health care
26
provider, or any other person or entity because of such
27
employee's, self-employed person's, employer's, health plan
28
provider's, health plan sponsor's, health care provider's,
29
or other person's or entity's unwillingness, based on
30
religious beliefs or moral convictions, to obtain or provide
31
coverage for, pay for, participate in, or refer for,
32
[abortion,] contraception[,] or sterilization in a health
33
plan.
34
5. Whenever the attorney general has a reasonable
35
cause to believe that any person or entity or group of
36
persons or entities is being, has been, or is threatened to
37
be denied any of the rights granted by this section or other
38
law that protects the religious beliefs or moral convictions
39
of such persons or entities, and such denial raises an issue
40
of general public importance, the attorney general may bring
41
a civil action in any appropriate state or federal court.
42
Such complaint shall set forth the facts and request such
43
appropriate relief, including but not limited to an
44
application for a permanent or temporary injunction,
45
restraining order, mandamus, an order under the federal
46
Administrative Procedure Act, Religious Freedom Restoration
47
Act, or other federal law, an order under section 1.302
48
relating to free exercise of religion, or other order
49
against the governmental entity, public official, or entity
50
acting in a governmental capacity responsible for such
51
denial or threatened denial of rights, as the attorney
52
general deems necessary to ensure the full enjoyment of the
53
rights granted by law. Nothing contained herein shall
54
preclude a private cause of action against a governmental
55
entity, public official, or entity acting in a governmental
56
capacity by any person or entity or group of persons or
57
SB 699
17
entities aggrieved by a violation of this section or other
58
law that protects the religious beliefs or moral convictions
59
of such persons or entities, or be considered a limitation
60
on any other remedy permitted by law. A court may order any
61
appropriate relief, including recovery of damages, payment
62
of reasonable attorney's fees, costs, and expenses.
63
6. For purposes of this section, "sterilization" shall
64
mean any elective medical procedure for which the sole
65
purpose is to make an individual incapable of reproduction.
66
191.831. 1. There is hereby established in the state
1
treasury a "Health Initiatives Fund", to which shall be
2
deposited all revenues designated for the fund under
3
subsection 8 of section 149.015, and subsection 3 of section
4
149.160, and section 167.609, and all other funds donated to
5
the fund or otherwise deposited pursuant to law. The state
6
treasurer shall administer the fund. Money in the fund
7
shall be appropriated to provide funding for implementing
8
the new programs and initiatives established by sections
9
105.711 and 105.721. The moneys in the fund may further be
10
used to fund those programs established by sections 191.411,
11
191.520 and 191.600, sections 208.151 and 208.152, and
12
sections 103.178, 143.999, 167.600 to 167.621, [188.230,]
13
191.211, 191.231, 191.825 to 191.839, 192.013, 208.177,
14
208.178, 208.179 and 208.181, 211.490, 285.240, 337.093,
15
374.126, 376.891 to 376.894, 431.064, 660.016, 660.017 and
16
660.018; in addition, not less than fifteen percent of the
17
proceeds deposited to the health initiative fund pursuant to
18
sections 149.015 and 149.160 shall be appropriated annually
19
to provide funding for the C-STAR substance abuse
20
rehabilitation program of the department of mental health,
21
or its successor program, and a C-STAR pilot project
22
developed by the director of the division of alcohol and
23
SB 699
18
drug abuse and the director of the department of corrections
24
as an alternative to incarceration, as provided in
25
subsections 2, 3, and 4 of this section. Such pilot project
26
shall be known as the "Alt-care" program. In addition, some
27
of the proceeds deposited to the health initiatives fund
28
pursuant to sections 149.015 and 149.160 shall be
29
appropriated annually to the division of alcohol and drug
30
abuse of the department of mental health to be used for the
31
administration and oversight of the substance abuse traffic
32
offenders program defined in section 302.010 and section
33
577.001. The provisions of section 33.080 to the contrary
34
notwithstanding, money in the health initiatives fund shall
35
not be transferred at the close of the biennium to the
36
general revenue fund.
37
2. The director of the division of alcohol and drug
38
abuse and the director of the department of corrections
39
shall develop and administer a pilot project to provide a
40
comprehensive substance abuse treatment and rehabilitation
41
program as an alternative to incarceration, hereinafter
42
referred to as "Alt-care". Alt-care shall be funded using
43
money provided under subsection 1 of this section through
44
the Missouri Medicaid program, the C-STAR program of the
45
department of mental health, and the division of alcohol and
46
drug abuse's purchase-of-service system. Alt-care shall
47
offer a flexible combination of clinical services and living
48
arrangements individually adapted to each client and her
49
children. Alt-care shall consist of the following
50
components:
51
(1) Assessment and treatment planning;
52
(2) Community support to provide continuity,
53
monitoring of progress and access to services and resources;
54
(3) Counseling from individual to family therapy;
55
SB 699
19
(4) Day treatment services which include accessibility
56
seven days per week, transportation to and from the Alt-care
57
program, weekly drug testing, leisure activities, weekly
58
events for families and companions, job and education
59
preparedness training, peer support and self-help and daily
60
living skills; and
61
(5) Living arrangement options which are permanent,
62
substance-free and conducive to treatment and recovery.
63
3. Any female who is pregnant or is the custodial
64
parent of a child or children under the age of twelve years,
65
and who has pleaded guilty to or found guilty of violating
66
the provisions of chapter 195, and whose controlled
67
substance abuse was a precipitating or contributing factor
68
in the commission of the offense, and who is placed on
69
probation may be required, as a condition of probation, to
70
participate in Alt-care, if space is available in the pilot
71
project area. Determinations of eligibility for the
72
program, placement, and continued participation shall be
73
made by the division of alcohol and drug abuse, in
74
consultation with the department of corrections.
75
4. The availability of space in Alt-care shall be
76
determined by the director of the division of alcohol and
77
drug abuse in conjunction with the director of the
78
department of corrections. If the sentencing court is
79
advised that there is no space available, the court shall
80
consider other authorized dispositions.
81
191.923. 1. The general assembly of the state of
1
Missouri hereby finds and declares that pregnant women who
2
choose to undergo prenatal screening should have access to
3
timely and informative counseling about the conditions being
4
tested for, the accuracy of such tests, and resources for
5
obtaining support services for such conditions. Informed
6
SB 699
20
consent is a critical component of all genetic testing and
7
prenatal screening[, particularly as the results of such
8
testing or screening and the counseling that follows may
9
lead to the unnecessary abortion of unborn humans with Down
10
Syndrome or other prenatally diagnosed conditions].
11
2. As used in this section, the following terms shall
12
mean:
13
(1) "Down Syndrome", a chromosomal disorder caused by
14
an error in cell division that results in the presence of an
15
extra whole or partial copy of chromosome 21;
16
(2) "Health care provider", any person or entity
17
licensed, accredited, or certified by the state of Missouri
18
to perform specified health services;
19
(3) "Prenatally diagnosed condition", any adverse
20
fetal health condition identified by prenatal genetic
21
testing or indicated by prenatal screening procedures;
22
(4) "Prenatal test", a diagnostic procedure or
23
screening procedure performed upon a pregnant woman or her
24
unborn offspring to obtain information about her offspring's
25
health or development.
26
3. When a prenatally diagnosed condition, including
27
but not limited to Down Syndrome, becomes known as a result
28
of one or more prenatal tests, the physician or other health
29
care professional who requested or ordered prenatal tests,
30
or his or her designee, shall provide the patient with
31
current information about the conditions that were tested
32
for, the accuracy of such tests, and resources for obtaining
33
support services for such conditions, including information
34
hotlines specific to Down Syndrome or other prenatally
35
diagnosed conditions, resource centers, and clearinghouses
36
for such conditions, support programs for parents and
37
SB 699
21
families, and the alternatives to abortion services program
38
under section 188.325.
39
4. The department of health and senior services shall
40
establish a clearinghouse of information concerning
41
supportive services providers, information hotlines specific
42
to Down Syndrome or other prenatally diagnosed conditions,
43
resource centers, education, other support programs for
44
parents and families, and the alternatives to abortion
45
services program under section 188.325.
46
191.975. 1. This section shall be known and may be
1
cited as the "Adoption Awareness Law".
2
2. To raise public awareness and to educate the
3
public, the department of social services, with the
4
assistance of the department of health and senior services,
5
shall be responsible for:
6
(1) Collecting and distributing resource materials to
7
educate the public about foster care and adoption;
8
(2) Developing and distributing educational materials,
9
including but not limited to videos, brochures and other
10
media as part of a comprehensive public relations campaign
11
about the positive option of adoption and foster care. The
12
materials shall include, but not be limited to, information
13
about:
14
(a) The benefits of adoption and foster care;
15
(b) Adoption and foster care procedures;
16
(c) Means of financing the cost of adoption and foster
17
care including, but not limited to, adoption subsidies,
18
foster care payments, and adoption tax credits;
19
(d) Options for birth parents in choosing adoptive
20
parents;
21
(e) Protection for and rights of birth parents and
22
adoptive parents prior to and following the adoption;
23
SB 699
22
(f) Location of adoption and foster care agencies;
24
(g) Information regarding various state health and
25
social service programs for pregnant women and children,
26
including but not limited to medical assistance programs and
27
temporary assistance for needy families (TANF); and
28
(h) Referrals to appropriate counseling services,
29
including but not be limited to counseling services for
30
parents who are considering retaining custody of their
31
children, placing their children for adoption, or becoming
32
foster or adoptive parents[; but excluding any referrals for
33
abortion or to abortion facilities];
34
(3) Making such educational materials available
35
through state and local public health clinics, public
36
hospitals, family planning clinics, [abortion facilities as
37
defined in section 188.015,] maternity homes as defined in
38
section 135.600, child-placing agencies licensed pursuant to
39
sections 210.481 to 210.536, attorneys whose practice
40
involves private adoptions, in vitro fertilization clinics
41
and private physicians for distribution to their patients
42
who request such educational materials. Such materials
43
shall also be available to the public through the department
44
of social services' internet website;
45
(4) Establishing a toll-free telephone number for
46
information on adoption and foster care, and to answer
47
questions and assist persons inquiring about becoming
48
adoptive or foster parents.
49
3. In addition, the department may establish and
50
implement an ongoing advertising campaign for the
51
recruitment of adoptive and foster care families, with a
52
special emphasis on the recruitment of qualified adoptive
53
and foster care families for special needs children. Such
54
advertising campaign may utilize, but shall not be limited
55
SB 699
23
to, the following media: television, radio, outdoor
56
advertising, newspaper, magazines and other print media,
57
websites, and the internet. The department may contract
58
with professional advertising agencies or other professional
59
entities to conduct such advertising campaign on behalf of
60
the department.
61
4. The provisions of this section shall be subject to
62
appropriations.
63
5. The department of social services shall promulgate
64
rules for the implementation of this section in accordance
65
with chapter 536.
66
192.665. As used in this section, section 192.667, and
1
sections 197.150 to 197.165, the following terms mean:
2
(1) "Charge data", information submitted by health
3
care providers on current charges for leading procedures and
4
diagnoses;
5
(2) "Charges by payer", information submitted by
6
hospitals on amount billed to Medicare, Medicaid, other
7
government sources and all nongovernment sources combined as
8
one data element;
9
(3) "Department", the department of health and senior
10
services;
11
(4) "Financial data", information submitted by
12
hospitals drawn from financial statements which includes the
13
balance sheet, income statement, charity care and bad debt
14
and charges by payer, prepared in accordance with generally
15
accepted accounting principles;
16
(5) "Health care provider", hospitals as defined in
17
section 197.020 and ambulatory surgical centers [and
18
abortion facilities] as defined in section 197.200;
19
(6) "Nosocomial infection", as defined by the federal
20
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and applied to
21
SB 699
24
infections within hospitals, ambulatory surgical centers,
22
abortion facilities, and other facilities;
23
(7) "Nosocomial infection incidence rate", a risk-
24
adjusted measurement of new cases of nosocomial infections
25
by procedure or device within a population over a given
26
period of time, with such measurements defined by rule of
27
the department pursuant to subsection 3 of section 192.667
28
for use by all hospitals, ambulatory surgical centers,
29
[abortion facilities,] and other facilities in complying
30
with the requirements of the Missouri nosocomial infection
31
control act of 2004;
32
(8) "Other facility", a type of facility determined to
33
be a source of infections and designated by rule of the
34
department pursuant to subsection 11 of section 192.667;
35
(9) "Patient abstract data", data submitted by
36
hospitals which includes but is not limited to date of
37
birth, sex, race, zip code, county of residence, admission
38
date, discharge date, principal and other diagnoses,
39
including external causes, principal and other procedures,
40
procedure dates, total billed charges, disposition of the
41
patient and expected source of payment with sources
42
categorized according to Medicare, Medicaid, other
43
government, workers' compensation, all commercial payors
44
coded with a common code, self-pay, no charge and other.
45
192.667. 1. All health care providers shall at least
1
annually provide to the department charge data as required
2
by the department. All hospitals shall at least annually
3
provide patient abstract data and financial data as required
4
by the department. Hospitals as defined in section 197.020
5
shall report patient abstract data for outpatients and
6
inpatients. Ambulatory surgical centers [and abortion
7
facilities] as defined in section 197.200 shall provide
8
SB 699
25
patient abstract data to the department. The department
9
shall specify by rule the types of information which shall
10
be submitted and the method of submission.
11
2. The department shall collect data on the incidence
12
of health care-associated infections from hospitals,
13
ambulatory surgical centers, [abortion facilities,] and
14
other facilities as necessary to generate the reports
15
required by this section. Hospitals, ambulatory surgical
16
centers, [abortion facilities,] and other facilities shall
17
provide such data in compliance with this section. In order
18
to streamline government and to eliminate duplicative
19
reporting requirements, if the Centers for Medicare and
20
Medicaid Services, or its successor entity, requires
21
hospitals to submit health care-associated infection data,
22
then hospitals and the department shall not be required to
23
comply with the health care-associated infection data
24
reporting requirements of subsections 2 to 17 of this
25
section applicable to hospitals, except that the department
26
shall post a link on its website to publicly reported data
27
by hospitals on the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid
28
Services' Hospital Compare website, or its successor.
29
3. The department shall promulgate rules specifying
30
the standards and procedures for the collection, analysis,
31
risk adjustment, and reporting of the incidence of health
32
care-associated infections and the types of infections and
33
procedures to be monitored pursuant to subsection 13 of this
34
section. In promulgating such rules, the department shall:
35
(1) Use methodologies and systems for data collection
36
established by the federal Centers for Disease Control and
37
Prevention's National Healthcare Safety Network, or its
38
successor; and
39
SB 699
26
(2) Consider the findings and recommendations of the
40
infection control advisory panel established pursuant to
41
section 197.165.
42
4. By January 1, 2017, the infection control advisory
43
panel created by section 197.165 shall make recommendations
44
to the department regarding the Centers for Medicare and
45
Medicaid Services' health care-associated infection data
46
collection, analysis, and public reporting requirements for
47
hospitals, ambulatory surgical centers, and other facilities
48
in the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's
49
National Healthcare Safety Network, or its successor, in
50
lieu of all or part of the data collection, analysis, and
51
public reporting requirements of this section. The advisory
52
panel recommendations shall address which hospitals shall be
53
required as a condition of licensure to use the National
54
Healthcare Safety Network for data collection; the use of
55
the National Healthcare Safety Network for risk adjustment
56
and analysis of hospital submitted data; and the use of the
57
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services' Hospital Compare
58
website, or its successor, for public reporting of the
59
incidence of health care-associated infection metrics. The
60
advisory panel shall consider the following factors in
61
developing its recommendation:
62
(1) Whether the public is afforded the same or greater
63
access to facility-specific infection control indicators and
64
metrics;
65
(2) Whether the data provided to the public is subject
66
to the same or greater accuracy of risk adjustment;
67
(3) Whether the public is provided with the same or
68
greater specificity of reporting of infections by type of
69
facility infections and procedures;
70
SB 699
27
(4) Whether the data is subject to the same or greater
71
level of confidentiality of the identity of an individual
72
patient;
73
(5) Whether the National Healthcare Safety Network, or
74
its successor, has the capacity to receive, analyze, and
75
report the required data for all facilities;
76
(6) Whether the cost to implement the National
77
Healthcare Safety Network infection data collection and
78
reporting system is the same or less.
79
5. After considering the recommendations of the
80
infection control advisory panel, and provided that the
81
requirements of subsection 13 of this section can be met,
82
the department shall implement guidelines from the federal
83
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's National
84
Healthcare Safety Network, or its successor. It shall be a
85
condition of licensure for hospitals that meet the minimum
86
public reporting requirements of the National Healthcare
87
Safety Network and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid
88
Services to participate in the National Healthcare Safety
89
Network, or its successor. Such hospitals shall permit the
90
National Healthcare Safety Network, or its successor, to
91
disclose facility-specific infection data to the department
92
as required under this section, and as necessary to provide
93
the public reports required by the department. It shall be
94
a condition of licensure for any ambulatory surgical center
95
[or abortion facility] which does not voluntarily
96
participate in the National Healthcare Safety Network, or
97
its successor, to submit facility-specific data to the
98
department as required under this section, and as necessary
99
to provide the public reports required by the department.
100
6. The department shall not require the resubmission
101
of data which has been submitted to the department of health
102
SB 699
28
and senior services or the department of social services
103
under any other provision of law. The department of health
104
and senior services shall accept data submitted by
105
associations or related organizations on behalf of health
106
care providers by entering into binding agreements
107
negotiated with such associations or related organizations
108
to obtain data required pursuant to section 192.665 and this
109
section. A health care provider shall submit the required
110
information to the department of health and senior services:
111
(1) If the provider does not submit the required data
112
through such associations or related organizations;
113
(2) If no binding agreement has been reached within
114
ninety days of August 28, 1992, between the department of
115
health and senior services and such associations or related
116
organizations; or
117
(3) If a binding agreement has expired for more than
118
ninety days.
119
7. Information obtained by the department under the
120
provisions of section 192.665 and this section shall not be
121
public information. Reports and studies prepared by the
122
department based upon such information shall be public
123
information and may identify individual health care
124
providers. The department of health and senior services may
125
authorize the use of the data by other research
126
organizations pursuant to the provisions of section
127
192.067. The department shall not use or release any
128
information provided under section 192.665 and this section
129
which would enable any person to determine any health care
130
provider's negotiated discounts with specific preferred
131
provider organizations or other managed care organizations.
132
The department shall not release data in a form which could
133
SB 699
29
be used to identify a patient. Any violation of this
134
subsection is a class A misdemeanor.
135
8. The department shall undertake a reasonable number
136
of studies and publish information, including at least an
137
annual consumer guide, in collaboration with health care
138
providers, business coalitions and consumers based upon the
139
information obtained pursuant to the provisions of section
140
192.665 and this section. The department shall allow all
141
health care providers and associations and related
142
organizations who have submitted data which will be used in
143
any publication to review and comment on the publication
144
prior to its publication or release for general use. The
145
publication shall be made available to the public for a
146
reasonable charge.
147
9. Any health care provider which continually and
148
substantially, as these terms are defined by rule, fails to
149
comply with the provisions of this section shall not be
150
allowed to participate in any program administered by the
151
state or to receive any moneys from the state.
152
10. A hospital, as defined in section 197.020,
153
aggrieved by the department's determination of ineligibility
154
for state moneys pursuant to subsection 9 of this section
155
may appeal as provided in section 197.071. An ambulatory
156
surgical center [or abortion facility] as defined in section
157
197.200 aggrieved by the department's determination of
158
ineligibility for state moneys pursuant to subsection 9 of
159
this section may appeal as provided in section 197.221.
160
11. The department of health may promulgate rules
161
providing for collection of data and publication of the
162
incidence of health care-associated infections for other
163
types of health facilities determined to be sources of
164
SB 699
30
infections; except that, physicians' offices shall be exempt
165
from reporting and disclosure of such infections.
166
12. By January 1, 2017, the advisory panel shall
167
recommend and the department shall adopt in regulation with
168
an effective date of no later than January 1, 2018, the
169
requirements for the reporting of the following types of
170
infections as specified in this subsection:
171
(1) Infections associated with a minimum of four
172
surgical procedures for hospitals and a minimum of two
173
surgical procedures for ambulatory surgical centers that
174
meet the following criteria:
175
(a) Are usually associated with an elective surgical
176
procedure. An "elective surgical procedure" is a planned,
177
nonemergency surgical procedure that may be either medically
178
required such as a hip replacement or optional such as
179
breast augmentation;
180
(b) Demonstrate a high priority aspect such as
181
affecting a large number of patients, having a substantial
182
impact for a smaller population, or being associated with
183
substantial cost, morbidity, or mortality; or
184
(c) Are infections for which reports are collected by
185
the National Healthcare Safety Network or its successor;
186
(2) Central line-related bloodstream infections;
187
(3) Health care-associated infections specified for
188
reporting by hospitals, ambulatory surgical centers, and
189
other health care facilities by the rules of the Centers for
190
Medicare and Medicaid Services to the federal Centers for
191
Disease Control and Prevention's National Healthcare Safety
192
Network, or its successor; and
193
(4) Other categories of infections that may be
194
established by rule by the department.
195
SB 699
31
The department, in consultation with the advisory panel,
196
shall be authorized to collect and report data on subsets of
197
each type of infection described in this subsection.
198
13. In consultation with the infection control
199
advisory panel established pursuant to section 197.165, the
200
department shall develop and disseminate to the public
201
reports based on data compiled for a period of twelve
202
months. Such reports shall be updated quarterly and shall
203
show for each hospital, ambulatory surgical center,
204
[abortion facility,] and other facility metrics on risk-
205
adjusted health care-associated infections under this
206
section.
207
14. The types of infections under subsection 12 of
208
this section to be publicly reported shall be determined by
209
the department by rule and shall be consistent with the
210
infections tracked by the National Healthcare Safety
211
Network, or its successor.
212
15. Reports published pursuant to subsection 13 of
213
this section shall be published and readily accessible on
214
the department's internet website. The reports shall be
215
distributed at least annually to the governor and members of
216
the general assembly. The department shall make such
217
reports available to the public for a period of at least two
218
years.
219
16. The Hospital Industry Data Institute shall publish
220
a report of Missouri hospitals'[,] and ambulatory surgical
221
centers'[, and abortion facilities'] compliance with
222
standardized quality of care measures established by the
223
federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services for
224
prevention of infections related to surgical procedures. If
225
the Hospital Industry Data Institute fails to do so by July
226
31, 2008, and annually thereafter, the department shall be
227
SB 699
32
authorized to collect information from the Centers for
228
Medicare and Medicaid Services or from hospitals, ambulatory
229
surgical centers, and abortion facilities and publish such
230
information in accordance with this section.
231
17. The data collected or published pursuant to this
232
section shall be available to the department for purposes of
233
licensing hospitals[,] and ambulatory surgical centers[, and
234
abortion facilities] pursuant to chapter 197.
235
18. The department shall promulgate rules to implement
236
the provisions of section 192.131 and sections 197.150 to
237
197.160. Any rule or portion of a rule, as that term is
238
defined in section 536.010, that is created under the
239
authority delegated in this section shall become effective
240
only if it complies with and is subject to all of the
241
provisions of chapter 536 and, if applicable, section
242
536.028. This section and chapter 536 are nonseverable and
243
if any of the powers vested with the general assembly
244
pursuant to chapter 536 to review, to delay the effective
245
date, or to disapprove and annul a rule are subsequently
246
held unconstitutional, then the grant of rulemaking
247
authority and any rule proposed or adopted after August 28,
248
2004, shall be invalid and void.
249
19. No later than August 28, 2017, each hospital,
250
excluding mental health facilities as defined in section
251
632.005, and each ambulatory surgical center [and abortion
252
facility] as defined in section 197.200, shall in
253
consultation with its medical staff establish an
254
antimicrobial stewardship program for evaluating the
255
judicious use of antimicrobials, especially antibiotics that
256
are the last line of defense against resistant infections.
257
The hospital's stewardship program and the results of the
258
program shall be monitored and evaluated by hospital quality
259
SB 699
33
improvement departments and shall be available upon
260
inspection to the department. At a minimum, the
261
antimicrobial stewardship program shall be designed to
262
evaluate that hospitalized patients receive, in accordance
263
with accepted medical standards of practice, the appropriate
264
antimicrobial, at the appropriate dose, at the appropriate
265
time, and for the appropriate duration.
266
20. Hospitals described in subsection 19 of this
267
section shall meet the National Healthcare Safety Network
268
requirements for reporting antimicrobial usage or resistance
269
by using the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's
270
Antimicrobial Use and Resistance (AUR) Module when
271
conditions of participation promulgated by the Centers for
272
Medicare and Medicaid Services requiring the electronic
273
reporting of antibiotic use or antibiotic resistance by
274
hospitals become effective. When such antimicrobial usage
275
or resistance reporting takes effect, hospitals shall
276
authorize the National Healthcare Safety Network, or its
277
successor, to disclose to the department facility-specific
278
information reported to the AUR Module. Facility-specific
279
data on antibiotic usage and resistance collected under this
280
subsection shall not be disclosed to the public, but the
281
department may release case-specific information to other
282
facilities, physicians, and the public if the department
283
determines on a case-by-case basis that the release of such
284
information is necessary to protect persons in a public
285
health emergency. Nothing in this section shall prohibit a
286
hospital from voluntarily reporting antibiotic use or
287
antibiotic resistance data through the National Healthcare
288
Safety Network, or its successor, prior to the effective
289
date of the conditions of participation requiring the
290
reporting.
291
SB 699
34
21. The department shall make a report to the general
292
assembly beginning January 1, 2018, and on every January
293
first thereafter on the incidence, type, and distribution of
294
antimicrobial-resistant infections identified in the state
295
and within regions of the state.
296
196.1127. 1. The moneys appropriated to the life
1
sciences research board pursuant to sections 196.1100 to
2
196.1124 shall be subject to the provisions of this section.
3
2. As used in this section, the following terms shall
4
mean:
5
(1) ["Abortion services" include performing, inducing,
6
or assisting with abortions, as defined in section 188.015,
7
or encouraging patients to have abortions, referring
8
patients for abortions not necessary to save the life of the
9
mother, or development of drugs, chemicals, or devices
10
intended to be used to induce an abortion;
11
(2)] "Child", a human being recognized as a minor
12
pursuant to the laws of this state, including if in vivo, an
13
unborn child as defined in section 188.015 and if in vitro,
14
a human being at any of the stages of biological development
15
of an unborn child from conception or inception onward;
16
[(3)] (2) "Conception", the same meaning as such term
17
is defined in section 188.015;
18
[(4)] (3) "Facilities and administrative costs", those
19
costs that are incurred for common or joint objectives and
20
therefore cannot be identified readily and specifically with
21
a particular research project or any other institutional
22
activity;
23
[(5)] (4) "Human cloning", the creation of a human
24
being by any means other than by the fertilization of an
25
oocyte of a human female by a sperm of a human male;
26
SB 699
35
[(6)] (5) "Prohibited human research", research in a
27
research project in which there is the taking or utilization
28
of the organs, tissues, or cellular material of:
29
(a) A deceased child, unless consent is given by the
30
parents in a manner provided in sections 194.210 to 194.290
31
relating to anatomical gifts, and neither parent caused the
32
death of such child or consented to another person causing
33
the death of such child;
34
(b) A living child, when the intended or likely result
35
of such taking or utilization is to kill or cause harm to
36
the health, safety, or welfare of such child, or when the
37
purpose is to target such child for possible destruction in
38
the future;
39
[(7)] (6) "Public funds", include:
40
(a) Any moneys received or controlled by the state of
41
Missouri or any official, department, division, agency, or
42
political subdivision thereof, including but not limited to
43
moneys derived from federal, state, or local taxes, gifts,
44
or grants from any source, settlements of any claims or
45
causes of action, public or private, bond proceeds, federal
46
grants or payments, or intergovernmental transfers;
47
(b) Any moneys received or controlled by an official,
48
department, division, or agency of state government or any
49
political subdivision thereof, or to any person or entity
50
pursuant to appropriation by the general assembly or
51
governing body of any political subdivision of this state;
52
[(8)] (7) "Research project", research proposed to be
53
funded by an award of public funds conducted under the
54
auspices of the entity or entities that applied for and
55
received such award, regardless of whether the research is
56
funded in whole or in part by such award. Such research
57
shall include basic research, including the discovery of new
58
SB 699
36
knowledge; translational research, including translational
59
knowledge in a usable form; and clinical research, including
60
but not limited to health research in human development and
61
aging, cancer, endocrine, cardiovascular, neurological,
62
pulmonary, and infectious disease.
63
3. Public funds shall not be expended, paid, or
64
granted to or on behalf of an existing or proposed research
65
project that involves [abortion services,] human cloning[,]
66
or prohibited human research. A research project that
67
receives an award of public funds shall not share costs with
68
another research project, person, or entity not eligible to
69
receive public funds pursuant to this subsection; provided
70
that a research project that receives an award of public
71
funds may pay a pro rata share of facilities and
72
administrative costs determined in the award of public funds
73
according to standards that ensure that public funds do not
74
in any way subsidize facilities and administrative costs of
75
other research projects, persons, or entities not eligible
76
to receive public funds pursuant to this subsection. The
77
application for an award of public funds shall set forth the
78
proposed rates of pro rata cost reimbursement and shall
79
provide supporting data and rationale for such rates. All
80
applicants for and recipients of awards of public funds
81
shall comply with the cost accounting principles set forth
82
in Part 9905 of Title 48 of the Code of Federal Regulations,
83
or successor regulations, in connection with the application
84
for and administration of the research project. All moneys
85
derived from an award of public funds shall be expended only
86
by checks, drafts, or electronic transfers using a separate
87
accounting process maintained for each research project. No
88
moneys derived from an award of public funds shall be used
89
to cover costs for any other research project or to any
90
SB 699
37
other person or entity. No moneys derived from an award of
91
public funds shall be passed through to any other research
92
project, person, or entity unless included in the original
93
application for the award of public funds or in subsequent
94
amendments or requests to use separate contractors. A
95
research project that receives an award of public funds
96
shall maintain financial records that demonstrate strict
97
compliance with this subsection. Any audit conducted
98
pursuant to any grant or contract awarding public funds
99
shall also certify whether there is compliance with this
100
subsection and shall note any noncompliance as a material
101
audit finding.
102
4. The provisions of this section shall inure to the
103
benefit of all residents of this state. Any taxpayer of
104
this state or any political subdivision of this state shall
105
have standing to bring suit against the state of Missouri or
106
any official, department, division, agency, or political
107
subdivision of this state, and any recipient of public funds
108
who or which is in violation of this subsection in any
109
circuit court with jurisdiction to enforce the provisions of
110
this section.
111
5. This section shall not be construed to permit or
112
make lawful any conduct that is otherwise unlawful pursuant
113
to the laws of this state.
114
6. Any provision of this section is not severable from
115
any appropriation subject to this section or any application
116
declared by any court to be subject to this section. If any
117
provision of this section is found to be invalid or
118
unconstitutional, any appropriation subject to this section
119
or any appropriation declared by any court to be subject to
120
this section shall be void, invalid, and unenforceable.
121
SB 699
38
197.150. The department shall require that each
1
hospital, ambulatory surgical center, [abortion facility,]
2
and other facility have in place procedures for monitoring
3
and enforcing compliance with infection control regulations
4
and standards. Such procedures shall be coordinated with
5
administrative staff, personnel staff, and the quality
6
improvement program. Such procedures shall include, at a
7
minimum, requirements for the facility's infection control
8
program to conduct surveillance of personnel with a portion
9
of the surveillance to be done in such manner that employees
10
and medical staff are observed without their knowledge of
11
such observation, provided that this unobserved surveillance
12
requirement shall not be considered to be grounds for
13
licensure enforcement action by the department until the
14
department establishes clear and verifiable criteria for
15
determining compliance. Such surveillance also may include
16
monitoring of the rate of use of hand hygiene products.
17
197.152. 1. Infection control officers as defined in
1
federal regulation and other hospital[,] and ambulatory
2
surgical center[, and abortion facility] employees shall be
3
protected against retaliation by the hospital[,] or
4
ambulatory surgical center[, or abortion facility] for
5
reporting infection control concerns pursuant to section
6
197.285 and shall be entitled to the full benefits of that
7
section. Such infection control officers shall report any
8
interference in the performance of their duties by their
9
supervisors to the hospital[,] or ambulatory surgical
10
center[, or abortion facility] compliance officer
11
established by and empowered to act pursuant to section
12
197.285.
13
2. Infection control officers as defined in federal
14
regulation shall also have the authority to order the
15
SB 699
39
cessation of a practice that falls outside accepted
16
practices as defined by appropriate state and federal
17
regulatory agencies, accreditation organizations, or the
18
standards adopted by the Centers for Disease Control and
19
Prevention or the Association of Professionals in Infection
20
Control and Epidemiology. The hospital[,] or ambulatory
21
surgical center[, or abortion facility] may require that
22
such a cessation order of an infection control officer be
23
endorsed by the hospital[,] or ambulatory surgical center[,
24
or abortion facility] chief executive officer or his or her
25
designee before taking effect. The hospital[,] or
26
ambulatory surgical center[, or abortion facility] infection
27
control committee shall convene as soon as possible to
28
review such cessation order and may overrule or sustain the
29
directive of the infection control officer. The department
30
shall promulgate rules governing documentation of such
31
events.
32
3. Members of the medical staff who report in good
33
faith infection control concerns to the hospital[,] or
34
ambulatory surgical center[, or abortion facility]
35
administration or medical staff leadership shall not be
36
subject to retaliation or discrimination for doing so.
37
Nothing in this section shall prevent or shield medical
38
staff members from being subject to professional review
39
actions for substandard care or breach of standards
40
established in hospital policy, rules, or medical staff
41
bylaws.
42
197.158. Every hospital[,] and ambulatory surgery
1
center[, and abortion facility] shall, beginning June 1,
2
2006, provide each patient an opportunity to submit to the
3
hospital[,] or ambulatory surgical center[, or abortion
4
facility] administration complaints, comments, and
5
SB 699
40
suggestions related to the care they received or their
6
personal observations related to the quality of care
7
provided. The department shall promulgate rules to
8
implement this section.
9
197.160. The department of health and senior services
1
shall have access to all data and information held by
2
hospitals, ambulatory surgical centers, [abortion
3
facilities,] and other facilities related to their infection
4
control practices, rates, or treatments of infections.
5
Failure to provide such access shall be grounds for full or
6
partial licensure suspension or revocation pursuant to
7
section 197.293, sections 197.010 to 197.100, or sections
8
197.200 to 197.240. If the department determines that the
9
hospital, ambulatory surgical center, [abortion facility,]
10
or other facility is willfully impeding access to such
11
information, the department shall be authorized to direct
12
all state agencies to suspend all or a portion of state
13
payments to such entity until such time as the desired
14
information is obtained by the department.
15
197.162. The department shall in its licensure of
1
hospitals[,] and ambulatory surgical centers[, and abortion
2
facilities] give special attention to infection control
3
practices and shall direct hospitals[,] and ambulatory
4
surgical centers[, and abortion facilities] to set
5
quantifiable measures of performance for reducing the
6
incidence of nosocomial infections in Missouri. The
7
department shall prepare an annual report on infection
8
control standards and compliance, which shall be shared with
9
the governor and the general assembly.
10
197.165. 1. The department shall appoint an
1
"Infection Control Advisory Panel" for the purposes of
2
implementing sections 192.131 and 192.667.
3
SB 699
41
2. Members of the infection control advisory panel
4
shall include:
5
(1) Two public members;
6
(2) Three board-certified or board-eligible physicians
7
licensed pursuant to chapter 334 who are affiliated with a
8
Missouri hospital or medical school, active members of the
9
Society for Health Care Epidemiology of America, and have
10
demonstrated interest and expertise in health facility
11
infection control;
12
(3) One physician licensed pursuant to chapter 334 who
13
is active in the practice of medicine in Missouri and who
14
holds medical staff privileges at a Missouri hospital;
15
(4) Four infection control practitioners certified by
16
the certification board of infection control and
17
epidemiology, at least two of whom shall be practicing in a
18
rural hospital or setting and at least two of whom shall be
19
registered professional nurses licensed under chapter 335;
20
(5) A medical statistician with an advanced degree in
21
such specialty;
22
(6) A clinical microbiologist with an advanced degree
23
in such specialty;
24
(7) Three employees of the department, representing
25
the functions of hospital[,] and ambulatory surgical
26
center[, and abortion facility] licensure, epidemiology and
27
health data analysis, who shall serve as ex officio
28
nonvoting members of the panel.
29
3. Reasonable expenses of the panel shall be paid from
30
private donations made specifically for that purpose to the
31
"Infection Control Advisory Panel Fund", which is hereby
32
created in the state treasury. If such donations are not
33
received from private sources, then the provisions of this
34
act shall be implemented without the advisory panel.
35
SB 699
42
197.200. As used in sections 197.200 to 197.240,
1
unless the context clearly indicates otherwise, the
2
following terms mean:
3
(1) ["Abortion facility", as such term is defined in
4
section 188.015;
5
(2)] "Ambulatory surgical center", any public or
6
private establishment operated primarily for the purpose of
7
performing surgical procedures or primarily for the purpose
8
of performing childbirths, and which does not provide
9
services or other accommodations for patients to stay more
10
than twenty-three hours within the establishment, provided,
11
however, that nothing in this definition shall be construed
12
to include the offices of dentists currently licensed
13
pursuant to chapter 332;
14
[(3)] (2) "Dentist", any person currently licensed to
15
practice dentistry pursuant to chapter 332;
16
[(4)] (3) "Department", the department of health and
17
senior services;
18
[(5)] (4) "Governmental unit", any city, county or
19
other political subdivision of this state, or any
20
department, division, board or other agency of any political
21
subdivision of this state;
22
[(6)] (5) "Person", any individual, firm, partnership,
23
corporation, company, or association and the legal
24
successors thereof;
25
[(7)] (6) "Physician", any person currently licensed
26
to practice medicine pursuant to chapter 334;
27
[(8)] (7) "Podiatrist", any person currently licensed
28
to practice podiatry pursuant to chapter 330.
29
197.205. 1. No person or governmental unit acting
1
severally or jointly with any other person or governmental
2
unit shall establish, conduct or maintain an ambulatory
3
SB 699
43
surgical center [or abortion facility] in this state without
4
a license under sections 197.200 to 197.240 issued by the
5
department of health and senior services.
6
2. Nothing in sections 197.200 to 197.240 shall be
7
construed to impair or abridge the authority of a
8
governmental unit to license ambulatory surgical centers [or
9
abortion facilities], provided that any ordinance of a
10
governmental unit shall require compliance with all rules,
11
regulations, and standards adopted by the department to
12
implement the provisions of sections 197.200 to 197.240.
13
197.215. 1. Upon receipt of an application for a
1
license, the department of health and senior services shall
2
issue a license if the applicant and ambulatory surgical
3
center facilities [or abortion facilities] meet the
4
requirements established under sections 197.200 to 197.240,
5
and have provided affirmative evidence that:
6
(1) Each member of the surgical staff is a physician,
7
dentist or podiatrist currently licensed to practice in
8
Missouri[, and each person authorized to perform or induce
9
abortions is a physician currently licensed to practice in
10
Missouri];
11
(2) Surgical procedures in ambulatory surgical centers
12
shall be performed only by physicians, dentists or
13
podiatrists, who at the time are privileged to perform
14
surgical procedures in at least one licensed hospital in the
15
community in which the ambulatory surgical center is
16
located, thus providing assurance to the public that
17
patients treated in the center shall receive continuity of
18
care should the services of a hospital be required;
19
alternatively, applicant shall submit a copy of a current
20
working agreement with at least one licensed hospital in the
21
community in which the ambulatory surgical center is
22
SB 699
44
located, guaranteeing the transfer and admittance of
23
patients for emergency treatment whenever necessary;
24
(3) Continuous physician services or registered
25
professional nursing services are provided whenever a
26
patient is in the facility;
27
(4) Adequate medical records for each patient are to
28
be maintained.
29
2. Upon receipt of an application for a license, or
30
the renewal thereof, the department shall issue or renew the
31
license if the applicant and program meet the requirements
32
established under sections 197.200 to 197.240. Each license
33
shall be issued only for the persons and premises named in
34
the application. A license, unless sooner suspended or
35
revoked, shall be issued for a period of one year.
36
3. Each license shall be issued only for the premises
37
and persons or governmental units named in the application,
38
and shall not be transferable or assignable except with the
39
written consent of the department. Licenses shall be posted
40
in a conspicuous place on the licensed premises.
41
4. If, during the period in which an ambulatory
42
surgical center [license or an abortion facility] license is
43
in effect, the license holder or operator legally transfers
44
operational responsibilities by any process to another
45
person as defined in section 197.200, an application shall
46
be made for the issuance of a new license to become
47
effective on the transfer date.
48
197.220. The department of health and senior services
1
may deny, suspend or revoke a license in any case in which
2
the department finds that there has been a substantial
3
failure to comply with the requirements of sections 197.200
4
to 197.240, or in any case in which the director of the
5
department makes a finding that:
6
SB 699
45
(1) The applicant, or if the applicant is a firm,
7
partnership or association, any of its members, or if a
8
corporation, any of its officers or directors, or the person
9
designated to manage or supervise the facility, has been
10
finally adjudicated and found guilty, or entered a plea of
11
guilty or nolo contendere, in a criminal prosecution under
12
the laws of any state or of the United States, for any
13
offense reasonably related to the qualifications, functions,
14
or duties of an ambulatory surgical center [or of an
15
abortion facility], or for any offense an essential element
16
of which is fraud, dishonesty, or an act of violence, or for
17
any offense involving moral turpitude, whether or not
18
sentence is imposed;
19
(2) The licensure status or record of the applicant,
20
or if the applicant is a firm, partnership or association,
21
of any of its members, or if a corporation, of any of its
22
officers or directors, or of the person designated to manage
23
or supervise the facility, from any other state, federal
24
district or land, territory or commonwealth of the United
25
States, or of any foreign country where the applicant has
26
done business in a similar capacity indicates that granting
27
a license to the applicant would be detrimental to the
28
interests of the public.
29
197.225. [1.] The department of health and senior
1
services may adopt such reasonable rules, regulations, and
2
standards for the types of services provided as are
3
necessary to carry out the provisions of sections 197.200 to
4
197.240, and to assure quality patient care and patient
5
safety, which shall include, but not be limited to:
6
(1) Construction of the facility including, but not
7
limited to, plumbing, heating, lighting, and ventilation
8
SB 699
46
which should insure the health, safety, comfort, and privacy
9
of patients and protection from fire hazard;
10
(2) Number, qualifications, and organization of all
11
personnel, having responsibility for any part of the care
12
provided to the patients;
13
(3) Equipment essential to the health, welfare, and
14
safety of the patients;
15
(4) Facilities, programs, and services to be provided
16
in connection with the care of patients in ambulatory
17
surgical centers; and
18
(5) Procedures for peer review and for receiving and
19
investigating complaints regarding any ambulatory surgical
20
center or any physician, dentist, podiatrist, nurse,
21
assistant, manager, supervisor, or employee practicing or
22
working in any such facility.
23
[2. The department of health and senior services may
24
adopt separate rules, regulations, or standards to apply to
25
ambulatory surgical centers and to apply to abortion
26
facilities.
27
3. Abortion facilities shall be required to maintain a
28
written protocol for managing medical emergencies and the
29
transfer of patients requiring further emergency care to a
30
hospital within a reasonable distance from the abortion
31
facility.]
32
197.230. 1. The department of health and senior
1
services shall make, or cause to be made, such inspections
2
and investigations as it deems necessary. The department
3
may delegate its powers and duties to investigate and
4
inspect ambulatory surgical centers [or abortion facilities]
5
to an official of a political subdivision having a
6
population of at least four hundred fifty thousand if such
7
political subdivision is deemed qualified by the department
8
SB 699
47
to inspect and investigate ambulatory surgical centers. The
9
official so designated shall submit a written report of his
10
or her findings to the department and the department may
11
accept the recommendations of such official if it determines
12
that the facility inspected meets minimum standards
13
established pursuant to sections 197.200 to 197.240.
14
2. [In the case of any abortion facility, the
15
department shall make or cause to be made an unannounced on-
16
site inspection and investigation at least annually. Such
17
on-site inspection and investigation shall include, but not
18
be limited to, the following areas:
19
(1) Compliance with all statutory and regulatory
20
requirements for an abortion facility, including
21
requirements that the facility maintain adequate staffing
22
and equipment to respond to medical emergencies;
23
(2) Compliance with the provisions of chapter 188; and
24
(3) Compliance with the requirement in section 197.215
25
that continuous physician services or registered
26
professional nursing services be provided whenever a patient
27
is in the facility.
28
3.] Inspection, investigation, and quality assurance
29
reports shall be made available to the public. Any portion
30
of a report may be redacted when made publicly available if
31
such portion would disclose information that is not subject
32
to disclosure under the law.
33
197.235. 1. Any person operating, conducting,
1
managing, or establishing an ambulatory surgical center [or
2
abortion facility] without a license required by sections
3
197.200 to 197.240 is guilty of a class A misdemeanor and,
4
upon conviction, shall be subject to a fine of not more than
5
five hundred dollars. Each day of continuing violation
6
shall constitute a separate offense.
7
SB 699
48
2. The attorney general shall represent the department
8
of health and senior services and shall institute an action
9
in the name of the state for injunctive or other relief
10
against any person or governmental unit to restrain or
11
prevent the establishment, conduct, management, or operation
12
of an ambulatory surgical center [or abortion facility]
13
without a license issued pursuant to the provisions of
14
sections 197.200 to 197.240.
15
3. Any person operating, conducting, managing, or
16
establishing an ambulatory surgical center [or abortion
17
facility] who, in the course of advertising, promoting, or
18
otherwise publicizing the activities, business, location, or
19
any other matter concerning the operations of said
20
ambulatory surgical center [or abortion facility], uses or
21
employs in any manner the words "State, Missouri, State of
22
Missouri, Department of Health and Senior Services, the
23
initials 'Mo.'," or any emblem of the state of Missouri or
24
the department of health and senior services, for the
25
purpose of conveying or in any manner reasonably calculated
26
to convey the false impression that the state of Missouri or
27
any department, agency, bureau, or instrumentality thereof
28
is involved in the business of said ambulatory surgical
29
center [or abortion facility], or took part in said
30
advertisement, promotion, publicity, or other statement,
31
shall be subject to a fine of one hundred dollars per day
32
for each day during the period beginning with the day said
33
advertisement, promotion, publication, or statement first
34
appears and ending on the day on which it is withdrawn.
35
197.240. After September 28, 1975, no individual or
1
group health insurance policy of insurance providing
2
coverage on an expense incurred basis, nor individual or
3
group service or indemnity type contract issued by a
4
SB 699
49
nonprofit corporation, nor any self-insured group health
5
benefit plan or trust, of any kind or description, shall be
6
issued or payment accepted therefor in renewal or
7
continuation thereof unless coverage for any service
8
performed in an ambulatory surgical center [or abortion
9
facility] is provided for therein if such service would have
10
been covered under the terms of the policy or contract as an
11
eligible inpatient service, except as provided in section
12
376.805. Nothing in this section shall apply to a group
13
contract, plan or trust which provides health care and
14
surgical care directly to its members and their dependents.
15
Nothing in this section shall be construed to mandate
16
coverage under an individual or group health insurance
17
policy of insurance providing coverage on an expense-
18
incurred basis, or an individual or group service or
19
indemnity type contract issued by a nonprofit corporation,
20
or any self-insured group health benefit plan or trust, of
21
any kind or description, to provide health insurance for
22
services which are usually performed in a physician's office.
23
197.285. 1. Hospitals[,] and ambulatory surgical
1
centers[, and abortion facilities] shall establish and
2
implement a written policy adopted by each hospital[,] and
3
ambulatory surgical center[, and abortion facility] relating
4
to the protections for employees who disclose information
5
pursuant to subsection 2 of this section. This policy shall
6
include a time frame for completion of investigations
7
related to complaints, not to exceed thirty days, and a
8
method for notifying the complainant of the disposition of
9
the investigation. This policy shall be submitted to the
10
department of health and senior services to verify
11
implementation. At a minimum, such policy shall include the
12
following provisions:
13
SB 699
50
(1) No supervisor or individual with authority to hire
14
or fire in a hospital[,] or ambulatory surgical center[, or
15
abortion facility] shall prohibit employees from disclosing
16
information pursuant to subsection 2 of this section;
17
(2) No supervisor or individual with authority to hire
18
or fire in a hospital[,] or ambulatory surgical center[, or
19
abortion facility] shall use or threaten to use his or her
20
supervisory authority to knowingly discriminate against,
21
dismiss, penalize or in any way retaliate against or harass
22
an employee because the employee in good faith reported or
23
disclosed any information pursuant to subsection 2 of this
24
section, or in any way attempt to dissuade, prevent or
25
interfere with an employee who wishes to report or disclose
26
such information;
27
(3) Establish a program to identify a compliance
28
officer who is a designated person responsible for
29
administering the reporting and investigation process and an
30
alternate person should the primary designee be implicated
31
in the report.
32
2. This section shall apply to information disclosed
33
or reported in good faith by an employee concerning:
34
(1) Alleged facility mismanagement or fraudulent
35
activity;
36
(2) Alleged violations of applicable federal or state
37
laws or administrative rules concerning patient care,
38
patient safety or facility safety; or
39
(3) The ability of employees to successfully perform
40
their assigned duties.
41
All information disclosed, collected and maintained pursuant
42
to this subsection and pursuant to the written policy
43
requirements of this section shall be accessible to the
44
SB 699
51
department of health and senior services at all times and
45
shall be reviewed by the department of health and senior
46
services at least annually. Complainants shall be notified
47
of the department of health and senior services' access to
48
such information and of the complainant's right to notify
49
the department of health and senior services of any
50
information concerning alleged violations of applicable
51
federal or state laws or administrative rules concerning
52
patient care, patient safety or facility safety.
53
3. Prior to any disclosure to individuals or agencies
54
other than the department of health and senior services,
55
employees wishing to make a disclosure pursuant to the
56
provisions of this section shall first report to the
57
individual or individuals designated by the hospital[,] or
58
ambulatory surgical center[, or abortion facility] pursuant
59
to subsection 1 of this section.
60
4. If the compliance officer, compliance committee or
61
management official discovers credible evidence of
62
misconduct from any source and, after a reasonable inquiry,
63
has reason to believe that the misconduct may violate
64
criminal, civil or administrative law, then the hospital[,]
65
or ambulatory surgical center[, or abortion facility] shall
66
report the existence of misconduct to the appropriate
67
governmental authority within a reasonable period, but not
68
more than seven days after determining that there is
69
credible evidence of a violation.
70
5. Reports made to the department of health and senior
71
services shall be subject to the provisions of section
72
197.477, provided that the restrictions of section 197.477
73
shall not be construed to limit the employee's ability to
74
subpoena from the original source the information reported
75
to the department pursuant to this section.
76
SB 699
52
6. Each written policy shall allow employees making a
77
report who wish to remain anonymous to do so, and shall
78
include safeguards to protect the confidentiality of the
79
employee making the report, the confidentiality of patients
80
and the integrity of data, information and medical records.
81
7. Each hospital[,] and ambulatory surgical center[,
82
and abortion facility] shall, within forty-eight hours of
83
the receipt of a report, notify the employee that his or her
84
report has been received and is being reviewed.
85
197.287. [By July 1, 2001,] All hospitals and
1
ambulatory surgical centers[, and by July 1, 2018, all
2
abortion facilities] shall provide training programs, with
3
measurable minimal training outcomes relating to quality of
4
patient care and patient safety, to all unlicensed staff
5
providing patient care in their facility within ninety days
6
of the beginning date of employment. Standards for such
7
training shall be established by the department of health
8
and senior services by rule. It shall be a requirement of
9
hospital[,] and ambulatory surgical center[, and abortion
10
facility] licensure pursuant to this chapter that all
11
hospitals[,] and ambulatory surgical centers[, and abortion
12
facilities] submit documentation to the department of health
13
and senior services on the training program used.
14
197.289. 1. All hospitals[,] and ambulatory surgical
1
centers[, and abortion facilities] shall develop and
2
implement a methodology which ensures adequate nurse
3
staffing that will meet the needs of patients. At a
4
minimum, there shall be on duty at all times a sufficient
5
number of licensed registered nurses to provide patient care
6
requiring the judgment and skills of a licensed registered
7
nurse and to oversee the activities of all nursing personnel.
8
SB 699
53
2. There shall be sufficient licensed and ancillary
9
nursing personnel on duty on each nursing unit to meet the
10
needs of each patient in accordance with accepted standards
11
of quality patient care.
12
197.293. 1. In addition to the powers established in
1
sections 197.070 and 197.220, the department of health and
2
senior services shall use the following standards for
3
enforcing hospital[,] and ambulatory surgical center[, and
4
abortion facility] licensure regulations promulgated to
5
enforce the provisions of sections 197.010 to 197.120,
6
sections 197.150 to 197.165, and sections 197.200 to 197.240:
7
(1) Upon notification of a deficiency in meeting
8
regulatory standards, the hospital[,] or ambulatory surgical
9
center[, or abortion facility] shall develop and implement a
10
plan of correction approved by the department which
11
includes, but is not limited to, the specific type of
12
corrective action to be taken and an estimated time to
13
complete such action;
14
(2) If the plan as implemented does not correct the
15
deficiency, the department may either:
16
(a) Direct the hospital[,] or ambulatory surgical
17
center[, or abortion facility] to develop and implement a
18
plan of correction pursuant to subdivision (1) of this
19
subsection; or
20
(b) Require the hospital[,] or ambulatory surgical
21
center[, or abortion facility] to implement a plan of
22
correction developed by the department;
23
(3) If there is a continuing deficiency after
24
implementation of the plan of correction pursuant to
25
subdivision (2) of this subsection and the hospital[,] or
26
ambulatory surgical center[, or abortion facility] has had
27
an opportunity to correct such deficiency, the department
28
SB 699
54
may restrict new inpatient admissions or outpatient entrants
29
to the service or services affected by such deficiency;
30
(4) If there is a continuing deficiency after the
31
department restricts new inpatient admissions or outpatient
32
entrants to the service or services pursuant to subdivision
33
(3) of this subsection and the hospital[,] or ambulatory
34
surgical center[, or abortion facility] has had an
35
opportunity to correct such deficiency, the department may
36
suspend operations in all or part of the service or services
37
affected by such deficiency;
38
(5) If there is a continuing deficiency after
39
suspension of operations pursuant to subdivision (4) of this
40
subsection, the department may deny, suspend or revoke the
41
hospital's[,] or ambulatory surgical center's[, or abortion
42
facility's] license pursuant to section 197.070 or section
43
197.220.
44
2. Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection 1 of
45
this section to the contrary, if a deficiency in meeting
46
licensure standards presents an immediate and serious threat
47
to the patients' health and safety, the department may,
48
based on the scope and severity of the deficiency, restrict
49
access to the service or services affected by the deficiency
50
until the hospital[,] or ambulatory surgical center[, or
51
abortion facility] has developed and implemented an approved
52
plan of correction. Decisions as to whether a deficiency
53
constitutes an immediate and serious threat to the patients'
54
health and safety shall be made in accordance with
55
guidelines established pursuant to regulation of the
56
department of health and senior services and such decisions
57
shall be approved by the bureau of health facility licensing
58
in the department of health and senior services, or its
59
successor agency, or by a person authorized by the
60
SB 699
55
regulations to approve such decisions in the absence of the
61
director.
62
197.295. 1. A hospital[,] or ambulatory surgical
1
center[, or abortion facility] aggrieved by a decision of
2
the department pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (b)
3
of subdivision (2) and subdivisions (3), (4) and (5) of
4
subsection 1 of section 197.293 may appeal such decision to
5
the administrative hearing commission pursuant to section
6
197.071 or section 197.221, and seek judicial review
7
pursuant to section 621.145. An appeal of an action to
8
restrict new inpatient admissions or outpatient entrants,
9
suspend operations or revoke a license shall be heard on an
10
expedited basis by the administrative hearing commission.
11
The hospital[,] or ambulatory surgical center[, or abortion
12
facility] may apply to the administrative hearing commission
13
for an order to stay or suspend any such departmental action
14
pending the commission's findings and ruling as authorized
15
by section 621.035.
16
2. If both the department and the hospital[,] or
17
ambulatory surgical center[, or abortion facility] agree to
18
do so, prior to an appeal to the administrative hearing
19
commission pursuant to section 197.071 or section 197.221,
20
an official action of the department made pursuant to
21
sections 197.010 to 197.120 or sections 197.200 to 197.240
22
may be appealed to a departmental hearing officer. The
23
department of health and senior services shall promulgate
24
rules specifying the qualifications of such a hearing
25
officer, establish procedures to ensure impartial decisions
26
and provide for comparable appeal remedies when a
27
departmental hearing officer is unavailable.
28
197.315. 1. Any person who proposes to develop or
1
offer a new institutional health service within the state
2
SB 699
56
must obtain a certificate of need from the committee prior
3
to the time such services are offered.
4
2. Only those new institutional health services which
5
are found by the committee to be needed shall be granted a
6
certificate of need. Only those new institutional health
7
services which are granted certificates of need shall be
8
offered or developed within the state. No expenditures for
9
new institutional health services in excess of the
10
applicable expenditure minimum shall be made by any person
11
unless a certificate of need has been granted.
12
3. After October 1, 1980, no state agency charged by
13
statute to license or certify health care facilities shall
14
issue a license to or certify any such facility, or distinct
15
part of such facility, that is developed without obtaining a
16
certificate of need.
17
4. If any person proposes to develop any new
18
institutional health care service without a certificate of
19
need as required by sections 197.300 to 197.366, the
20
committee shall notify the attorney general, and he shall
21
apply for an injunction or other appropriate legal action in
22
any court of this state against that person.
23
5. After October 1, 1980, no agency of state
24
government may appropriate or grant funds to or make payment
25
of any funds to any person or health care facility which has
26
not first obtained every certificate of need required
27
pursuant to sections 197.300 to 197.366.
28
6. A certificate of need shall be issued only for the
29
premises and persons named in the application and is not
30
transferable except by consent of the committee.
31
7. Project cost increases, due to changes in the
32
project application as approved or due to project change
33
orders, exceeding the initial estimate by more than ten
34
SB 699
57
percent shall not be incurred without consent of the
35
committee.
36
8. Periodic reports to the committee shall be required
37
of any applicant who has been granted a certificate of need
38
until the project has been completed. The committee may
39
order the forfeiture of the certificate of need upon failure
40
of the applicant to file any such report.
41
9. A certificate of need shall be subject to
42
forfeiture for failure to incur a capital expenditure on any
43
approved project within six months after the date of the
44
order. The applicant may request an extension from the
45
committee of not more than six additional months based upon
46
substantial expenditure made.
47
10. Each application for a certificate of need must be
48
accompanied by an application fee. The time of filing
49
commences with the receipt of the application and the
50
application fee. The application fee is one thousand
51
dollars, or one-tenth of one percent of the total cost of
52
the proposed project, whichever is greater. All application
53
fees shall be deposited in the state treasury. Because of
54
the loss of federal funds, the general assembly will
55
appropriate funds to the Missouri health facilities review
56
committee.
57
11. In determining whether a certificate of need
58
should be granted, no consideration shall be given to the
59
facilities or equipment of any other health care facility
60
located more than a fifteen-mile radius from the applying
61
facility.
62
12. When a nursing facility shifts from a skilled to
63
an intermediate level of nursing care, it may return to the
64
higher level of care if it meets the licensure requirements,
65
without obtaining a certificate of need.
66
SB 699
58
13. [In no event shall a certificate of need be denied
67
because the applicant refuses to provide abortion services
68
or information.
69
14.] A certificate of need shall not be required for
70
the transfer of ownership of an existing and operational
71
health facility in its entirety.
72
[15.] 14. A certificate of need may be granted to a
73
facility for an expansion, an addition of services, a new
74
institutional service, or for a new hospital facility which
75
provides for something less than that which was sought in
76
the application.
77
[16.] 15. The provisions of this section shall not
78
apply to facilities operated by the state, and appropriation
79
of funds to such facilities by the general assembly shall be
80
deemed in compliance with this section, and such facilities
81
shall be deemed to have received an appropriate certificate
82
of need without payment of any fee or charge. The
83
provisions of this subsection shall not apply to hospitals
84
operated by the state and licensed under this chapter,
85
except for department of mental health state-operated
86
psychiatric hospitals.
87
[17.] 16. Notwithstanding other provisions of this
88
section, a certificate of need may be issued after July 1,
89
1983, for an intermediate care facility operated exclusively
90
for the intellectually disabled.
91
[18.] 17. To assure the safe, appropriate, and cost-
92
effective transfer of new medical technology throughout the
93
state, a certificate of need shall not be required for the
94
purchase and operation of:
95
(1) Research equipment that is to be used in a
96
clinical trial that has received written approval from a
97
duly constituted institutional review board of an accredited
98
SB 699
59
school of medicine or osteopathy located in Missouri to
99
establish its safety and efficacy and does not increase the
100
bed complement of the institution in which the equipment is
101
to be located. After the clinical trial has been completed,
102
a certificate of need must be obtained for continued use in
103
such facility; or
104
(2) Equipment that is to be used by an academic health
105
center operated by the state in furtherance of its research
106
or teaching missions.
107
334.100. 1. The board may refuse to issue or renew
1
any certificate of registration or authority, permit or
2
license required pursuant to this chapter for one or any
3
combination of causes stated in subsection 2 of this
4
section. The board shall notify the applicant in writing of
5
the reasons for the refusal and shall advise the applicant
6
of the applicant's right to file a complaint with the
7
administrative hearing commission as provided by chapter
8
621. As an alternative to a refusal to issue or renew any
9
certificate, registration or authority, the board may, at
10
its discretion, issue a license which is subject to
11
probation, restriction or limitation to an applicant for
12
licensure for any one or any combination of causes stated in
13
subsection 2 of this section. The board's order of
14
probation, limitation or restriction shall contain a
15
statement of the discipline imposed, the basis therefor, the
16
date such action shall become effective, and a statement
17
that the applicant has thirty days to request in writing a
18
hearing before the administrative hearing commission. If
19
the board issues a probationary, limited or restricted
20
license to an applicant for licensure, either party may file
21
a written petition with the administrative hearing
22
commission within thirty days of the effective date of the
23
SB 699
60
probationary, limited or restricted license seeking review
24
of the board's determination. If no written request for a
25
hearing is received by the administrative hearing commission
26
within the thirty-day period, the right to seek review of
27
the board's decision shall be considered as waived.
28
2. The board may cause a complaint to be filed with
29
the administrative hearing commission as provided by chapter
30
621 against any holder of any certificate of registration or
31
authority, permit or license required by this chapter or any
32
person who has failed to renew or has surrendered the
33
person's certificate of registration or authority, permit or
34
license for any one or any combination of the following
35
causes:
36
(1) Use of any controlled substance, as defined in
37
chapter 195, or alcoholic beverage to an extent that such
38
use impairs a person's ability to perform the work of any
39
profession licensed or regulated by this chapter;
40
(2) The person has been finally adjudicated and found
41
guilty, or entered a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, in a
42
criminal prosecution under the laws of any state or of the
43
United States, for any offense reasonably related to the
44
qualifications, functions or duties of any profession
45
licensed or regulated pursuant to this chapter, for any
46
offense involving fraud, dishonesty or an act of violence,
47
or for any offense involving moral turpitude, whether or not
48
sentence is imposed;
49
(3) Use of fraud, deception, misrepresentation or
50
bribery in securing any certificate of registration or
51
authority, permit or license issued pursuant to this chapter
52
or in obtaining permission to take any examination given or
53
required pursuant to this chapter;
54
SB 699
61
(4) Misconduct, fraud, misrepresentation, dishonesty,
55
unethical conduct or unprofessional conduct in the
56
performance of the functions or duties of any profession
57
licensed or regulated by this chapter, including, but not
58
limited to, the following:
59
(a) Obtaining or attempting to obtain any fee, charge,
60
tuition or other compensation by fraud, deception or
61
misrepresentation; willfully and continually overcharging or
62
overtreating patients; or charging for visits to the
63
physician's office which did not occur unless the services
64
were contracted for in advance, or for services which were
65
not rendered or documented in the patient's records;
66
(b) Attempting, directly or indirectly, by way of
67
intimidation, coercion or deception, to obtain or retain a
68
patient or discourage the use of a second opinion or
69
consultation;
70
(c) Willfully and continually performing inappropriate
71
or unnecessary treatment, diagnostic tests or medical or
72
surgical services;
73
(d) Delegating professional responsibilities to a
74
person who is not qualified by training, skill, competency,
75
age, experience or licensure to perform such
76
responsibilities;
77
(e) Misrepresenting that any disease, ailment or
78
infirmity can be cured by a method, procedure, treatment,
79
medicine or device;
80
(f) Performing or prescribing medical services which
81
have been declared by board rule to be of no medical or
82
osteopathic value;
83
(g) Final disciplinary action by any professional
84
medical or osteopathic association or society or licensed
85
hospital or medical staff of such hospital in this or any
86
SB 699
62
other state or territory, whether agreed to voluntarily or
87
not, and including, but not limited to, any removal,
88
suspension, limitation, or restriction of the person's
89
license or staff or hospital privileges, failure to renew
90
such privileges or license for cause, or other final
91
disciplinary action, if the action was in any way related to
92
unprofessional conduct, professional incompetence,
93
malpractice or any other violation of any provision of this
94
chapter;
95
(h) Signing a blank prescription form; or dispensing,
96
prescribing, administering or otherwise distributing any
97
drug, controlled substance or other treatment without
98
sufficient examination including failing to establish a
99
valid physician-patient relationship pursuant to section
100
334.108, or for other than medically accepted therapeutic or
101
experimental or investigative purposes duly authorized by a
102
state or federal agency, or not in the course of
103
professional practice, or not in good faith to relieve pain
104
and suffering, or not to cure an ailment, physical infirmity
105
or disease, except as authorized in section 334.104;
106
(i) Exercising influence within a physician-patient
107
relationship for purposes of engaging a patient in sexual
108
activity;
109
(j) Being listed on any state or federal sexual
110
offender registry;
111
(k) Terminating the medical care of a patient without
112
adequate notice or without making other arrangements for the
113
continued care of the patient;
114
(l) Failing to furnish details of a patient's medical
115
records to other treating physicians or hospitals upon
116
proper request; or failing to comply with any other law
117
relating to medical records;
118
SB 699
63
(m) Failure of any applicant or licensee to cooperate
119
with the board during any investigation;
120
(n) Failure to comply with any subpoena or subpoena
121
duces tecum from the board or an order of the board;
122
(o) Failure to timely pay license renewal fees
123
specified in this chapter;
124
(p) Violating a probation agreement, order, or other
125
settlement agreement with this board or any other licensing
126
agency;
127
(q) Failing to inform the board of the physician's
128
current residence and business address;
129
(r) Advertising by an applicant or licensee which is
130
false or misleading, or which violates any rule of the
131
board, or which claims without substantiation the positive
132
cure of any disease, or professional superiority to or
133
greater skill than that possessed by any other physician.
134
An applicant or licensee shall also be in violation of this
135
provision if the applicant or licensee has a financial
136
interest in any organization, corporation or association
137
which issues or conducts such advertising;
138
(s) Any other conduct that is unethical or
139
unprofessional involving a minor;
140
(5) Any conduct or practice which is or might be
141
harmful or dangerous to the mental or physical health of a
142
patient or the public; or incompetency, gross negligence or
143
repeated negligence in the performance of the functions or
144
duties of any profession licensed or regulated by this
145
chapter. For the purposes of this subdivision, "repeated
146
negligence" means the failure, on more than one occasion, to
147
use that degree of skill and learning ordinarily used under
148
the same or similar circumstances by the member of the
149
applicant's or licensee's profession;
150
SB 699
64
(6) Violation of, or attempting to violate, directly
151
or indirectly, or assisting or enabling any person to
152
violate, any provision of this chapter or chapter 324, or of
153
any lawful rule or regulation adopted pursuant to this
154
chapter or chapter 324;
155
(7) Impersonation of any person holding a certificate
156
of registration or authority, permit or license or allowing
157
any person to use his or her certificate of registration or
158
authority, permit, license or diploma from any school;
159
(8) Revocation, suspension, restriction, modification,
160
limitation, reprimand, warning, censure, probation or other
161
final disciplinary action against the holder of or applicant
162
for a license or other right to practice any profession
163
regulated by this chapter by another state, territory,
164
federal agency or country, whether or not voluntarily agreed
165
to by the licensee or applicant, including, but not limited
166
to, the denial of licensure, surrender of the license,
167
allowing the license to expire or lapse, or discontinuing or
168
limiting the practice of medicine while subject to an
169
investigation or while actually under investigation by any
170
licensing authority, medical facility, branch of the Armed
171
Forces of the United States of America, insurance company,
172
court, agency of the state or federal government, or
173
employer;
174
(9) A person is finally adjudged incapacitated or
175
disabled by a court of competent jurisdiction;
176
(10) Assisting or enabling any person to practice or
177
offer to practice any profession licensed or regulated by
178
this chapter who is not registered and currently eligible to
179
practice pursuant to this chapter; or knowingly performing
180
any act which in any way aids, assists, procures, advises,
181
or encourages any person to practice medicine who is not
182
SB 699
65
registered and currently eligible to practice pursuant to
183
this chapter. A physician who works in accordance with
184
standing orders or protocols or in accordance with the
185
provisions of section 334.104 shall not be in violation of
186
this subdivision;
187
(11) Issuance of a certificate of registration or
188
authority, permit or license based upon a material mistake
189
of fact;
190
(12) Failure to display a valid certificate or license
191
if so required by this chapter or any rule promulgated
192
pursuant to this chapter;
193
(13) Violation of the drug laws or rules and
194
regulations of this state, including but not limited to any
195
provision of chapter 195, any other state, or the federal
196
government;
197
(14) Knowingly making, or causing to be made, or
198
aiding, or abetting in the making of, a false statement in
199
any birth, death or other certificate or document executed
200
in connection with the practice of the person's profession;
201
(15) Knowingly making a false statement, orally or in
202
writing to the board;
203
(16) Soliciting patronage in person or by agents or
204
representatives, or by any other means or manner, under the
205
person's own name or under the name of another person or
206
concern, actual or pretended, in such a manner as to
207
confuse, deceive, or mislead the public as to the need or
208
necessity for or appropriateness of health care services for
209
all patients, or the qualifications of an individual person
210
or persons to diagnose, render, or perform health care
211
services;
212
(17) Using, or permitting the use of, the person's
213
name under the designation of "Doctor", "Dr.", "M.D.", or
214
SB 699
66
"D.O.", or any similar designation with reference to the
215
commercial exploitation of any goods, wares or merchandise;
216
(18) Knowingly making or causing to be made a false
217
statement or misrepresentation of a material fact, with
218
intent to defraud, for payment pursuant to the provisions of
219
chapter 208 or chapter 630 or for payment from Title XVIII
220
or Title XIX of the Social Security Act;
221
(19) Failure or refusal to properly guard against
222
contagious, infectious or communicable diseases or the
223
spread thereof; maintaining an unsanitary office or
224
performing professional services under unsanitary
225
conditions; or failure to report the existence of an
226
unsanitary condition in the office of a physician or in any
227
health care facility to the board, in writing, within thirty
228
days after the discovery thereof;
229
(20) Any candidate for licensure or person licensed to
230
practice as a physical therapist, paying or offering to pay
231
a referral fee or, notwithstanding section 334.010 to the
232
contrary, practicing or offering to practice professional
233
physical therapy independent of the prescription and
234
direction of a person licensed and registered as a physician
235
and surgeon pursuant to this chapter, as a dentist pursuant
236
to chapter 332, as a podiatrist pursuant to chapter 330, as
237
an advanced practice registered nurse under chapter 335, or
238
any licensed and registered physician, dentist, podiatrist,
239
or advanced practice registered nurse practicing in another
240
jurisdiction, whose license is in good standing;
241
(21) Any candidate for licensure or person licensed to
242
practice as a physical therapist, treating or attempting to
243
treat ailments or other health conditions of human beings
244
other than by professional physical therapy and as
245
authorized by sections 334.500 to 334.620;
246
SB 699
67
(22) Any person licensed to practice as a physician or
247
surgeon, requiring, as a condition of the physician-patient
248
relationship, that the patient receive prescribed drugs,
249
devices or other professional services directly from
250
facilities of that physician's office or other entities
251
under that physician's ownership or control. A physician
252
shall provide the patient with a prescription which may be
253
taken to the facility selected by the patient and a
254
physician knowingly failing to disclose to a patient on a
255
form approved by the advisory commission for professional
256
physical therapists as established by section 334.625 which
257
is dated and signed by a patient or guardian acknowledging
258
that the patient or guardian has read and understands that
259
the physician has a pecuniary interest in a physical therapy
260
or rehabilitation service providing prescribed treatment and
261
that the prescribed treatment is available on a competitive
262
basis. This subdivision shall not apply to a referral by
263
one physician to another physician within a group of
264
physicians practicing together;
265
(23) A pattern of personal use or consumption of any
266
controlled substance unless it is prescribed, dispensed or
267
administered by another physician who is authorized by law
268
to do so;
269
(24) Habitual intoxication or dependence on alcohol,
270
evidence of which may include more than one alcohol-related
271
enforcement contact as defined by section 302.525;
272
(25) Failure to comply with a treatment program or an
273
aftercare program entered into as part of a board order,
274
settlement agreement or licensee's professional health
275
program;
276
(26) Revocation, suspension, limitation, probation, or
277
restriction of any kind whatsoever of any controlled
278
SB 699
68
substance authority, whether agreed to voluntarily or not,
279
or voluntary termination of a controlled substance authority
280
while under investigation;
281
(27) For a physician to operate, conduct, manage, or
282
establish an abortion facility, or for a physician to
283
perform an abortion in an abortion facility[, if such
284
facility comes under the definition of an ambulatory
285
surgical center pursuant to sections 197.200 to 197.240, and
286
such facility has failed to obtain or renew a license as an
287
ambulatory surgical center].
288
3. Collaborative practice arrangements, protocols and
289
standing orders shall be in writing and signed and dated by
290
a physician prior to their implementation.
291
4. After the filing of such complaint before the
292
administrative hearing commission, the proceedings shall be
293
conducted in accordance with the provisions of chapter 621.
294
Upon a finding by the administrative hearing commission that
295
the grounds, provided in subsection 2 of this section, for
296
disciplinary action are met, the board may, singly or in
297
combination, warn, censure or place the person named in the
298
complaint on probation on such terms and conditions as the
299
board deems appropriate for a period not to exceed ten
300
years, or may suspend the person's license, certificate or
301
permit for a period not to exceed three years, or restrict
302
or limit the person's license, certificate or permit for an
303
indefinite period of time, or revoke the person's license,
304
certificate, or permit, or administer a public or private
305
reprimand, or deny the person's application for a license,
306
or permanently withhold issuance of a license or require the
307
person to submit to the care, counseling or treatment of
308
physicians designated by the board at the expense of the
309
individual to be examined, or require the person to attend
310
SB 699
69
such continuing educational courses and pass such
311
examinations as the board may direct.
312
5. In any order of revocation, the board may provide
313
that the person may not apply for reinstatement of the
314
person's license for a period of time ranging from two to
315
seven years following the date of the order of revocation.
316
All stay orders shall toll this time period.
317
6. Before restoring to good standing a license,
318
certificate or permit issued pursuant to this chapter which
319
has been in a revoked, suspended or inactive state for any
320
cause for more than two years, the board may require the
321
applicant to attend such continuing medical education
322
courses and pass such examinations as the board may direct.
323
7. In any investigation, hearing or other proceeding
324
to determine a licensee's or applicant's fitness to
325
practice, any record relating to any patient of the licensee
326
or applicant shall be discoverable by the board and
327
admissible into evidence, regardless of any statutory or
328
common law privilege which such licensee, applicant, record
329
custodian or patient might otherwise invoke. In addition,
330
no such licensee, applicant, or record custodian may
331
withhold records or testimony bearing upon a licensee's or
332
applicant's fitness to practice on the ground of privilege
333
between such licensee, applicant or record custodian and a
334
patient.
335
376.1199. 1. Each health carrier or health benefit
1
plan that offers or issues health benefit plans providing
2
obstetrical/gynecological benefits and pharmaceutical
3
coverage, which are delivered, issued for delivery,
4
continued or renewed in this state on or after January 1,
5
2002, shall:
6
SB 699
70
(1) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection 4 of
7
section 354.618, provide enrollees with direct access to the
8
services of a participating obstetrician, participating
9
gynecologist or participating obstetrician/gynecologist of
10
her choice within the provider network for covered
11
services. The services covered by this subdivision shall be
12
limited to those services defined by the published
13
recommendations of the accreditation council for graduate
14
medical education for training an obstetrician, gynecologist
15
or obstetrician/gynecologist, including but not limited to
16
diagnosis, treatment and referral for such services. A
17
health carrier shall not impose additional co-payments,
18
coinsurance or deductibles upon any enrollee who seeks or
19
receives health care services pursuant to this subdivision,
20
unless similar additional co-payments, coinsurance or
21
deductibles are imposed for other types of health care
22
services received within the provider network. Nothing in
23
this subsection shall be construed to require a health
24
carrier to perform, induce, pay for, reimburse, guarantee,
25
arrange, provide any resources for or refer a patient for an
26
abortion, as defined in section 188.015, other than a
27
spontaneous abortion or to prevent the death of the female
28
upon whom the abortion is performed, or to supersede or
29
conflict with section 376.805; and
30
(2) Notify enrollees annually of cancer screenings
31
covered by the enrollees' health benefit plan and the
32
current American Cancer Society guidelines for all cancer
33
screenings or notify enrollees at intervals consistent with
34
current American Cancer Society guidelines of cancer
35
screenings which are covered by the enrollees' health
36
benefit plans. The notice shall be delivered by mail unless
37
SB 699
71
the enrollee and health carrier have agreed on another
38
method of notification; and
39
(3) Include coverage for services related to
40
diagnosis, treatment and appropriate management of
41
osteoporosis when such services are provided by a person
42
licensed to practice medicine and surgery in this state, for
43
individuals with a condition or medical history for which
44
bone mass measurement is medically indicated for such
45
individual. In determining whether testing or treatment is
46
medically appropriate, due consideration shall be given to
47
peer-reviewed medical literature. A policy, provision,
48
contract, plan or agreement may apply to such services the
49
same deductibles, coinsurance and other limitations as apply
50
to other covered services; and
51
(4) If the health benefit plan also provides coverage
52
for pharmaceutical benefits, provide coverage for
53
contraceptives either at no charge or at the same level of
54
deductible, coinsurance or co-payment as any other covered
55
drug.
56
No such deductible, coinsurance or co-payment shall be
57
greater than any drug on the health benefit plan's
58
formulary. As used in this section, "contraceptive" shall
59
include all prescription drugs and devices approved by the
60
federal Food and Drug Administration for use as a
61
contraceptive, but shall exclude all drugs and devices that
62
are intended to induce an abortion, as defined in section
63
188.015, which shall be subject to section 376.805. Nothing
64
in this subdivision shall be construed to exclude coverage
65
for prescription contraceptive drugs or devices ordered by a
66
health care provider with prescriptive authority for reasons
67
other than contraceptive or abortion purposes.
68
SB 699
72
2. For the purposes of this section, "health carrier"
69
and "health benefit plan" shall have the same meaning as
70
defined in section 376.1350.
71
3. The provisions of this section shall not apply to a
72
supplemental insurance policy, including a life care
73
contract, accident-only policy, specified disease policy,
74
hospital policy providing a fixed daily benefit only,
75
Medicare supplement policy, long-term care policy, short-
76
term major medical policies of six months or less duration,
77
or any other supplemental policy as determined by the
78
director of the department of commerce and insurance.
79
4. Notwithstanding the provisions of subdivision (4)
80
of subsection 1 of this section to the contrary:
81
(1) Any health carrier shall offer and issue to any
82
person or entity purchasing a health benefit plan, a health
83
benefit plan that excludes coverage for contraceptives if
84
the use or provision of such contraceptives is contrary to
85
the moral, ethical or religious beliefs or tenets of such
86
person or entity;
87
(2) Upon request of an enrollee who is a member of a
88
group health benefit plan and who states that the use or
89
provision of contraceptives is contrary to his or her moral,
90
ethical or religious beliefs, any health carrier shall issue
91
to or on behalf of such enrollee a policy form that excludes
92
coverage for contraceptives. Any administrative costs to a
93
group health benefit plan associated with such exclusion of
94
coverage not offset by the decreased costs of providing
95
coverage shall be borne by the group policyholder or group
96
plan holder;
97
(3) Any health carrier which is owned, operated or
98
controlled in substantial part by an entity that is operated
99
pursuant to moral, ethical or religious tenets that are
100
SB 699
73
contrary to the use or provision of contraceptives shall be
101
exempt from the provisions of subdivision (4) of subsection
102
1 of this section. For purposes of this subsection, if new
103
premiums are charged for a contract, plan or policy, it
104
shall be determined to be a new contract, plan or policy.
105
5. Except for a health carrier that is exempted from
106
providing coverage for contraceptives pursuant to this
107
section, a health carrier shall allow enrollees in a health
108
benefit plan that excludes coverage for contraceptives
109
pursuant to subsection 4 of this section to purchase a
110
health benefit plan that includes coverage for
111
contraceptives.
112
6. Any health benefit plan issued pursuant to
113
subsection 1 of this section shall provide clear and
114
conspicuous written notice on the enrollment form or any
115
accompanying materials to the enrollment form and the group
116
health benefit plan application and contract:
117
(1) Whether coverage for contraceptives is or is not
118
included;
119
(2) That an enrollee who is a member of a group health
120
benefit plan with coverage for contraceptives has the right
121
to exclude coverage for contraceptives if such coverage is
122
contrary to his or her moral, ethical or religious beliefs;
123
and
124
(3) That an enrollee who is a member of a group health
125
benefit plan without coverage for contraceptives has the
126
right to purchase coverage for contraceptives[;
127
(4) Whether an optional rider for elective abortions
128
has been purchased by the group contract holder pursuant to
129
section 376.805; and
130
(5) That an enrollee who is a member of a group health
131
plan with coverage for elective abortions has the right to
132
SB 699
74
exclude and not pay for coverage for elective abortions if
133
such coverage is contrary to his or her moral, ethical, or
134
religious beliefs].
135
For purposes of this subsection, if new premiums are charged
136
for a contract, plan, or policy, it shall be determined to
137
be a new contract, plan, or policy.
138
7. Health carriers shall not disclose to the person or
139
entity who purchased the health benefit plan the names of
140
enrollees who exclude coverage for contraceptives in the
141
health benefit plan or who purchase a health benefit plan
142
that includes coverage for contraceptives. Health carriers
143
and the person or entity who purchased the health benefit
144
plan shall not discriminate against an enrollee because the
145
enrollee excluded coverage for contraceptives in the health
146
benefit plan or purchased a health benefit plan that
147
includes coverage for contraceptives.
148
8. The departments of health and senior services and
149
commerce and insurance may promulgate rules necessary to
150
implement the provisions of this section. No rule or
151
portion of a rule promulgated pursuant to this section shall
152
become effective unless it has been promulgated pursuant to
153
chapter 536. Any rule or portion of a rule, as that term is
154
defined in section 536.010, that is created under the
155
authority delegated in this section shall become effective
156
only if it complies with and is subject to all of the
157
provisions of chapter 536 and, if applicable, section
158
536.028. This section and chapter 536 are nonseverable and
159
if any of the powers vested with the general assembly
160
pursuant to chapter 536 to review, to delay the effective
161
date or to disapprove and annul a rule are subsequently held
162
unconstitutional, then the grant of rulemaking authority and
163
SB 699
75
any rule proposed or adopted after August 28, 2001, shall be
164
invalid and void.
165
491.060. The following persons shall be incompetent to
1
testify:
2
(1) A person who is mentally incapacitated at the time
3
of his or her production for examination;
4
(2) A child under ten years of age, who appears
5
incapable of receiving just impressions of the facts
6
respecting which the child is examined, or of relating them
7
truly; provided, however, that except as provided in
8
subdivision (1) of this section, a child under the age of
9
ten who is alleged to be a victim of an offense pursuant to
10
chapter 565, 566 or 568 shall be considered a competent
11
witness and shall be allowed to testify without
12
qualification in any judicial proceeding involving such
13
alleged offense. The trier of fact shall be permitted to
14
determine the weight and credibility to be given to the
15
testimony;
16
(3) An attorney, concerning any communication made to
17
the attorney by such attorney's client in that relation, or
18
such attorney's advice thereon, without the consent of such
19
client;
20
(4) Any person practicing as a minister of the gospel,
21
priest, rabbi or other person serving in a similar capacity
22
for any organized religion, concerning a communication made
23
to him or her in his or her professional capacity as a
24
spiritual advisor, confessor, counselor or comforter;
25
(5) A physician licensed pursuant to chapter 334, a
26
chiropractor licensed pursuant to chapter 331, a licensed
27
psychologist or a dentist licensed pursuant to chapter 332,
28
concerning any information which he or she may have acquired
29
from any patient while attending the patient in a
30
SB 699
76
professional character, and which information was necessary
31
to enable him or her to prescribe and provide treatment for
32
such patient as a physician, chiropractor, psychologist or
33
dentist;
34
(6) Any employee of an alternatives to abortion
35
agency, as defined in section 188.125, concerning a
36
communication made to him or her in his or her professional
37
capacity by an individual who presents themselves to the
38
agency for the purpose of seeking an alternative to an
39
abortion, unless such individual consents to the disclosure
40
of the communication.
41
556.061. In this code, unless the context requires a
1
different definition, the following terms shall mean:
2
(1) "Access", to instruct, communicate with, store
3
data in, retrieve or extract data from, or otherwise make
4
any use of any resources of, a computer, computer system, or
5
computer network;
6
(2) "Affirmative defense":
7
(a) The defense referred to is not submitted to the
8
trier of fact unless supported by evidence; and
9
(b) If the defense is submitted to the trier of fact
10
the defendant has the burden of persuasion that the defense
11
is more probably true than not;
12
(3) "Burden of injecting the issue":
13
(a) The issue referred to is not submitted to the
14
trier of fact unless supported by evidence; and
15
(b) If the issue is submitted to the trier of fact any
16
reasonable doubt on the issue requires a finding for the
17
defendant on that issue;
18
(4) "Commercial film and photographic print
19
processor", any person who develops exposed photographic
20
film into negatives, slides or prints, or who makes prints
21
SB 699
77
from negatives or slides, for compensation. The term
22
commercial film and photographic print processor shall
23
include all employees of such persons but shall not include
24
a person who develops film or makes prints for a public
25
agency;
26
(5) "Computer", the box that houses the central
27
processing unit (CPU), along with any internal storage
28
devices, such as internal hard drives, and internal
29
communication devices, such as internal modems capable of
30
sending or receiving electronic mail or fax cards, along
31
with any other hardware stored or housed internally. Thus,
32
computer refers to hardware, software and data contained in
33
the main unit. Printers, external modems attached by cable
34
to the main unit, monitors, and other external attachments
35
will be referred to collectively as peripherals and
36
discussed individually when appropriate. When the computer
37
and all peripherals are referred to as a package, the term
38
"computer system" is used. Information refers to all the
39
information on a computer system including both software
40
applications and data;
41
(6) "Computer equipment", computers, terminals, data
42
storage devices, and all other computer hardware associated
43
with a computer system or network;
44
(7) "Computer hardware", all equipment which can
45
collect, analyze, create, display, convert, store, conceal
46
or transmit electronic, magnetic, optical or similar
47
computer impulses or data. Hardware includes, but is not
48
limited to, any data processing devices, such as central
49
processing units, memory typewriters and self-contained
50
laptop or notebook computers; internal and peripheral
51
storage devices, transistor-like binary devices and other
52
memory storage devices, such as floppy disks, removable
53
SB 699
78
disks, compact disks, digital video disks, magnetic tape,
54
hard drive, optical disks and digital memory; local area
55
networks, such as two or more computers connected together
56
to a central computer server via cable or modem; peripheral
57
input or output devices, such as keyboards, printers,
58
scanners, plotters, video display monitors and optical
59
readers; and related communication devices, such as modems,
60
cables and connections, recording equipment, RAM or ROM
61
units, acoustic couplers, automatic dialers, speed dialers,
62
programmable telephone dialing or signaling devices and
63
electronic tone-generating devices; as well as any devices,
64
mechanisms or parts that can be used to restrict access to
65
computer hardware, such as physical keys and locks;
66
(8) "Computer network", two or more interconnected
67
computers or computer systems;
68
(9) "Computer program", a set of instructions,
69
statements, or related data that directs or is intended to
70
direct a computer to perform certain functions;
71
(10) "Computer software", digital information which
72
can be interpreted by a computer and any of its related
73
components to direct the way they work. Software is stored
74
in electronic, magnetic, optical or other digital form. The
75
term commonly includes programs to run operating systems and
76
applications, such as word processing, graphic, or
77
spreadsheet programs, utilities, compilers, interpreters and
78
communications programs;
79
(11) "Computer-related documentation", written,
80
recorded, printed or electronically stored material which
81
explains or illustrates how to configure or use computer
82
hardware, software or other related items;
83
(12) "Computer system", a set of related, connected or
84
unconnected, computer equipment, data, or software;
85
SB 699
79
(13) "Confinement":
86
(a) A person is in confinement when such person is
87
held in a place of confinement pursuant to arrest or order
88
of a court, and remains in confinement until:
89
a. A court orders the person's release; or
90
b. The person is released on bail, bond, or
91
recognizance, personal or otherwise; or
92
c. A public servant having the legal power and duty to
93
confine the person authorizes his release without guard and
94
without condition that he return to confinement;
95
(b) A person is not in confinement if:
96
a. The person is on probation or parole, temporary or
97
otherwise; or
98
b. The person is under sentence to serve a term of
99
confinement which is not continuous, or is serving a
100
sentence under a work-release program, and in either such
101
case is not being held in a place of confinement or is not
102
being held under guard by a person having the legal power
103
and duty to transport the person to or from a place of
104
confinement;
105
(14) "Consent": consent or lack of consent may be
106
expressed or implied. Assent does not constitute consent if:
107
(a) It is given by a person who lacks the mental
108
capacity to authorize the conduct charged to constitute the
109
offense and such mental incapacity is manifest or known to
110
the actor; or
111
(b) It is given by a person who by reason of youth,
112
mental disease or defect, intoxication, a drug-induced
113
state, or any other reason is manifestly unable or known by
114
the actor to be unable to make a reasonable judgment as to
115
the nature or harmfulness of the conduct charged to
116
constitute the offense; or
117
SB 699
80
(c) It is induced by force, duress or deception;
118
(15) "Controlled substance", a drug, substance, or
119
immediate precursor in schedules I through V as defined in
120
chapter 195;
121
(16) "Criminal negligence", failure to be aware of a
122
substantial and unjustifiable risk that circumstances exist
123
or a result will follow, and such failure constitutes a
124
gross deviation from the standard of care which a reasonable
125
person would exercise in the situation;
126
(17) "Custody", a person is in custody when he or she
127
has been arrested but has not been delivered to a place of
128
confinement;
129
(18) "Damage", when used in relation to a computer
130
system or network, means any alteration, deletion, or
131
destruction of any part of the computer system or network;
132
(19) "Dangerous felony", the felonies of arson in the
133
first degree, assault in the first degree, attempted rape in
134
the first degree if physical injury results, attempted
135
forcible rape if physical injury results, attempted sodomy
136
in the first degree if physical injury results, attempted
137
forcible sodomy if physical injury results, rape in the
138
first degree, forcible rape, sodomy in the first degree,
139
forcible sodomy, assault in the second degree if the victim
140
of such assault is a special victim as defined in
141
subdivision (14) of section 565.002, kidnapping in the first
142
degree, kidnapping, murder in the second degree, assault of
143
a law enforcement officer in the first degree, domestic
144
assault in the first degree, elder abuse in the first
145
degree, robbery in the first degree, armed criminal action,
146
conspiracy to commit an offense when the offense is a
147
dangerous felony, vehicle hijacking when punished as a class
148
A felony, statutory rape in the first degree when the victim
149
SB 699
81
is a child less than twelve years of age at the time of the
150
commission of the act giving rise to the offense, statutory
151
sodomy in the first degree when the victim is a child less
152
than twelve years of age at the time of the commission of
153
the act giving rise to the offense, child molestation in the
154
first or second degree, abuse of a child if the child dies
155
as a result of injuries sustained from conduct chargeable
156
under section 568.060, child kidnapping, parental kidnapping
157
committed by detaining or concealing the whereabouts of the
158
child for not less than one hundred twenty days under
159
section 565.153, and an "intoxication-related traffic
160
offense" or "intoxication-related boating offense" if the
161
person is found to be a "habitual offender" or "habitual
162
boating offender" as such terms are defined in section
163
577.001;
164
(20) "Dangerous instrument", any instrument, article
165
or substance, which, under the circumstances in which it is
166
used, is readily capable of causing death or other serious
167
physical injury;
168
(21) "Data", a representation of information, facts,
169
knowledge, concepts, or instructions prepared in a
170
formalized or other manner and intended for use in a
171
computer or computer network. Data may be in any form
172
including, but not limited to, printouts, microfiche,
173
magnetic storage media, punched cards and as may be stored
174
in the memory of a computer;
175
(22) "Deadly weapon", any firearm, loaded or unloaded,
176
or any weapon from which a shot, readily capable of
177
producing death or serious physical injury, may be
178
discharged, or a switchblade knife, dagger, billy club,
179
blackjack or metal knuckles;
180
SB 699
82
(23) "Digital camera", a camera that records images in
181
a format which enables the images to be downloaded into a
182
computer;
183
(24) "Disability", a mental, physical, or
184
developmental impairment that substantially limits one or
185
more major life activities or the ability to provide
186
adequately for one's care or protection, whether the
187
impairment is congenital or acquired by accident, injury or
188
disease, where such impairment is verified by medical
189
findings;
190
(25) "Elderly person", a person sixty years of age or
191
older;
192
(26) "Felony", an offense so designated or an offense
193
for which persons found guilty thereof may be sentenced to
194
death or imprisonment for a term of more than one year;
195
(27) "Forcible compulsion" either:
196
(a) Physical force that overcomes reasonable
197
resistance; or
198
(b) A threat, express or implied, that places a person
199
in reasonable fear of death, serious physical injury or
200
kidnapping of such person or another person;
201
(28) "Incapacitated", a temporary or permanent
202
physical or mental condition in which a person is
203
unconscious, unable to appraise the nature of his or her
204
conduct, or unable to communicate unwillingness to an act;
205
(29) "Infraction", a violation defined by this code or
206
by any other statute of this state if it is so designated or
207
if no sentence other than a fine, or fine and forfeiture or
208
other civil penalty, is authorized upon conviction;
209
(30) "Inhabitable structure", a vehicle, vessel or
210
structure:
211
SB 699
83
(a) Where any person lives or carries on business or
212
other calling; or
213
(b) Where people assemble for purposes of business,
214
government, education, religion, entertainment, or public
215
transportation; or
216
(c) Which is used for overnight accommodation of
217
persons.
218
Any such vehicle, vessel, or structure is inhabitable
219
regardless of whether a person is actually present. If a
220
building or structure is divided into separately occupied
221
units, any unit not occupied by the actor is an inhabitable
222
structure of another;
223
(31) "Knowingly", when used with respect to:
224
(a) Conduct or attendant circumstances, means a person
225
is aware of the nature of his or her conduct or that those
226
circumstances exist; or
227
(b) A result of conduct, means a person is aware that
228
his or her conduct is practically certain to cause that
229
result;
230
(32) "Law enforcement officer", any public servant
231
having both the power and duty to make arrests for
232
violations of the laws of this state, and federal law
233
enforcement officers authorized to carry firearms and to
234
make arrests for violations of the laws of the United States;
235
(33) "Misdemeanor", an offense so designated or an
236
offense for which persons found guilty thereof may be
237
sentenced to imprisonment for a term of which the maximum is
238
one year or less;
239
(34) "Of another", property that any entity, including
240
but not limited to any natural person, corporation, limited
241
liability company, partnership, association, governmental
242
SB 699
84
subdivision or instrumentality, other than the actor, has a
243
possessory or proprietary interest therein, except that
244
property shall not be deemed property of another who has
245
only a security interest therein, even if legal title is in
246
the creditor pursuant to a conditional sales contract or
247
other security arrangement;
248
(35) "Offense", any felony or misdemeanor;
249
(36) "Person", includes a human being from the moment
250
of conception as defined in section 188.015;
251
(37) "Physical injury", slight impairment of any
252
function of the body or temporary loss of use of any part of
253
the body;
254
[(37)] (38) "Place of confinement", any building or
255
facility and the grounds thereof wherein a court is legally
256
authorized to order that a person charged with or convicted
257
of a crime be held;
258
[(38)] (39) "Possess" or "possessed", having actual or
259
constructive possession of an object with knowledge of its
260
presence. A person has actual possession if such person has
261
the object on his or her person or within easy reach and
262
convenient control. A person has constructive possession if
263
such person has the power and the intention at a given time
264
to exercise dominion or control over the object either
265
directly or through another person or persons. Possession
266
may also be sole or joint. If one person alone has
267
possession of an object, possession is sole. If two or more
268
persons share possession of an object, possession is joint;
269
[(39)] (40) "Property", anything of value, whether
270
real or personal, tangible or intangible, in possession or
271
in action;
272
[(40)] (41) "Public servant", any person employed in
273
any way by a government of this state who is compensated by
274
SB 699
85
the government by reason of such person's employment, any
275
person appointed to a position with any government of this
276
state, or any person elected to a position with any
277
government of this state. It includes, but is not limited
278
to, legislators, jurors, members of the judiciary and law
279
enforcement officers. It does not include witnesses;
280
[(41)] (42) "Purposely", when used with respect to a
281
person's conduct or to a result thereof, means when it is
282
his or her conscious object to engage in that conduct or to
283
cause that result;
284
[(42)] (43) "Recklessly", consciously disregarding a
285
substantial and unjustifiable risk that circumstances exist
286
or that a result will follow, and such disregard constitutes
287
a gross deviation from the standard of care which a
288
reasonable person would exercise in the situation;
289
[(43)] (44) "Serious emotional injury", an injury that
290
creates a substantial risk of temporary or permanent medical
291
or psychological damage, manifested by impairment of a
292
behavioral, cognitive or physical condition. Serious
293
emotional injury shall be established by testimony of
294
qualified experts upon the reasonable expectation of
295
probable harm to a reasonable degree of medical or
296
psychological certainty;
297
[(44)] (45) "Serious physical injury", physical injury
298
that creates a substantial risk of death or that causes
299
serious disfigurement or protracted loss or impairment of
300
the function of any part of the body;
301
[(45)] (46) "Services", when used in relation to a
302
computer system or network, means use of a computer,
303
computer system, or computer network and includes, but is
304
not limited to, computer time, data processing, and storage
305
or retrieval functions;
306
SB 699
86
[(46)] (47) "Sexual orientation", male or female
307
heterosexuality, homosexuality or bisexuality by
308
inclination, practice, identity or expression, or having a
309
self-image or identity not traditionally associated with
310
one's gender;
311
[(47)] (48) "Vehicle", a self-propelled mechanical
312
device designed to carry a person or persons, excluding
313
vessels or aircraft;
314
[(48)] (49) "Vessel", any boat or craft propelled by a
315
motor or by machinery, whether or not such motor or
316
machinery is a principal source of propulsion used or
317
capable of being used as a means of transportation on water,
318
or any boat or craft more than twelve feet in length which
319
is powered by sail alone or by a combination of sail and
320
machinery, and used or capable of being used as a means of
321
transportation on water, but not any boat or craft having,
322
as the only means of propulsion, a paddle or oars;
323
[(49)] (50) "Voluntary act":
324
(a) A bodily movement performed while conscious as a
325
result of effort or determination. Possession is a
326
voluntary act if the possessor knowingly procures or
327
receives the thing possessed, or having acquired control of
328
it was aware of his or her control for a sufficient time to
329
have enabled him or her to dispose of it or terminate his or
330
her control; or
331
(b) An omission to perform an act of which the actor
332
is physically capable. A person is not guilty of an offense
333
based solely upon an omission to perform an act unless the
334
law defining the offense expressly so provides, or a duty to
335
perform the omitted act is otherwise imposed by law;
336
[(50)] (51) "Vulnerable person", any person in the
337
custody, care, or control of the department of mental health
338
SB 699
87
who is receiving services from an operated, funded,
339
licensed, or certified program.
340
562.031. 1. A person is not relieved of criminal
1
liability for conduct because he or she engages in such
2
conduct under a mistaken belief of fact or law unless such
3
mistake negatives the existence of the mental state required
4
by the offense.
5
2. A person is not relieved of criminal liability for
6
conduct because he or she believes his or her conduct does
7
not constitute an offense unless his or her belief is
8
reasonable and:
9
(1) The offense is defined by an administrative
10
regulation or order which is not known to him or her and has
11
not been published or otherwise made reasonably available to
12
him or her, and he or she could not have acquired such
13
knowledge by the exercise of due diligence pursuant to facts
14
known to him or her; or
15
(2) He or she acts in reasonable reliance upon an
16
official statement of the law, afterward determined to be
17
invalid or erroneous, contained in:
18
(a) A statute;
19
(b) An opinion or order of an appellate court; or
20
(c) An official interpretation of the statute,
21
regulation or order defining the offense made by a public
22
official or agency legally authorized to interpret such
23
statute, regulation or order.
24
3. The burden of injecting the issue of reasonable
25
belief that conduct does not constitute an offense under
26
subdivisions (1) and (2) of subsection 2 of this section is
27
on the defendant.
28
4. For purposes of this section, reliance is
29
unreasonable if based upon an official statement permitting
30
SB 699
88
the unjustified homicide of an unborn child as defined in
31
section 1.205.
32
562.071. 1. It is an affirmative defense that the
1
defendant engaged in the conduct charged to constitute an
2
offense because he or she was coerced to do so, by the use
3
of, or threatened imminent use of, unlawful physical force
4
upon him or her or a third person, which force or threatened
5
force a person of reasonable firmness in his situation would
6
have been unable to resist.
7
2. The defense of "duress" as defined in subsection 1
8
of this section is not available:
9
(1) As to the crime of murder, except murder by
10
abortion as defined in section 188.015;
11
(2) As to any offense when the defendant recklessly
12
places himself or herself in a situation in which it is
13
probable that he or she will be subjected to the force or
14
threatened force described in subsection 1 of this section.
15
563.026. 1. Unless inconsistent with other provisions
1
of this chapter defining justifiable use of physical force,
2
or with some other provision of law, conduct which would
3
otherwise constitute any offense [other than a class A
4
felony or murder] is justifiable and not criminal when it is
5
necessary as an emergency measure to avoid an imminent
6
public or private injury which is about to occur by reason
7
of a situation occasioned or developed through no fault of
8
the actor, and which is of such gravity that, according to
9
ordinary standards of intelligence and morality, the
10
desirability of avoiding the injury outweighs the
11
desirability of avoiding the injury sought to be prevented
12
by the statute defining the offense charged.
13
2. The necessity and justifiability of conduct under
14
subsection 1 of this section may not rest upon
15
SB 699
89
considerations pertaining only to the morality and
16
advisability of the statute, either in its general
17
application or with respect to its application to a
18
particular class of cases arising thereunder. Whenever
19
evidence relating to the defense of justification under this
20
section is offered, the court shall rule as a matter of law
21
whether the claimed facts and circumstances would, if
22
established, constitute a justification.
23
3. The defense of justification under this section is
24
an affirmative defense.
25
565.015. 1. This section shall be known and may be
1
cited as the "Abolition of Abortion in Missouri Act".
2
2. It is the intent of the general assembly to provide
3
to unborn children the equal protection of the laws of this
4
state; to establish that a living human child, from the
5
moment of conception, is entitled to the same rights,
6
powers, privileges, justice, and protections as are secured
7
or granted by the laws of this state to any other human
8
person; and to treat as void and of no effect any and all
9
federal acts, laws, treaties, decisions, orders, rules, or
10
regulations that would deprive an unborn child of the right
11
to life or prohibit the protection of such right.
12
3. The attorney general and prosecuting and circuit
13
attorneys shall ensure the enforcement of this chapter in
14
relation to abortion regardless of any contrary or
15
conflicting federal acts, laws, treaties, decisions, orders,
16
rules, or regulations. The attorney general shall have
17
concurrent original jurisdiction throughout the state, along
18
with each prosecuting and circuit attorney within their
19
respective jurisdictions, to commence actions to ensure the
20
enforcement of this chapter in relation to abortion.
21
SB 699
90
4. This chapter shall be enforced in relation to
22
abortion regardless of any contrary or conflicting federal
23
acts, laws, treaties, decisions, orders, rules, or
24
regulations. Any court decision purporting to enjoin this
25
state from protecting innocent human life from the moment of
26
conception shall be treated as nonauthoritative, void, and
27
of no force. No government agency or official of this
28
state, including any sheriff, deputy sheriff, or other law
29
enforcement officer, shall give force or effect to any court
30
order that conflicts with this section. Cooperative
31
agreements with federal agencies notwithstanding, no law
32
enforcement agency or law enforcement officer in this state
33
shall assist or cooperate in any way with the arrest or
34
imprisonment of any government official or individual who
35
complies with this section and refuses to comply with any
36
contrary court order. Such contrary orders shall include,
37
but not be limited to, any order to levy upon property,
38
seize bank accounts, arrest the person, or serve process for
39
the purpose of causing any person to violate this section,
40
or for the purpose of punishing any person for the failure
41
to comply with an order contrary to this section. A federal
42
officer or agent who arrests any Missouri government
43
official for compliance with this section shall be subject
44
to arrest by Missouri law enforcement.
45
5. In any investigation or proceeding brought to
46
enforce the provisions of this chapter relating to abortion,
47
as in all other criminal cases, a court on motion of the
48
prosecuting or circuit attorney may order that a witness
49
shall not be excused from giving testimony or producing any
50
papers, documents, or things, on the grounds that such
51
testimony may tend to incriminate or subject the witness to
52
a penalty or forfeiture; but such witness shall not be
53
SB 699
91
prosecuted or subjected to criminal penalty or forfeiture
54
for or on account of any transaction, matter, or thing
55
concerning which the witness has been ordered to testify.
56
The prosecuting or circuit attorney shall also have
57
authority to grant such immunity to a witness who
58
voluntarily agrees to give testimony or produce any papers,
59
documents, or things. The witness may nevertheless be
60
prosecuted for failing to comply with the order to answer,
61
perjury, or the giving of false evidence.
62
6. A woman upon whom an abortion is performed or
63
induced or attempted or intended to be performed or induced
64
shall not be held criminally responsible for the death or
65
attempted death of her child if the woman has been coerced,
66
through physical or other means, to undergo the abortion or
67
if, as a result of mental disease or defect, she was
68
incapable of knowing and appreciating the nature, quality,
69
or wrongfulness of her conduct, as described in section
70
562.086.
71
595.027. 1. Upon request by the department for
1
verification of injuries of victims, medical providers shall
2
submit the information requested by the department within
3
twenty working days of the request at no cost to the fund.
4
2. For purposes of this section, "medical providers"
5
means physicians, dentists, clinical psychologists,
6
optometrists, podiatrists, registered nurses, physician's
7
assistants, chiropractors, physical therapists, hospitals,
8
ambulatory surgical centers, [abortion facilities,] and
9
nursing homes.
10
3. Failure to submit the information as required by
11
this section shall be an infraction.
12
595.120. 1. Prior to January 1, 2019, the department
1
of public safety shall create a poster that provides
2
SB 699
92
information regarding the national human trafficking
3
resource center hotline. The poster shall be no smaller
4
than eight and one-half inches by eleven inches in size and
5
shall include a statement in substantially the following
6
form:
7
The statement shall appear on each poster in English,
26
Spanish, and, for each county, any other language required
27
for voting materials in that county under Section 1973 of
28
the Voting Rights Act of 1965, 42 U.S.C. Section 1973, as
29
amended. In addition to the national human trafficking
30
resource center hotline, the statement may contain any
31
additional hotlines regarding human trafficking for access
32
to help and services.
33
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
"If you or someone you know is being forced to
engage in any activity and cannot leave – whether
it is commercial sex, housework, farm work, or any
other activity – call the National Human
Trafficking Resource Center Hotline at 1-888-373-
7888 or text 233733 (BEFREE) or visit the
following website:
www.traffickingresourcecenter.org to access help
and services. Victims of human trafficking are
protected under U.S. and Missouri law.
18
The toll-free hotline is:
19
- Available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week
20
21
- Operated by a nonprofit, nongovernmental
organization
22
- Anonymous and confidential
23
- Accessible in 170 languages
24
25
- Able to provide help, referral to services,
training, and general information.".
SB 699
93
2. Beginning March 1, 2019, the human trafficking
34
hotline poster designed by the department of public safety
35
shall be displayed in a conspicuous place in or near the
36
bathrooms or near the entrance of each of the following
37
establishments:
38
(1) Hotels, motels, or other establishments that have
39
been cited as a public nuisance for prostitution under
40
section 567.080;
41
(2) Strip clubs or other sexually oriented businesses;
42
(3) Private clubs that have a liquor permit for on-
43
premises consumption, do not hold themselves out to be food
44
service establishments, and are not affiliated with any
45
nonprofit fraternal, athletic, religious, or veteran
46
organizations;
47
(4) Airports;
48
(5) Train stations that serve passengers;
49
(6) Emergency rooms within general acute care
50
hospitals;
51
(7) Urgent care centers;
52
(8) Privately operated job recruitment centers;
53
(9) Businesses or establishments that offer massage or
54
body work services for compensation by individuals who are
55
not licensed under section 324.265;
56
(10) Women's health centers;
57
(11) [Abortion facilities as defined in section
58
188.015;
59
(12)] Family planning clinics;
60
[(13)] (12) Maternity homes as defined in section
61
135.600;
62
[(14)] (13) Pregnancy resource centers as defined in
63
section 135.630;
64
[(15)] (14) Bus stations;
65
SB 699
94
[(16)] (15) Truck stops. For the purposes of this
66
section, "truck stops" shall mean privately owned and
67
operated facilities that provide food, fuel, shower or other
68
sanitary facilities, and lawful overnight parking; and
69
[(17)] (16) Roadside rest areas.
70
3. The department of public safety shall make the
71
poster available for print on its public website. To obtain
72
a copy of the poster, the owners or operators of an
73
establishment required to post the human trafficking hotline
74
notice under subsection 2 of this section may print the
75
online poster using the online link or request that the
76
poster be mailed for the cost of printing and first class
77
postage.
78
4. Any owner or operator of an establishment required
79
to post the human trafficking hotline notice under
80
subsection 2 of this section who fails to comply with the
81
requirement shall receive a written warning for the first
82
violation and may be guilty of an infraction for any
83
subsequent violation.
84
[188.017. 1. This section shall be known
1
and may be cited as the "Right to Life of the
2
Unborn Child Act".
3
2. Notwithstanding any other provision of
4
law to the contrary, no abortion shall be
5
performed or induced upon a woman, except in
6
cases of medical emergency. Any person who
7
knowingly performs or induces an abortion of an
8
unborn child in violation of this subsection
9
shall be guilty of a class B felony, as well as
10
subject to suspension or revocation of his or
11
her professional license by his or her
12
professional licensing board. A woman upon whom
13
an abortion is performed or induced in violation
14
of this subsection shall not be prosecuted for a
15
conspiracy to violate the provisions of this
16
subsection.
17
3. It shall be an affirmative defense for
18
any person alleged to have violated the
19
provisions of subsection 2 of this section that
20
the person performed or induced an abortion
21
because of a medical emergency. The defendant
22
SB 699
95
shall have the burden of persuasion that the
23
defense is more probably true than not.
24
4. The enactment of this section shall
25
only become effective upon notification to the
26
revisor of statutes by an opinion by the
27
attorney general of Missouri, a proclamation by
28
the governor of Missouri, or the adoption of a
29
concurrent resolution by the Missouri general
30
assembly that:
31
(1) The United States Supreme Court has
32
overruled, in whole or in part, Roe v. Wade, 410
33
U.S. 113 (1973), restoring or granting to the
34
state of Missouri the authority to regulate
35
abortion to the extent set forth in this
36
section, and that as a result, it is reasonably
37
probable that this section would be upheld by
38
the court as constitutional;
39
(2) An amendment to the Constitution of
40
the United States has been adopted that has the
41
effect of restoring or granting to the state of
42
Missouri the authority to regulate abortion to
43
the extent set forth in this section; or
44
(3) The United States Congress has enacted
45
a law that has the effect of restoring or
46
granting to the state of Missouri the authority
47
to regulate abortion to the extent set forth in
48
this section.]
49
[188.018. If any one or more provisions,
1
sections, subsections, sentences, clauses,
2
phrases, or words of this chapter or the
3
application thereof to any person, circumstance,
4
or period of gestational age is found to be
5
unenforceable, unconstitutional, or invalid by a
6
court of competent jurisdiction, the same is
7
hereby declared to be severable and the balance
8
of this chapter shall remain effective
9
notwithstanding such unenforceability,
10
unconstitutionality, or invalidity. The general
11
assembly hereby declares that it would have
12
passed each provision, section, subsection,
13
sentence, clause, phrase, or word thereof,
14
irrespective of the fact that any one or more
15
provisions, sections, subsections, sentences,
16
clauses, phrases, or words of this chapter, or
17
the application of this chapter to any person,
18
circumstance, or period of gestational age,
19
would be declared unenforceable,
20
unconstitutional, or invalid.]
21
[188.021. 1. When RU-486 (mifepristone)
1
or any drug or chemical is used for the purpose
2
of inducing an abortion, the initial dose of the
3
drug or chemical shall be administered in the
4
same room and in the physical presence of the
5
physician who prescribed, dispensed, or
6
otherwise provided the drug or chemical to the
7
patient. The physician inducing the abortion,
8
SB 699
96
or a person acting on such physician's behalf,
9
shall make all reasonable efforts to ensure that
10
the patient returns after the administration or
11
use of RU-486 or any drug or chemical for a
12
follow-up visit unless such termination of the
13
pregnancy has already been confirmed and the
14
patient's medical condition has been assessed by
15
a licensed physician prior to discharge.
16
2. When the Food and Drug Administration
17
label of any drug or chemical used for the
18
purpose of inducing an abortion includes any
19
clinical study in which more than one percent of
20
those administered the drug or chemical required
21
surgical intervention after its administration,
22
no physician may prescribe or administer such
23
drug or chemical to any patient without first
24
obtaining approval from the department of health
25
and senior services of a complication plan from
26
the physician for administration of the drug or
27
chemical to any patient. The complication plan
28
shall include any information deemed necessary
29
by the department to ensure the safety of any
30
patient suffering complications as a result of
31
the administration of the drug or chemical in
32
question. No complication plan shall be
33
required where the patient is administered the
34
drug in a medical emergency at a hospital and is
35
then treated as an inpatient at a hospital under
36
medical monitoring by the hospital until the
37
abortion is completed.
38
3. The department may adopt rules,
39
regulations, and standards governing
40
complication plans to ensure that patients
41
undergoing abortions induced by drugs or
42
chemicals have access to safe and reliable
43
care. Any rule or portion of a rule, as that
44
term is defined in section 536.010, that is
45
created under the authority delegated in this
46
section shall become effective only if it
47
complies with and is subject to all of the
48
provisions of chapter 536 and, if applicable,
49
section 536.028. This section and chapter 536
50
are nonseverable and if any of the powers vested
51
with the general assembly pursuant to chapter
52
536 to review, to delay the effective date, or
53
to disapprove and annul a rule are subsequently
54
held unconstitutional, then the grant of
55
rulemaking authority and any rule proposed or
56
adopted after October 24, 2017, shall be invalid
57
and void.]
58
[188.025. Every abortion performed at
1
sixteen weeks gestational age or later shall be
2
performed in a hospital.]
3
[188.026. 1. This section and sections
1
188.056, 188.057, and 188.058 shall be known and
2
SB 699
97
may be cited as the "Missouri Stands for the
3
Unborn Act".
4
2. In Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973),
5
certain information about the development of the
6
unborn child, human pregnancy, and the effects
7
of abortion was either not part of the record or
8
was not available at the time. Since 1973,
9
advances in medical and scientific technology
10
have greatly expanded our knowledge of prenatal
11
life and the effects of abortion on women. The
12
general assembly of this state finds:
13
(1) At conception, a new genetically
14
distinct human being is formed;
15
(2) The fact that the life of an
16
individual human being begins at conception has
17
long been recognized in Missouri law: "[T]he
18
child is, in truth, alive from the moment of
19
conception". State v. Emerich, 13 Mo. App. 492,
20
495 (1883), affirmed, 87 Mo. 110 (1885). Under
21
section 1.205, the general assembly has
22
recognized that the life of each human being
23
begins at conception and that unborn children
24
have protectable interests in life, health, and
25
well-being;
26
(3) The first prohibition of abortion in
27
Missouri was enacted in 1825. Since then, the
28
repeal and reenactment of prohibitions of
29
abortion have made distinctions with respect to
30
penalties for performing or inducing abortion on
31
the basis of "quickening"; however, the unborn
32
child was still protected from conception onward;
33
(4) In ruling that Missouri's prohibition
34
on abortion was constitutional in 1972, the
35
Missouri supreme court accepted as a stipulation
36
of the parties that "'[i]nfant Doe, Intervenor
37
Defendant in this case, and all other unborn
38
children have all the qualities and attributes
39
of adult human persons differing only in age or
40
maturity. Medically, human life is a continuum
41
from conception to death.'" Rodgers v. Danforth,
42
486 S.W.2d 258, 259 (1972);
43
(5) In Webster v. Reproductive Health
44
Services, 492 U.S. 490 (1989), the Supreme
45
Court, while considering the "preamble" that set
46
forth "findings" in section 1.205, stated: "We
47
think the extent to which the preamble's
48
language might be used to interpret other state
49
statutes or regulations is something that only
50
the courts of Missouri can definitively decide.
51
State law has offered protections to unborn
52
children in tort and probate law". Id. at 506.
53
Since Webster, Missouri courts have construed
54
section 1.205 and have consistently found that
55
an unborn child is a person for purposes of
56
Missouri's homicide and assault laws when the
57
unborn child's mother was killed or assaulted by
58
another person. Section 1.205 has even been
59
SB 699
98
found applicable to the manslaughter of an
60
unborn child who was eight weeks gestational age
61
or earlier. State v. Harrison, 390 S.W.3d 927
62
(Mo. Ct. App. 2013);
63
(6) In medicine, a special emphasis is
64
placed on the heartbeat. The heartbeat is a
65
discernible sign of life at every stage of human
66
existence. During the fifth week of gestational
67
age, an unborn child's heart begins to beat and
68
blood flow begins during the sixth week;
69
(7) Depending on the ultrasound equipment
70
being used, the unborn child's heartbeat can be
71
visually detected as early as six to eight weeks
72
gestational age. By about twelve weeks
73
gestational age, the unborn child's heartbeat
74
can consistently be made audible through the use
75
of a handheld Doppler fetal heart rate device;
76
(8) Confirmation of a pregnancy can be
77
indicated through the detection of the unborn
78
child's heartbeat, while the absence of a
79
heartbeat can be an indicator of the death of
80
the unborn child if the child has reached the
81
point of development when a heartbeat should be
82
detectable;
83
(9) Heart rate monitoring during pregnancy
84
and labor is utilized to measure the heart rate
85
and rhythm of the unborn child, at an average
86
rate between one hundred ten and one hundred
87
sixty beats per minute, and helps determine the
88
health of the unborn child;
89
(10) The Supreme Court in Roe discussed
90
"the difficult question of when life begins" and
91
wrote: "[p]hysicians and their scientific
92
colleagues have regarded [quickening] with less
93
interest and have tended to focus either upon
94
conception, upon live birth, or upon the interim
95
point at which the fetus becomes 'viable', that
96
is, potentially able to live outside the
97
mother's womb, albeit with artificial aid".
98
Roe, 410 U.S. at 160. Today, however,
99
physicians' and scientists' interests on life in
100
the womb also focus on other markers of
101
development in the unborn child, including, but
102
not limited to, presence of a heartbeat, brain
103
development, a viable pregnancy or viable
104
intrauterine pregnancy during the first
105
trimester of pregnancy, and the ability to
106
experience pain;
107
(11) In Planned Parenthood of Central
108
Missouri v. Danforth, 428 U.S. 52 (1976), the
109
Supreme Court noted that "we recognized in Roe
110
that viability was a matter of medical judgment,
111
skill, and technical ability, and we preserved
112
the flexibility of the term". Id. at 64. Due to
113
advances in medical technology and diagnoses,
114
present-day physicians and scientists now
115
describe the viability of an unborn child in an
116
SB 699
99
additional manner, by determining whether there
117
is a viable pregnancy or viable intrauterine
118
pregnancy during the first trimester of
119
pregnancy;
120
(12) While the overall risk of miscarriage
121
after clinical recognition of pregnancy is
122
twelve to fifteen percent, the incidence
123
decreases significantly if cardiac activity in
124
the unborn child has been confirmed. The
125
detection of a heartbeat in an unborn child is a
126
reliable indicator of a viable pregnancy and
127
that the unborn child will likely survive to
128
birth, especially if presenting for a prenatal
129
visit at eight weeks gestational age or later.
130
For asymptomatic women attending a first
131
prenatal visit between six and eleven weeks
132
gestational age where a heartbeat was confirmed
133
through an ultrasound, the subsequent risk of
134
miscarriage is one and six-tenths percent.
135
Although the risk is higher at six weeks
136
gestational age at nine and four-tenths percent,
137
it declines rapidly to one and five-tenths
138
percent at eight weeks gestational age, and less
139
than one percent at nine weeks gestational age
140
or later;
141
(13) The presence of a heartbeat in an
142
unborn child represents a more definable point
143
of ascertaining survivability than the ambiguous
144
concept of viability that has been adopted by
145
the Supreme Court, especially since if a
146
heartbeat is detected at eight weeks gestational
147
age or later in a normal pregnancy, there is
148
likely to be a viable pregnancy and there is a
149
high probability that the unborn child will
150
survive to birth;
151
(14) The placenta begins developing during
152
the early first trimester of pregnancy and
153
performs a respiratory function by making oxygen
154
supply to and carbon dioxide removal from the
155
unborn child possible later in the first
156
trimester and throughout the second and third
157
trimesters of pregnancy;
158
(15) By the fifth week of gestation, the
159
development of the brain of the unborn child is
160
underway. Brain waves have been measured and
161
recorded as early as the eighth week of
162
gestational age in children who were removed
163
during an ectopic pregnancy or hysterectomy.
164
Fetal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of an
165
unborn child's brain is used during the second
166
and third trimesters of pregnancy and brain
167
activity has been observed using MRI;
168
(16) Missouri law identifies the presence
169
of circulation, respiration, and brain function
170
as indicia of life under section 194.005, as the
171
presence of circulation, respiration, and brain
172
SB 699
100
function indicates that such person is not
173
legally dead, but is legally alive;
174
(17) Unborn children at eight weeks
175
gestational age show spontaneous movements, such
176
as a twitching of the trunk and developing
177
limbs. It has been reported that unborn
178
children at this stage show reflex responses to
179
touch. The perioral area is the first part of
180
the unborn child's body to respond to touch at
181
about eight weeks gestational age and by
182
fourteen weeks gestational age most of the
183
unborn child's body is responsive to touch;
184
(18) Peripheral cutaneous sensory
185
receptors, the receptors that feel pain, develop
186
early in the unborn child. They appear in the
187
perioral cutaneous area at around seven to eight
188
weeks gestational age, in the palmar regions at
189
ten to ten and a half weeks gestational age, the
190
abdominal wall at fifteen weeks gestational age,
191
and over all of the unborn child's body at
192
sixteen weeks gestational age;
193
(19) Substance P, a peptide that functions
194
as a neurotransmitter, especially in the
195
transmission of pain, is present in the dorsal
196
horn of the spinal cord of the unborn child at
197
eight to ten weeks gestational age.
198
Enkephalins, peptides that play a role in
199
neurotransmission and pain modulation, are
200
present in the dorsal horn at twelve to fourteen
201
weeks gestational age;
202
(20) When intrauterine needling is
203
performed on an unborn child at sixteen weeks
204
gestational age or later, the reaction to this
205
invasive stimulus is blood flow redistribution
206
to the brain. Increased blood flow to the brain
207
is the same type of stress response seen in a
208
born child and an adult;
209
(21) By sixteen weeks gestational age,
210
pain transmission from a peripheral receptor to
211
the cortex is possible in the unborn child;
212
(22) Physicians provide anesthesia during
213
in utero treatment of unborn children as early
214
as sixteen weeks gestational age for certain
215
procedures, including those to correct fetal
216
urinary tract obstruction. Anesthesia is
217
administered by ultrasound-guided injection into
218
the arm or leg of the unborn child;
219
(23) A leading textbook on prenatal
220
development of the human brain states, "It may
221
be concluded that, although nociperception (the
222
actual perception of pain) awaits the appearance
223
of consciousness, nociception (the experience of
224
pain) is present some time before birth. In the
225
absence of disproof, it is merely prudent to
226
assume that pain can be experienced even early
227
in prenatal life (Dr. J. Wisser, Zürich): the
228
fetus should be given the benefit of the
229
SB 699
101
doubt". Ronan O'Rahilly & Fabiola Müller. The
230
Embryonic Human Brain: An Atlas of
231
Developmental Stages (3d ed. 2005);
232
(24) By fourteen or fifteen weeks
233
gestational age or later, the predominant
234
abortion method in Missouri is dilation and
235
evacuation (D&E). The D&E abortion method
236
includes the dismemberment, disarticulation, and
237
exsanguination of the unborn child, causing the
238
unborn child's death;
239
(25) The Supreme Court acknowledged in
240
Gonzales v. Carhart, 550 U.S. 124, 160 (2007),
241
that "the standard D&E is in some respects as
242
brutal, if not more, than the intact D&E"
243
partial birth abortion method banned by Congress
244
and upheld as facially constitutional by the
245
Supreme Court, even though the federal ban was
246
applicable both before and after viability and
247
had no exception for the health of the mother;
248
(26) Missouri's ban on the partial birth
249
abortion method, section 565.300, is in effect
250
because of Gonzales v. Carhart and the Supreme
251
Court's subsequent decision in Nixon v.
252
Reproductive Health Services of Planned
253
Parenthood of the St. Louis Region, Inc., 550
254
U.S. 901 (2007), to vacate and remand to the
255
appellate court the prior invalidation of
256
section 565.300. Since section 565.300, like
257
Congress' ban on partial birth abortion, is
258
applicable both before and after viability,
259
there is ample precedent for the general
260
assembly to constitutionally prohibit the brutal
261
D&E abortion method at fourteen weeks
262
gestational age or later, even before the unborn
263
child is viable, with a medical emergency
264
exception;
265
(27) In Roper v. Simmons, 543 U.S. 551
266
(2005), the Supreme Court determined that
267
"evolving standards of decency" dictated that a
268
Missouri statute allowing the death penalty for
269
a conviction of murder in the first degree for a
270
person under eighteen years of age when the
271
crime was committed was unconstitutional under
272
the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments to the
273
United States Constitution because it violated
274
the prohibition against "cruel and unusual
275
punishments";
276
(28) In Bucklew v. Precythe, 139 S. Ct.
277
1112, 1123 (2019), the Supreme Court noted that
278
"'[d]isgusting' practices" like disemboweling
279
and quartering "readily qualified as 'cruel and
280
unusual', as a reader at the time of the Eighth
281
Amendment's adoption would have understood those
282
words";
283
(29) Evolving standards of decency dictate
284
that Missouri should prohibit the brutal and
285
painful D&E abortion method at fourteen weeks
286
SB 699
102
gestational age or later, with a medical
287
emergency exception, because if a comparable
288
method of killing was used on:
289
(a) A person convicted of murder in the
290
first degree, it would be cruel and unusual
291
punishment; or
292
(b) An animal, it would be unlawful under
293
state law because it would not be a humane
294
method, humane euthanasia, or humane killing of
295
certain animals under chapters 273 and 578;
296
(30) In Roper, the Supreme Court also
297
found that "[i]t is proper that we acknowledge
298
the overwhelming weight of international opinion
299
against the juvenile death penalty.... The
300
opinion of the world community, while not
301
controlling our outcome, does provide respected
302
and significant confirmation for our own
303
conclusions". Roper, 543 U.S. at 578. In its
304
opinion, the Supreme Court was instructed by
305
"international covenants prohibiting the
306
juvenile death penalty", such as the
307
International Covenant on Civil and Political
308
Rights, 999 U.N.T.S. 171. Id. at 577;
309
(31) The opinion of the world community,
310
reflected in the laws of the United Nation's 193-
311
member states and six other entities, is that in
312
most countries, most abortions are prohibited
313
after twelve weeks gestational age or later;
314
(32) The opinion of the world community is
315
also shared by most Americans, who believe that
316
most abortions in the second and third
317
trimesters of pregnancy should be illegal, based
318
on polling that has remained consistent since
319
1996;
320
(33) Abortion procedures performed later
321
in pregnancy have a higher medical risk for
322
women. Compared to an abortion at eight weeks
323
gestational age or earlier, the relative risk
324
increases exponentially at later gestational
325
ages. The relative risk of death for a pregnant
326
woman who had an abortion performed or induced
327
upon her at:
328
(a) Eleven to twelve weeks gestational age
329
is between three and four times higher than an
330
abortion at eight weeks gestational age or
331
earlier;
332
(b) Thirteen to fifteen weeks gestational
333
age is almost fifteen times higher than an
334
abortion at eight weeks gestational age or
335
earlier;
336
(c) Sixteen to twenty weeks gestational
337
age is almost thirty times higher than an
338
abortion at eight weeks gestational age or
339
earlier; and
340
(d) Twenty-one weeks gestational age or
341
later is more than seventy-five times higher
342
SB 699
103
than an abortion at eight weeks gestational age
343
or earlier;
344
(34) In addition to the short-term risks
345
of an abortion, studies have found that the long-
346
term physical and psychological consequences of
347
abortion for women include, but are not limited
348
to, an increased risk of preterm birth, low
349
birthweight babies, and placenta previa in
350
subsequent pregnancies, as well as serious
351
behavioral health issues. These risks increase
352
as abortions are performed or induced at later
353
gestational ages. These consequences of an
354
abortion have a detrimental effect not only on
355
women, their children, and their families, but
356
also on an already burdened health care system,
357
taxpayers, and the workforce;
358
(35) A large percentage of women who have
359
an abortion performed or induced upon them in
360
Missouri each year are at less than eight weeks
361
gestational age, a large majority are at less
362
than fourteen weeks gestational age, a larger
363
majority are at less than eighteen weeks
364
gestational age, and an even larger majority are
365
at less than twenty weeks gestational age. A
366
prohibition on performing or inducing an
367
abortion at eight weeks gestational age or
368
later, with a medical emergency exception, does
369
not amount to a substantial obstacle to a large
370
fraction of women for whom the prohibition is
371
relevant, which is pregnant women in Missouri
372
who are seeking an abortion while not
373
experiencing a medical emergency. The burden
374
that a prohibition on performing or inducing an
375
abortion at eight, fourteen, eighteen, or twenty
376
weeks gestational age or later, with a medical
377
emergency exception, might impose on abortion
378
access, is outweighed by the benefits conferred
379
upon the following:
380
(a) Women more advanced in pregnancy who
381
are at greater risk of harm from abortion;
382
(b) Unborn children at later stages of
383
development;
384
(c) The medical profession, by preserving
385
its integrity and fulfilling its commitment to
386
do no harm; and
387
(d) Society, by fostering respect for
388
human life, born and unborn, at all stages of
389
development, and by lessening societal tolerance
390
of violence against innocent human life;
391
(36) In Webster, the Supreme Court noted,
392
in upholding a Missouri statute, "that there may
393
be a 4-week error in estimating gestational
394
age". Webster, 492 U.S. at 516. Thus, an
395
unborn child thought to be eight weeks
396
gestational age might in fact be twelve weeks
397
gestational age, when an abortion poses a
398
greater risk to the woman and the unborn child
399
SB 699
104
is considerably more developed. An unborn child
400
at fourteen weeks gestational age might be
401
eighteen weeks gestational age and an unborn
402
child at eighteen weeks gestational age might be
403
twenty-two weeks gestational age, when an
404
abortion poses a greater risk to the woman, the
405
unborn child is considerably more developed, the
406
abortion method likely to be employed is more
407
brutal, and the risk of pain experienced by the
408
unborn child is greater. An unborn child at
409
twenty weeks gestational age might be twenty-
410
four weeks gestational age, when an abortion
411
poses a greater risk to the woman, the unborn
412
child is considerably more developed, the
413
abortion method likely to be employed is more
414
brutal, the risk of pain experienced by the
415
unborn child is greater, and the unborn child
416
may be viable.
417
3. The state of Missouri is bound by
418
Article VI, Clause 2 of the Constitution of the
419
United States that "all treaties made, or which
420
shall be made, under the authority of the United
421
States, shall be the supreme law of the land".
422
One such treaty is the International Covenant on
423
Civil and Political Rights, entered into force
424
on March 23, 1976, and adopted by the United
425
States on September 8, 1992. In ratifying the
426
Covenant, the United States declared that while
427
the provisions of Articles 1 through 27 of the
428
Covenant are not self-executing, the United
429
States' understanding is that state governments
430
share responsibility with the federal government
431
in implementing the Covenant.
432
4. Article 6, Paragraph 1, U.N.T.S. at
433
174, of the International Covenant on Civil and
434
Political Rights states, "Every human being has
435
the inherent right to life. This right shall be
436
protected by law. No one shall be arbitrarily
437
deprived of his life". The state of Missouri
438
takes seriously its obligation to comply with
439
the Covenant and to implement this paragraph as
440
it relates to the inherent right to life of
441
unborn human beings, protecting the rights of
442
unborn human beings by law, and ensuring that
443
such unborn human beings are not arbitrarily
444
deprived of life. The state of Missouri hereby
445
implements Article 6, Paragraph 1 of the
446
Covenant by the regulation of abortion in this
447
state.
448
5. The state of Missouri has interests
449
that include, but are not limited to:
450
(1) Protecting unborn children throughout
451
pregnancy and preserving and promoting their
452
lives from conception to birth;
453
(2) Encouraging childbirth over abortion;
454
(3) Ensuring respect for all human life
455
from conception to natural death;
456
SB 699
105
(4) Safeguarding an unborn child from the
457
serious harm of pain by an abortion method that
458
would cause the unborn child to experience pain
459
while she or he is being killed;
460
(5) Preserving the integrity of the
461
medical profession and regulating and
462
restricting practices that might cause the
463
medical profession or society as a whole to
464
become insensitive, even disdainful, to life.
465
This includes regulating and restricting
466
abortion methods that are not only brutal and
467
painful, but if allowed to continue, will
468
further coarsen society to the humanity of not
469
only unborn children, but all vulnerable and
470
innocent human life, making it increasingly
471
difficult to protect such life;
472
(6) Ending the incongruities in state law
473
by permitting some unborn children to be killed
474
by abortion, while requiring that unborn
475
children be protected in nonabortion
476
circumstances through, including, but not
477
limited to, homicide, assault, self-defense, and
478
defense of another statutes; laws guaranteeing
479
prenatal health care, emergency care, and
480
testing; state-sponsored health insurance for
481
unborn children; the prohibition of restraints
482
in correctional institutions to protect pregnant
483
offenders and their unborn children; and
484
protecting the interests of unborn children by
485
the appointment of conservators, guardians, and
486
representatives;
487
(7) Reducing the risks of harm to pregnant
488
women who obtain abortions later in pregnancy;
489
and
490
(8) Avoiding burdens on the health care
491
system, taxpayers, and the workforce because of
492
increased preterm births, low birthweight
493
babies, compromised pregnancies, extended
494
postpartum recoveries, and behavioral health
495
problems caused by the long-term effects of
496
abortions performed or induced later in the
497
pregnancy.]
498
[188.027. 1. Except in cases of medical
1
emergency, no abortion shall be performed or
2
induced on a woman without her voluntary and
3
informed consent, given freely and without
4
coercion. Consent to an abortion is voluntary
5
and informed and given freely and without
6
coercion if, and only if, at least seventy-two
7
hours prior to the abortion:
8
(1) The physician who is to perform or
9
induce the abortion, a qualified professional,
10
or the referring physician has informed the
11
woman orally, reduced to writing, and in person,
12
of the following:
13
SB 699
106
(a) The name of the physician who will
14
perform or induce the abortion;
15
(b) Medically accurate information that a
16
reasonable patient would consider material to
17
the decision of whether or not to undergo the
18
abortion, including:
19
a. A description of the proposed abortion
20
method;
21
b. The immediate and long-term medical
22
risks to the woman associated with the proposed
23
abortion method including, but not limited to,
24
infection, hemorrhage, cervical tear or uterine
25
perforation, harm to subsequent pregnancies or
26
the ability to carry a subsequent child to term,
27
and possible adverse psychological effects
28
associated with the abortion; and
29
c. The immediate and long-term medical
30
risks to the woman, in light of the anesthesia
31
and medication that is to be administered, the
32
unborn child's gestational age, and the woman's
33
medical history and medical condition;
34
(c) Alternatives to the abortion which
35
shall include making the woman aware that
36
information and materials shall be provided to
37
her detailing such alternatives to the abortion;
38
(d) A statement that the physician
39
performing or inducing the abortion is available
40
for any questions concerning the abortion,
41
together with the telephone number that the
42
physician may be later reached to answer any
43
questions that the woman may have;
44
(e) The location of the hospital that
45
offers obstetrical or gynecological care located
46
within thirty miles of the location where the
47
abortion is performed or induced and at which
48
the physician performing or inducing the
49
abortion has clinical privileges and where the
50
woman may receive follow-up care by the
51
physician if complications arise;
52
(f) The gestational age of the unborn
53
child at the time the abortion is to be
54
performed or induced; and
55
(g) The anatomical and physiological
56
characteristics of the unborn child at the time
57
the abortion is to be performed or induced;
58
(2) The physician who is to perform or
59
induce the abortion or a qualified professional
60
has presented the woman, in person, printed
61
materials provided by the department, which
62
describe the probable anatomical and
63
physiological characteristics of the unborn
64
child at two-week gestational increments from
65
conception to full term, including color
66
photographs or images of the developing unborn
67
child at two-week gestational increments. Such
68
descriptions shall include information about
69
brain and heart functions, the presence of
70
SB 699
107
external members and internal organs during the
71
applicable stages of development and information
72
on when the unborn child is viable. The printed
73
materials shall prominently display the
74
following statement: "The life of each human
75
being begins at conception. Abortion will
76
terminate the life of a separate, unique, living
77
human being.";
78
(3) The physician who is to perform or
79
induce the abortion, a qualified professional,
80
or the referring physician has presented the
81
woman, in person, printed materials provided by
82
the department, which describe the various
83
surgical and drug-induced methods of abortion
84
relevant to the stage of pregnancy, as well as
85
the immediate and long-term medical risks
86
commonly associated with each abortion method
87
including, but not limited to, infection,
88
hemorrhage, cervical tear or uterine
89
perforation, harm to subsequent pregnancies or
90
the ability to carry a subsequent child to term,
91
and the possible adverse psychological effects
92
associated with an abortion;
93
(4) The physician who is to perform or
94
induce the abortion or a qualified professional
95
shall provide the woman with the opportunity to
96
view at least seventy-two hours prior to the
97
abortion an active ultrasound of the unborn
98
child and hear the heartbeat of the unborn child
99
if the heartbeat is audible. The woman shall be
100
provided with a geographically indexed list
101
maintained by the department of health care
102
providers, facilities, and clinics that perform
103
ultrasounds, including those that offer
104
ultrasound services free of charge. Such
105
materials shall provide contact information for
106
each provider, facility, or clinic including
107
telephone numbers and, if available, website
108
addresses. Should the woman decide to obtain an
109
ultrasound from a provider, facility, or clinic
110
other than the abortion facility, the woman
111
shall be offered a reasonable time to obtain the
112
ultrasound examination before the date and time
113
set for performing or inducing an abortion. The
114
person conducting the ultrasound shall ensure
115
that the active ultrasound image is of a quality
116
consistent with standard medical practice in the
117
community, contains the dimensions of the unborn
118
child, and accurately portrays the presence of
119
external members and internal organs, if present
120
or viewable, of the unborn child. The
121
auscultation of fetal heart tone must also be of
122
a quality consistent with standard medical
123
practice in the community. If the woman chooses
124
to view the ultrasound or hear the heartbeat or
125
both at the abortion facility, the viewing or
126
hearing or both shall be provided to her at the
127
SB 699
108
abortion facility at least seventy-two hours
128
prior to the abortion being performed or induced;
129
(5) The printed materials provided by the
130
department shall include information on the
131
possibility of an abortion causing pain in the
132
unborn child. This information shall include,
133
but need not be limited to, the following:
134
(a) Unborn children as early as eight
135
weeks gestational age start to show spontaneous
136
movements and unborn children at this stage in
137
pregnancy show reflex responses to touch;
138
(b) In the unborn child, the area around
139
his or her mouth and lips is the first part of
140
the unborn child's body to respond to touch and
141
by fourteen weeks gestational age most of the
142
unborn child's body is responsive to touch;
143
(c) Pain receptors on the unborn child's
144
skin develop around his or her mouth at around
145
seven to eight weeks gestational age, around the
146
palms of his or her hands at ten to ten and a
147
half weeks, on the abdominal wall at fifteen
148
weeks, and over all of his or her body at
149
sixteen weeks gestational age;
150
(d) Beginning at sixteen weeks gestational
151
age and later, it is possible for pain to be
152
transmitted from receptors to the cortex of the
153
unborn child's brain, where thinking and
154
perceiving occur;
155
(e) When a physician performs a life-
156
saving surgery, he or she provides anesthesia to
157
unborn children as young as sixteen weeks
158
gestational age in order to alleviate the unborn
159
child's pain; and
160
(f) A description of the actual steps in
161
the abortion procedure to be performed or
162
induced and at which steps the abortion
163
procedure could be painful to the unborn child;
164
(6) The physician who is to perform or
165
induce the abortion or a qualified professional
166
has presented the woman, in person, printed
167
materials provided by the department explaining
168
to the woman alternatives to abortion she may
169
wish to consider. Such materials shall:
170
(a) Identify on a geographical basis
171
public and private agencies available to assist
172
a woman in carrying her unborn child to term,
173
and to assist her in caring for her dependent
174
child or placing her child for adoption,
175
including agencies commonly known and generally
176
referred to as pregnancy resource centers,
177
crisis pregnancy centers, maternity homes, and
178
adoption agencies. Such materials shall provide
179
a comprehensive list by geographical area of the
180
agencies, a description of the services they
181
offer, and the telephone numbers and addresses
182
of the agencies; provided that such materials
183
shall not include any programs, services,
184
SB 699
109
organizations, or affiliates of organizations
185
that perform or induce, or assist in the
186
performing or inducing of, abortions or that
187
refer for abortions;
188
(b) Explain the Missouri alternatives to
189
abortion services program under section 188.325,
190
and any other programs and services available to
191
pregnant women and mothers of newborn children
192
offered by public or private agencies which
193
assist a woman in carrying her unborn child to
194
term and assist her in caring for her dependent
195
child or placing her child for adoption,
196
including but not limited to prenatal care;
197
maternal health care; newborn or infant care;
198
mental health services; professional counseling
199
services; housing programs; utility assistance;
200
transportation services; food, clothing, and
201
supplies related to pregnancy; parenting skills;
202
educational programs; job training and placement
203
services; drug and alcohol testing and
204
treatment; and adoption assistance;
205
(c) Identify the state website for the
206
Missouri alternatives to abortion services
207
program under section 188.325, and any toll-free
208
number established by the state operated in
209
conjunction with the program;
210
(d) Prominently display the statement:
211
"There are public and private agencies willing
212
and able to help you carry your child to term,
213
and to assist you and your child after your
214
child is born, whether you choose to keep your
215
child or place him or her for adoption. The
216
state of Missouri encourages you to contact
217
those agencies before making a final decision
218
about abortion. State law requires that your
219
physician or a qualified professional give you
220
the opportunity to call agencies like these
221
before you undergo an abortion.";
222
(7) The physician who is to perform or
223
induce the abortion or a qualified professional
224
has presented the woman, in person, printed
225
materials provided by the department explaining
226
that the father of the unborn child is liable to
227
assist in the support of the child, even in
228
instances where he has offered to pay for the
229
abortion. Such materials shall include
230
information on the legal duties and support
231
obligations of the father of a child, including,
232
but not limited to, child support payments, and
233
the fact that paternity may be established by
234
the father's name on a birth certificate or
235
statement of paternity, or by court action.
236
Such printed materials shall also state that
237
more information concerning paternity
238
establishment and child support services and
239
enforcement may be obtained by calling the
240
SB 699
110
family support division within the Missouri
241
department of social services; and
242
(8) The physician who is to perform or
243
induce the abortion or a qualified professional
244
shall inform the woman that she is free to
245
withhold or withdraw her consent to the abortion
246
at any time without affecting her right to
247
future care or treatment and without the loss of
248
any state or federally funded benefits to which
249
she might otherwise be entitled.
250
2. All information required to be provided
251
to a woman considering abortion by subsection 1
252
of this section shall be presented to the woman
253
individually, in the physical presence of the
254
woman and in a private room, to protect her
255
privacy, to maintain the confidentiality of her
256
decision, to ensure that the information focuses
257
on her individual circumstances, to ensure she
258
has an adequate opportunity to ask questions,
259
and to ensure that she is not a victim of
260
coerced abortion. Should a woman be unable to
261
read materials provided to her, they shall be
262
read to her. Should a woman need an interpreter
263
to understand the information presented in the
264
written materials, an interpreter shall be
265
provided to her. Should a woman ask questions
266
concerning any of the information or materials,
267
answers shall be provided in a language she can
268
understand.
269
3. No abortion shall be performed or
270
induced unless and until the woman upon whom the
271
abortion is to be performed or induced certifies
272
in writing on a checklist form provided by the
273
department that she has been presented all the
274
information required in subsection 1 of this
275
section, that she has been provided the
276
opportunity to view an active ultrasound image
277
of the unborn child and hear the heartbeat of
278
the unborn child if it is audible, and that she
279
further certifies that she gives her voluntary
280
and informed consent, freely and without
281
coercion, to the abortion procedure.
282
4. No physician shall perform or induce an
283
abortion unless and until the physician has
284
obtained from the woman her voluntary and
285
informed consent given freely and without
286
coercion. If the physician has reason to
287
believe that the woman is being coerced into
288
having an abortion, the physician or qualified
289
professional shall inform the woman that
290
services are available for her and shall provide
291
her with private access to a telephone and
292
information about such services, including but
293
not limited to the following:
294
(1) Rape crisis centers, as defined in
295
section 455.003;
296
SB 699
111
(2) Shelters for victims of domestic
297
violence, as defined in section 455.200; and
298
(3) Orders of protection, pursuant to
299
chapter 455.
300
5. The physician who is to perform or
301
induce the abortion shall, at least seventy-two
302
hours prior to such procedure, inform the woman
303
orally and in person of:
304
(1) The immediate and long-term medical
305
risks to the woman associated with the proposed
306
abortion method including, but not limited to,
307
infection, hemorrhage, cervical tear or uterine
308
perforation, harm to subsequent pregnancies or
309
the ability to carry a subsequent child to term,
310
and possible adverse psychological effects
311
associated with the abortion; and
312
(2) The immediate and long-term medical
313
risks to the woman, in light of the anesthesia
314
and medication that is to be administered, the
315
unborn child's gestational age, and the woman's
316
medical history and medical conditions.
317
6. No physician shall perform or induce an
318
abortion unless and until the physician has
319
received and signed a copy of the form
320
prescribed in subsection 3 of this section. The
321
physician shall retain a copy of the form in the
322
patient's medical record.
323
7. In the event of a medical emergency,
324
the physician who performed or induced the
325
abortion shall clearly certify in writing the
326
nature and circumstances of the medical
327
emergency. This certification shall be signed
328
by the physician who performed or induced the
329
abortion, and shall be maintained under section
330
188.060.
331
8. No person or entity shall require,
332
obtain, or accept payment for an abortion from
333
or on behalf of a patient until at least seventy-
334
two hours have passed since the time that the
335
information required by subsection 1 of this
336
section has been provided to the patient.
337
Nothing in this subsection shall prohibit a
338
person or entity from notifying the patient that
339
payment for the abortion will be required after
340
the seventy-two-hour period has expired if she
341
voluntarily chooses to have the abortion.
342
9. The term "qualified professional" as
343
used in this section shall refer to a physician,
344
physician assistant, registered nurse, licensed
345
practical nurse, psychologist, licensed
346
professional counselor, or licensed social
347
worker, licensed or registered under chapter
348
334, 335, or 337, acting under the supervision
349
of the physician performing or inducing the
350
abortion, and acting within the course and scope
351
of his or her authority provided by law. The
352
provisions of this section shall not be
353
SB 699
112
construed to in any way expand the authority
354
otherwise provided by law relating to the
355
licensure, registration, or scope of practice of
356
any such qualified professional.
357
10. By November 30, 2010, the department
358
shall produce the written materials and forms
359
described in this section. Any written
360
materials produced shall be printed in a
361
typeface large enough to be clearly legible.
362
All information shall be presented in an
363
objective, unbiased manner designed to convey
364
only accurate scientific and medical
365
information. The department shall furnish the
366
written materials and forms at no cost and in
367
sufficient quantity to any person who performs
368
or induces abortions, or to any hospital or
369
facility that provides abortions. The
370
department shall make all information required
371
by subsection 1 of this section available to the
372
public through its department website. The
373
department shall maintain a toll-free, twenty-
374
four-hour hotline telephone number where a
375
caller can obtain information on a regional
376
basis concerning the agencies and services
377
described in subsection 1 of this section. No
378
identifying information regarding persons who
379
use the website shall be collected or
380
maintained. The department shall monitor the
381
website on a regular basis to prevent tampering
382
and correct any operational deficiencies.
383
11. In order to preserve the compelling
384
interest of the state to ensure that the choice
385
to consent to an abortion is voluntary and
386
informed, and given freely and without coercion,
387
the department shall use the procedures for
388
adoption of emergency rules under section
389
536.025 in order to promulgate all necessary
390
rules, forms, and other necessary material to
391
implement this section by November 30, 2010.
392
12. If the provisions in subsections 1 and
393
8 of this section requiring a seventy-two-hour
394
waiting period for an abortion are ever
395
temporarily or permanently restrained or
396
enjoined by judicial order, then the waiting
397
period for an abortion shall be twenty-four
398
hours; provided, however, that if such temporary
399
or permanent restraining order or injunction is
400
stayed or dissolved, or otherwise ceases to have
401
effect, the waiting period for an abortion shall
402
be seventy-two hours.]
403
[188.028. 1. Except in the case of a
1
medical emergency, no person shall knowingly
2
perform or induce an abortion upon a pregnant
3
woman under the age of eighteen years unless:
4
(1) The attending physician has secured
5
the informed written consent of the minor and
6
SB 699
113
one parent or guardian, and the consenting
7
parent or guardian of the minor has notified any
8
other custodial parent in writing prior to the
9
securing of the informed written consent of the
10
minor and one parent or guardian. For purposes
11
of this subdivision, "custodial parent" shall
12
only mean a parent of a minor who has been
13
awarded joint legal custody or joint physical
14
custody of such minor by a court of competent
15
jurisdiction. Notice shall not be required for
16
any parent:
17
(a) Who has been found guilty of any
18
offense in violation of chapter 565, relating to
19
offenses against the person; chapter 566,
20
relating to sexual offenses; chapter 567,
21
relating to prostitution; chapter 568, relating
22
to offenses against the family; or chapter 573,
23
related to pornography and related offenses, if
24
a child was a victim;
25
(b) Who has been found guilty of any
26
offense in any other state or foreign country,
27
or under federal, tribal, or military
28
jurisdiction if a child was a victim, which
29
would be a violation of chapters 565, 566, 567,
30
568, or 573 if committed in this state;
31
(c) Who is listed on the sexual offender
32
registry under sections 589.400 to 589.425;
33
(d) Against whom an order of protection
34
has been issued, including a foreign order of
35
protection given full faith and credit in this
36
state under section 455.067;
37
(e) Whose custodial, parental, or
38
guardianship rights have been terminated by a
39
court of competent jurisdiction; or
40
(f) Whose whereabouts are unknown after
41
reasonable inquiry, who is a fugitive from
42
justice, who is habitually in an intoxicated or
43
drugged condition, or who has been declared
44
mentally incompetent or incapacitated by a court
45
of competent jurisdiction;
46
(2) The minor is emancipated and the
47
attending physician has received the informed
48
written consent of the minor;
49
(3) The minor has been granted the right
50
to self-consent to the abortion by court order
51
pursuant to subsection 2 of this section, and
52
the attending physician has received the
53
informed written consent of the minor; or
54
(4) The minor has been granted consent to
55
the abortion by court order, and the court has
56
given its informed written consent in accordance
57
with subsection 2 of this section, and the minor
58
is having the abortion willingly, in compliance
59
with subsection 3 of this section.
60
2. The right of a minor to self-consent to
61
an abortion under subdivision (3) of subsection
62
1 of this section or court consent under
63
SB 699
114
subdivision (4) of subsection 1 of this section
64
may be granted by a court pursuant to the
65
following procedures:
66
(1) The minor or next friend shall make an
67
application to the juvenile court which shall
68
assist the minor or next friend in preparing the
69
petition and notices required pursuant to this
70
section. The minor or the next friend of the
71
minor shall thereafter file a petition setting
72
forth the initials of the minor; the age of the
73
minor; the names and addresses of each parent,
74
guardian, or, if the minor's parents are
75
deceased and no guardian has been appointed, any
76
other person standing in loco parentis of the
77
minor; that the minor has been fully informed of
78
the risks and consequences of the abortion; that
79
the minor is of sound mind and has sufficient
80
intellectual capacity to consent to the
81
abortion; that, if the court does not grant the
82
minor majority rights for the purpose of consent
83
to the abortion, the court should find that the
84
abortion is in the best interest of the minor
85
and give judicial consent to the abortion; that
86
the court should appoint a guardian ad litem of
87
the child; and if the minor does not have
88
private counsel, that the court should appoint
89
counsel. The petition shall be signed by the
90
minor or the next friend;
91
(2) A hearing on the merits of the
92
petition, to be held on the record, shall be
93
held as soon as possible within five days of the
94
filing of the petition. If any party is unable
95
to afford counsel, the court shall appoint
96
counsel at least twenty-four hours before the
97
time of the hearing. At the hearing, the court
98
shall hear evidence relating to the emotional
99
development, maturity, intellect and
100
understanding of the minor; the nature, possible
101
consequences, and alternatives to the abortion;
102
and any other evidence that the court may find
103
useful in determining whether the minor should
104
be granted majority rights for the purpose of
105
consenting to the abortion or whether the
106
abortion is in the best interests of the minor;
107
(3) In the decree, the court shall for
108
good cause:
109
(a) Grant the petition for majority rights
110
for the purpose of consenting to the abortion;
111
(b) Find the abortion to be in the best
112
interests of the minor and give judicial consent
113
to the abortion, setting forth the grounds for
114
so finding; or
115
(c) Deny the petition, setting forth the
116
grounds on which the petition is denied;
117
(4) If the petition is allowed, the
118
informed consent of the minor, pursuant to a
119
court grant of majority rights, or the judicial
120
SB 699
115
consent, shall bar an action by the parents or
121
guardian of the minor on the grounds of battery
122
of the minor by those performing or inducing the
123
abortion. The immunity granted shall only
124
extend to the performance or induction of the
125
abortion in accordance herewith and any
126
necessary accompanying services which are
127
performed in a competent manner. The costs of
128
the action shall be borne by the parties;
129
(5) An appeal from an order issued under
130
the provisions of this section may be taken to
131
the court of appeals of this state by the minor
132
or by a parent or guardian of the minor. The
133
notice of intent to appeal shall be given within
134
twenty-four hours from the date of issuance of
135
the order. The record on appeal shall be
136
completed and the appeal shall be perfected
137
within five days from the filing of notice to
138
appeal. Because time may be of the essence
139
regarding the performance or induction of the
140
abortion, the supreme court of this state shall,
141
by court rule, provide for expedited appellate
142
review of cases appealed under this section.
143
3. If a minor desires an abortion, then
144
she shall be orally informed of and, if
145
possible, sign the written consent required
146
under this chapter in the same manner as an
147
adult person. No abortion shall be performed or
148
induced on any minor against her will, except
149
that an abortion may be performed or induced
150
against the will of a minor pursuant to a court
151
order described in subdivision (4) of subsection
152
1 of this section that the abortion is necessary
153
to preserve the life of the minor.]
154
[188.030. 1. Except in the case of a
1
medical emergency, no abortion of a viable
2
unborn child shall be performed or induced
3
unless the abortion is necessary to preserve the
4
life of the pregnant woman whose life is
5
endangered by a physical disorder, physical
6
illness, or physical injury, including a life-
7
endangering physical condition caused by or
8
arising from the pregnancy itself, or when
9
continuation of the pregnancy will create a
10
serious risk of substantial and irreversible
11
physical impairment of a major bodily function
12
of the pregnant woman. For purposes of this
13
section, "major bodily function" includes, but
14
is not limited to, functions of the immune
15
system, normal cell growth, digestive, bowel,
16
bladder, neurological, brain, respiratory,
17
circulatory, endocrine, and reproductive
18
functions.
19
2. Except in the case of a medical
20
emergency:
21
SB 699
116
(1) Prior to performing or inducing an
22
abortion upon a woman, the physician shall
23
determine the gestational age of the unborn
24
child in a manner consistent with accepted
25
obstetrical and neonatal practices and
26
standards. In making such determination, the
27
physician shall make such inquiries of the
28
pregnant woman and perform or cause to be
29
performed such medical examinations, imaging
30
studies, and tests as a reasonably prudent
31
physician, knowledgeable about the medical facts
32
and conditions of both the woman and the unborn
33
child involved, would consider necessary to
34
perform and consider in making an accurate
35
diagnosis with respect to gestational age;
36
(2) If the physician determines that the
37
gestational age of the unborn child is twenty
38
weeks or more, prior to performing or inducing
39
an abortion upon the woman, the physician shall
40
determine if the unborn child is viable by using
41
and exercising that degree of care, skill, and
42
proficiency commonly exercised by a skillful,
43
careful, and prudent physician. In making this
44
determination of viability, the physician shall
45
perform or cause to be performed such medical
46
examinations and tests as are necessary to make
47
a finding of the gestational age, weight, and
48
lung maturity of the unborn child and shall
49
enter such findings and determination of
50
viability in the medical record of the woman;
51
(3) If the physician determines that the
52
gestational age of the unborn child is twenty
53
weeks or more, and further determines that the
54
unborn child is not viable and performs or
55
induces an abortion upon the woman, the
56
physician shall report such findings and
57
determinations and the reasons for such
58
determinations to the health care facility in
59
which the abortion is performed and to the state
60
board of registration for the healing arts, and
61
shall enter such findings and determinations in
62
the medical records of the woman and in the
63
individual abortion report submitted to the
64
department under section 188.052;
65
(4) (a) If the physician determines that
66
the unborn child is viable, the physician shall
67
not perform or induce an abortion upon the woman
68
unless the abortion is necessary to preserve the
69
life of the pregnant woman or that a
70
continuation of the pregnancy will create a
71
serious risk of substantial and irreversible
72
physical impairment of a major bodily function
73
of the woman.
74
(b) Before a physician may proceed with
75
performing or inducing an abortion upon a woman
76
when it has been determined that the unborn
77
child is viable, the physician shall first
78
SB 699
117
certify in writing the medical threat posed to
79
the life of the pregnant woman, or the medical
80
reasons that continuation of the pregnancy would
81
cause a serious risk of substantial and
82
irreversible physical impairment of a major
83
bodily function of the pregnant woman. Upon
84
completion of the abortion, the physician shall
85
report the reasons and determinations for the
86
abortion of a viable unborn child to the health
87
care facility in which the abortion is performed
88
and to the state board of registration for the
89
healing arts, and shall enter such findings and
90
determinations in the medical record of the
91
woman and in the individual abortion report
92
submitted to the department under section
93
188.052.
94
(c) Before a physician may proceed with
95
performing or inducing an abortion upon a woman
96
when it has been determined that the unborn
97
child is viable, the physician who is to perform
98
the abortion shall obtain the agreement of a
99
second physician with knowledge of accepted
100
obstetrical and neonatal practices and standards
101
who shall concur that the abortion is necessary
102
to preserve the life of the pregnant woman, or
103
that continuation of the pregnancy would cause a
104
serious risk of substantial and irreversible
105
physical impairment of a major bodily function
106
of the pregnant woman. This second physician
107
shall also report such reasons and
108
determinations to the health care facility in
109
which the abortion is to be performed and to the
110
state board of registration for the healing
111
arts, and shall enter such findings and
112
determinations in the medical record of the
113
woman and the individual abortion report
114
submitted to the department under section
115
188.052. The second physician shall not have
116
any legal or financial affiliation or
117
relationship with the physician performing or
118
inducing the abortion, except that such
119
prohibition shall not apply to physicians whose
120
legal or financial affiliation or relationship
121
is a result of being employed by or having staff
122
privileges at the same hospital as the term
123
"hospital" is defined in section 197.020.
124
(d) Any physician who performs or induces
125
an abortion upon a woman when it has been
126
determined that the unborn child is viable shall
127
utilize the available method or technique of
128
abortion most likely to preserve the life or
129
health of the unborn child. In cases where the
130
method or technique of abortion most likely to
131
preserve the life or health of the unborn child
132
would present a greater risk to the life or
133
health of the woman than another legally
134
permitted and available method or technique, the
135
SB 699
118
physician may utilize such other method or
136
technique. In all cases where the physician
137
performs an abortion upon a viable unborn child,
138
the physician shall certify in writing the
139
available method or techniques considered and
140
the reasons for choosing the method or technique
141
employed.
142
(e) No physician shall perform or induce
143
an abortion upon a woman when it has been
144
determined that the unborn child is viable
145
unless there is in attendance a physician other
146
than the physician performing or inducing the
147
abortion who shall take control of and provide
148
immediate medical care for a child born as a
149
result of the abortion. During the performance
150
of the abortion, the physician performing it,
151
and subsequent to the abortion, the physician
152
required to be in attendance, shall take all
153
reasonable steps in keeping with good medical
154
practice, consistent with the procedure used, to
155
preserve the life or health of the viable unborn
156
child; provided that it does not pose an
157
increased risk to the life of the woman or does
158
not pose an increased risk of substantial and
159
irreversible physical impairment of a major
160
bodily function of the woman.
161
3. Any person who knowingly performs or
162
induces an abortion of an unborn child in
163
violation of the provisions of this section is
164
guilty of a class D felony, and, upon a finding
165
of guilt or plea of guilty, shall be imprisoned
166
for a term of not less than one year, and,
167
notwithstanding the provisions of section
168
558.002, shall be fined not less than ten
169
thousand nor more than fifty thousand dollars.
170
4. Any physician who pleads guilty to or
171
is found guilty of performing or inducing an
172
abortion of an unborn child in violation of this
173
section shall be subject to suspension or
174
revocation of his or her license to practice
175
medicine in the state of Missouri by the state
176
board of registration for the healing arts under
177
the provisions of sections 334.100 and 334.103.
178
5. Any hospital licensed in the state of
179
Missouri that knowingly allows an abortion of an
180
unborn child to be performed or induced in
181
violation of this section may be subject to
182
suspension or revocation of its license under
183
the provisions of section 197.070.
184
6. Any abortion facility licensed in the
185
state of Missouri that knowingly allows an
186
abortion of an unborn child to be performed or
187
induced in violation of this section may be
188
subject to suspension or revocation of its
189
license under the provisions of section 197.220.
190
7. A woman upon whom an abortion is
191
performed or induced in violation of this
192
SB 699
119
section shall not be prosecuted for a conspiracy
193
to violate the provisions of this section.
194
8. Nothing in this section shall be
195
construed as creating or recognizing a right to
196
abortion, nor is it the intention of this
197
section to make lawful any abortion that is
198
currently unlawful.
199
9. It is the intent of the legislature
200
that this section be severable as noted in
201
section 1.140. In the event that any section,
202
subsection, subdivision, paragraph, sentence, or
203
clause of this section be declared invalid under
204
the Constitution of the United States or the
205
Constitution of the State of Missouri, it is the
206
intent of the legislature that the remaining
207
provisions of this section remain in force and
208
effect as far as capable of being carried into
209
execution as intended by the legislature.
210
10. The general assembly may, by
211
concurrent resolution, appoint one or more of
212
its members who sponsored or co-sponsored this
213
act in his or her official capacity to intervene
214
as a matter of right in any case in which the
215
constitutionality of this law is challenged.]
216
[188.031. For purposes of section 188.028,
1
the term "next friend" shall not include another
2
minor child, or any entity or person in an
3
individual or representative capacity that has a
4
financial interest or potential gain from the
5
proposed abortion, or any employee of or
6
volunteer for such entity or person.]
7
[188.033. Whenever an abortion facility or
1
a family planning agency located in this state,
2
or any of its agents or employees acting within
3
the scope of his or her authority or employment,
4
provides to a woman considering an abortion the
5
name, address, telephone number, or website of
6
an abortion provider that is located outside of
7
the state, such abortion facility or family
8
planning agency or its agents or employees shall
9
also provide to such woman the printed materials
10
produced by the department under section
11
188.027. If the name, address, telephone
12
number, or website of such abortion provider is
13
not provided to such woman in person, such
14
printed materials shall be offered to her, and
15
if she chooses, sent to such woman at no cost to
16
her the same day or as soon as possible either
17
electronically or by U.S. mail overnight
18
delivery service or by other overnight or same-
19
day delivery service to an address of such
20
woman's choosing. The department shall furnish
21
such printed materials at no cost and in
22
sufficient quantities to abortion facilities and
23
family planning agencies located within the
24
state.]
25
SB 699
120
[188.035. Whoever, with intent to do so,
1
shall take the life of a child aborted alive,
2
shall be guilty of murder of the second degree.]
3
[188.036. 1. No physician shall perform
1
an abortion on a woman if the physician knows
2
that the woman conceived the unborn child for
3
the purpose of providing fetal organs or tissue
4
for medical transplantation to herself or
5
another, and the physician knows that the woman
6
intends to procure the abortion to utilize those
7
organs or tissue for such use for herself or
8
another.
9
2. No person shall utilize the fetal
10
organs or tissue resulting from an abortion for
11
medical transplantation, if the person knows
12
that the abortion was procured for the purpose
13
of utilizing those organs or tissue for such use.
14
3. No person shall offer any inducement,
15
monetary or otherwise, to a woman or a
16
prospective father of an unborn child for the
17
purpose of conceiving an unborn child for the
18
medical, scientific, experimental or therapeutic
19
use of the fetal organs or tissue.
20
4. No person shall offer any inducement,
21
monetary or otherwise, to the mother or father
22
of an unborn child for the purpose of procuring
23
an abortion for the medical, scientific,
24
experimental or therapeutic use of the fetal
25
organs or tissue.
26
5. No person shall knowingly offer or
27
receive any valuable consideration for the fetal
28
organs or tissue resulting from an abortion,
29
provided that nothing in this subsection shall
30
prohibit payment for burial or other final
31
disposition of the fetal remains, or payment for
32
a pathological examination, autopsy or
33
postmortem examination of the fetal remains.
34
6. If any provision in this section or the
35
application thereof to any person, circumstance
36
or period of gestation is held invalid, such
37
invalidity shall not affect the provisions or
38
applications which can be given effect without
39
the invalid provision or application, and to
40
this end the provisions of this section are
41
declared severable.]
42
[188.038. 1. The general assembly of this
1
state finds that:
2
(1) Removing vestiges of any past bias or
3
discrimination against pregnant women, their
4
partners, and their family members, including
5
their unborn children, is an important task for
6
those in the legal, medical, social services,
7
and human services professions;
8
(2) Ending any current bias or
9
discrimination against pregnant women, their
10
partners, and their family members, including
11
SB 699
121
their unborn children, is a legitimate purpose
12
of government in order to guarantee that those
13
who "are endowed by their Creator with certain
14
unalienable Rights" can enjoy "Life, Liberty and
15
the pursuit of Happiness";
16
(3) The historical relationship of bias or
17
discrimination by some family planning programs
18
and policies towards poor and minority
19
populations, including, but not limited to, the
20
nonconsensual sterilization of mentally ill,
21
poor, minority, and immigrant women and other
22
coercive family planning programs and policies,
23
must be rejected;
24
(4) Among Missouri residents, the rate of
25
black or African-American women who undergo
26
abortions is significantly higher, about three
27
and one-half times higher, than the rate of
28
white women who undergo abortions. Among
29
Missouri residents, the rate of black or African-
30
American women who undergo repeat abortions is
31
significantly higher, about one and one-half
32
times higher, than the rate of white women who
33
undergo repeat abortions;
34
(5) Performing or inducing an abortion
35
because of the sex of the unborn child is
36
repugnant to the values of equality of females
37
and males and the same opportunities for girls
38
and boys, and furthers a false mindset of female
39
inferiority;
40
(6) Government has a legitimate interest
41
in preventing the abortion of unborn children
42
with Down Syndrome because it is a form of bias
43
or disability discrimination and victimizes the
44
disabled unborn child at his or her most
45
vulnerable stage. Eliminating unborn children
46
with Down Syndrome raises grave concerns for the
47
lives of those who do live with disabilities.
48
It sends a message of dwindling support for
49
their unique challenges, fosters a false sense
50
that disability is something that could have
51
been avoidable, and is likely to increase the
52
stigma associated with disability.
53
2. No person shall perform or induce an
54
abortion on a woman if the person knows that the
55
woman is seeking the abortion solely because of
56
a prenatal diagnosis, test, or screening
57
indicating Down Syndrome or the potential of
58
Down Syndrome in an unborn child.
59
3. No person shall perform or induce an
60
abortion on a woman if the person knows that the
61
woman is seeking the abortion solely because of
62
the sex or race of the unborn child.
63
4. Any physician or other person who
64
performs or induces or attempts to perform or
65
induce an abortion prohibited by this section
66
shall be subject to all applicable civil
67
SB 699
122
penalties under this chapter including, but not
68
limited to, sections 188.065 and 188.085.]
69
[188.039. 1. For purposes of this
1
section, "medical emergency" means a condition
2
which, on the basis of the physician's good
3
faith clinical judgment, so complicates the
4
medical condition of a pregnant woman as to
5
necessitate the immediate abortion of her
6
pregnancy to avert her death or for which a
7
delay will create a serious risk of substantial
8
and irreversible impairment of a major bodily
9
function.
10
2. Except in the case of medical
11
emergency, no person shall perform or induce an
12
abortion unless at least seventy-two hours prior
13
thereto the physician who is to perform or
14
induce the abortion, a qualified professional,
15
or the referring physician has conferred with
16
the patient and discussed with her the
17
indicators and contraindicators, and risk
18
factors including any physical, psychological,
19
or situational factors for the proposed
20
procedure and the use of medications, including
21
but not limited to mifepristone, in light of her
22
medical history and medical condition. For an
23
abortion performed or an abortion induced by a
24
drug or drugs, such conference shall take place
25
at least seventy-two hours prior to the writing
26
or communication of the first prescription for
27
such drug or drugs in connection with inducing
28
an abortion. Only one such conference shall be
29
required for each abortion.
30
3. The patient shall be evaluated by the
31
physician who is to perform or induce the
32
abortion, a qualified professional, or the
33
referring physician during the conference for
34
indicators and contraindicators, risk factors
35
including any physical, psychological, or
36
situational factors which would predispose the
37
patient to or increase the risk of experiencing
38
one or more adverse physical, emotional, or
39
other health reactions to the proposed procedure
40
or drug or drugs in either the short or long
41
term as compared with women who do not possess
42
such risk factors.
43
4. At the end of the conference, and if
44
the woman chooses to proceed with the abortion,
45
the physician who is to perform or induce the
46
abortion, a qualified professional, or the
47
referring physician shall sign and shall cause
48
the patient to sign a written statement that the
49
woman gave her informed consent freely and
50
without coercion after the physician or
51
qualified professional had discussed with her
52
the indicators and contraindicators, and risk
53
factors, including any physical, psychological,
54
SB 699
123
or situational factors. All such executed
55
statements shall be maintained as part of the
56
patient's medical file, subject to the
57
confidentiality laws and rules of this state.
58
5. The director of the department of
59
health and senior services shall disseminate a
60
model form that physicians or qualified
61
professionals may use as the written statement
62
required by this section, but any lack or
63
unavailability of such a model form shall not
64
affect the duties of the physician or qualified
65
professional set forth in subsections 2 to 4 of
66
this section.
67
6. As used in this section, the term
68
"qualified professional" shall refer to a
69
physician, physician assistant, registered
70
nurse, licensed practical nurse, psychologist,
71
licensed professional counselor, or licensed
72
social worker, licensed or registered under
73
chapter 334, 335, or 337, acting under the
74
supervision of the physician performing or
75
inducing the abortion, and acting within the
76
course and scope of his or her authority
77
provided by law. The provisions of this section
78
shall not be construed to in any way expand the
79
authority otherwise provided by law relating to
80
the licensure, registration, or scope of
81
practice of any such qualified professional.
82
7. If the provisions in subsection 2 of
83
this section requiring a seventy-two-hour
84
waiting period for an abortion are ever
85
temporarily or permanently restrained or
86
enjoined by judicial order, then the waiting
87
period for an abortion shall be twenty-four
88
hours; provided, however, that if such temporary
89
or permanent restraining order or injunction is
90
stayed or dissolved, or otherwise ceases to have
91
effect, the waiting period for an abortion shall
92
be seventy-two hours.]
93
[188.043. 1. No person shall perform or
1
induce an abortion on another unless such person
2
has medical malpractice insurance with coverage
3
amounts of at least one million dollars per
4
occurrence and three million dollars in the
5
annual aggregate.
6
2. For the purpose of this section,
7
"medical malpractice insurance" means insurance
8
coverage against the legal liability of the
9
insured and against loss, damage, or expense
10
incident to a claim arising out of the death or
11
injury of any person as a result of the
12
negligence or malpractice in rendering
13
professional service by any health care provider.
14
3. No abortion facility or hospital shall
15
employ or engage the services of a person to
16
perform or induce an abortion on another if the
17
SB 699
124
person does not have medical malpractice
18
insurance pursuant to this section, except that
19
the abortion facility or hospital may provide
20
medical malpractice insurance for the services
21
of persons employed or engaged by such facility
22
or hospital which is no less than the coverage
23
amounts set forth in this section.
24
4. Notwithstanding the provisions of
25
section 334.100, failure of a person to maintain
26
the medical malpractice insurance required by
27
this section shall be an additional ground for
28
sanctioning of a person's license, certificate,
29
or permit.]
30
[188.044. 1. When a drug or chemical, or
1
combination thereof, used by a person to induce
2
an abortion carries a warning from its
3
manufacturer or distributor, a peer-reviewed
4
medical journal article, or a Food and Drug
5
Administration label that its use may cause
6
birth defects, disability, or other injury in a
7
child who survives the abortion, then in
8
addition to the requirements of section 188.043,
9
such person shall also carry tail insurance with
10
coverage amounts of at least one million dollars
11
per occurrence and three million dollars in the
12
annual aggregate for personal injury to or death
13
of a child who survives such abortion. Such
14
policy shall be maintained in force or be in
15
effect for a period of twenty-one years after
16
the person used the drug or chemical, or
17
combination thereof, to induce the abortion.
18
2. For the purpose of this section, "tail
19
insurance" means insurance which covers the
20
legal liability of the insured once a medical
21
malpractice insurance policy is cancelled, not
22
renewed, or terminated, and covers claims made
23
after such cancellation or termination for acts
24
occurring during the period the prior medical
25
malpractice insurance was in effect.
26
3. No abortion facility or hospital shall
27
employ or engage the services of a person to
28
induce an abortion on another using any drug or
29
chemical, or combination thereof, which may
30
cause birth defects, disability, or other injury
31
in a child who survives the abortion if the
32
person does not have tail insurance pursuant to
33
this section, except that the abortion facility
34
or hospital may provide tail insurance for the
35
services of persons employed or engaged by such
36
facility or hospital which is no less than the
37
coverage amounts and duration set forth in this
38
section.
39
4. Notwithstanding the provisions of
40
section 334.100 to the contrary, failure of a
41
person to maintain the tail insurance required
42
by this section shall be an additional ground
43
SB 699
125
for sanctioning of a person's license,
44
certificate, or permit.]
45
[188.047. 1. All tissue, except that
1
tissue needed for purposes described in
2
subsection 5 of this section, removed at the
3
time of abortion shall be submitted within five
4
days to a board-eligible or certified
5
pathologist for gross and histopathological
6
examination. The pathologist shall file a copy
7
of the tissue report with the state department
8
of health and senior services, and shall provide
9
within seventy-two hours a copy of the report to
10
the abortion facility or hospital in which the
11
abortion was performed or induced. The
12
pathologist's report shall be made a part of the
13
patient's permanent record. If the pathological
14
examination fails to identify evidence of a
15
completed abortion, the pathologist shall notify
16
the abortion facility or hospital within twenty-
17
four hours.
18
2. The department shall reconcile each
19
notice of abortion with its corresponding tissue
20
report. If the department does not receive the
21
notice of abortion or the tissue report, the
22
department shall make an inquiry of the abortion
23
facility or hospital. After such inquiry, if
24
the hospital or abortion facility has not
25
satisfactorily responded to said inquiry and the
26
department finds that the abortion facility or
27
hospital where the abortion was performed or
28
induced was not in compliance with the
29
provisions of this section, the department shall
30
consider such noncompliance a deficiency
31
requiring an unscheduled inspection of the
32
facility to ensure the deficiency is remedied,
33
subject to the provisions of chapter 197
34
regarding license suspensions, reviews, and
35
appeals.
36
3. Beginning January 1, 2018, the
37
department shall make an annual report to the
38
general assembly. The report shall include the
39
number of any deficiencies and inquiries by the
40
department of each abortion facility in the
41
calendar year and whether any deficiencies were
42
remedied and, for each abortion facility,
43
aggregated de-identified data about the total
44
number of abortions performed at the facility,
45
the termination procedures used, the number and
46
type of complications reported for each type of
47
termination procedure, whether the department
48
received the tissue report for each abortion,
49
and the existence and nature, if any, of any
50
inconsistencies or concerns between the abortion
51
reports submitted under section 188.052 and the
52
tissue report submitted under this section. The
53
report shall not contain any personal patient
54
SB 699
126
information the disclosure of which is
55
prohibited by state or federal law.
56
4. All reports provided by the department
57
to the general assembly under this section shall
58
maintain confidentiality of all personal
59
information of patients, facility personnel, and
60
facility physicians.
61
5. Nothing in this section shall prohibit
62
the utilization of fetal organs or tissue
63
resulting from an abortion for medical or
64
scientific purposes to determine the cause or
65
causes of any anomaly, illness, death, or
66
genetic condition of the fetus, the paternity of
67
the fetus, or for law enforcement purposes.
68
6. The department may adopt rules,
69
regulations, and standards governing the reports
70
required under this section. In doing so, the
71
department shall ensure that these reports
72
contain all information necessary to ensure
73
compliance with all applicable laws and
74
regulations. Any rule or portion of a rule, as
75
that term is defined in section 536.010, that is
76
created under the authority delegated in this
77
section shall become effective only if it
78
complies with and is subject to all of the
79
provisions of chapter 536 and, if applicable,
80
section 536.028. This section and chapter 536
81
are nonseverable and if any of the powers vested
82
with the general assembly pursuant to chapter
83
536 to review, to delay the effective date, or
84
to disapprove and annul a rule are subsequently
85
held unconstitutional, then the grant of
86
rulemaking authority and any rule proposed or
87
adopted after October 24, 2017, shall be invalid
88
and void.]
89
[188.052. 1. An individual abortion
1
report for each abortion performed or induced
2
upon a woman shall be completed by the physician
3
who performed or induced the abortion. Abortion
4
reports shall include, but not be limited to, a
5
certification that the physician does not have
6
any knowledge that the woman sought the abortion
7
solely because of a prenatal diagnosis, test, or
8
screening indicating Down Syndrome or the
9
potential of Down Syndrome in the unborn child
10
and a certification that the physician does not
11
have any knowledge that the woman sought the
12
abortion solely because of the sex or race of
13
the unborn child.
14
2. An individual complication report for
15
any post-abortion care performed upon a woman
16
shall be completed by the physician providing
17
such post-abortion care. This report shall
18
include:
19
(1) The date of the abortion;
20
SB 699
127
(2) The name and address of the abortion
21
facility or hospital where the abortion was
22
performed or induced;
23
(3) The nature of the abortion
24
complication diagnosed or treated.
25
3. All abortion reports shall be signed by
26
the attending physician who performed or induced
27
the abortion and submitted to the department
28
within forty-five days from the date of the
29
abortion. All complication reports shall be
30
signed by the physician providing the post-
31
abortion care and submitted to the department
32
within forty-five days from the date of the post-
33
abortion care.
34
4. A copy of the abortion report shall be
35
made a part of the medical record of the patient
36
of the abortion facility or hospital in which
37
the abortion was performed or induced.
38
5. The department shall be responsible for
39
collecting all abortion reports and complication
40
reports and collating and evaluating all data
41
gathered therefrom and shall annually publish a
42
statistical report based on such data from
43
abortions performed or induced in the previous
44
calendar year.]
45
[188.055. 1. Every abortion facility,
1
hospital, and physician shall be supplied with
2
forms by the department of health and senior
3
services for use in regards to the consents and
4
reports required by sections 188.010 to
5
188.085. A purpose and function of such
6
consents and reports shall be the preservation
7
of maternal health and life by adding to the sum
8
of medical knowledge through the compilation of
9
relevant maternal health and life data and to
10
monitor all abortions performed to assure that
11
they are done only under and in accordance with
12
the provisions of the law.
13
2. All information obtained by physician,
14
hospital, or abortion facility from a patient
15
for the purpose of preparing reports to the
16
department of health and senior services under
17
sections 188.010 to 188.085 or reports received
18
by the division of health shall be confidential
19
and shall be used only for statistical
20
purposes. Such records, however, may be
21
inspected and health data acquired by local,
22
state, or national public health officers.]
23
[188.056. 1. Notwithstanding any other
1
provision of law to the contrary, no abortion
2
shall be performed or induced upon a woman at
3
eight weeks gestational age or later, except in
4
cases of medical emergency. Any person who
5
knowingly performs or induces an abortion of an
6
unborn child in violation of this subsection
7
shall be guilty of a class B felony, as well as
8
SB 699
128
subject to suspension or revocation of his or
9
her professional license by his or her
10
professional licensing board. A woman upon whom
11
an abortion is performed or induced in violation
12
of this subsection shall not be prosecuted for a
13
conspiracy to violate the provisions of this
14
section.
15
2. It shall be an affirmative defense for
16
any person alleged to have violated the
17
provisions of subsection 1 of this section that
18
the person performed or induced an abortion
19
because of a medical emergency. The defendant
20
shall have the burden of persuasion that the
21
defense is more probably true than not.
22
3. Prosecution under this section shall
23
bar prosecution under section* 188.057, 188.058,
24
or 188.375 if prosecution under such sections
25
would violate the provisions of Amendment V to
26
the Constitution of the United States or Article
27
I, Section 19 of the Constitution of Missouri.
28
4. If any one or more provisions,
29
subsections, sentences, clauses, phrases, or
30
words of this section or the application thereof
31
to any person, circumstance, or period of
32
gestational age is found to be unenforceable,
33
unconstitutional, or invalid by a court of
34
competent jurisdiction, the same is hereby
35
declared to be severable and the balance of the
36
section shall remain effective notwithstanding
37
such unenforceability, unconstitutionality, or
38
invalidity. The general assembly hereby
39
declares that it would have passed this section,
40
and each provision, subsection, sentence,
41
clause, phrase, or word thereof, irrespective of
42
the fact that any one or more provisions,
43
subsections, sentences, clauses, phrases, or
44
words of the section, or the application of the
45
section to any person, circumstance, or period
46
of gestational age, would be declared
47
unenforceable, unconstitutional, or invalid.]
48
[188.057. 1. Notwithstanding any other
1
provision of law to the contrary, no abortion
2
shall be performed or induced upon a woman at
3
fourteen weeks gestational age or later, except
4
in cases of medical emergency. Any person who
5
knowingly performs or induces an abortion of an
6
unborn child in violation of this subsection
7
shall be guilty of a class B felony, as well as
8
subject to suspension or revocation of his or
9
her professional license by his or her
10
professional licensing board. A woman upon whom
11
an abortion is performed or induced in violation
12
of this subsection shall not be prosecuted for a
13
conspiracy to violate the provisions of this
14
section.
15
SB 699
129
2. It shall be an affirmative defense for
16
any person alleged to have violated the
17
provisions of subsection 1 of this section that
18
the person performed or induced an abortion
19
because of a medical emergency. The defendant
20
shall have the burden of persuasion that the
21
defense is more probably true than not.
22
3. Prosecution under this section shall
23
bar prosecution under section 188.056, 188.058,
24
or 188.375 if prosecution under such sections
25
would violate the provisions of Amendment V to
26
the Constitution of the United States or Article
27
I, Section 19 of the Constitution of Missouri.
28
4. If any one or more provisions,
29
subsections, sentences, clauses, phrases, or
30
words of this section or the application thereof
31
to any person, circumstance, or period of
32
gestational age is found to be unenforceable,
33
unconstitutional, or invalid by a court of
34
competent jurisdiction, the same is hereby
35
declared to be severable and the balance of the
36
section shall remain effective notwithstanding
37
such unenforceability, unconstitutionality, or
38
invalidity. The general assembly hereby
39
declares that it would have passed this section,
40
and each provision, subsection, sentence,
41
clause, phrase, or word thereof, irrespective of
42
the fact that any one or more provisions,
43
subsections, sentences, clauses, phrases, or
44
words of the section, or the application of the
45
section to any person, circumstance, or period
46
of gestational age, would be declared
47
unenforceable, unconstitutional, or invalid.]
48
[188.058. 1. Notwithstanding any other
1
provision of law to the contrary, no abortion
2
shall be performed or induced upon a woman at
3
eighteen weeks gestational age or later, except
4
in cases of medical emergency. Any person who
5
knowingly performs or induces an abortion of an
6
unborn child in violation of this subsection
7
shall be guilty of a class B felony, as well as
8
subject to suspension or revocation of his or
9
her professional license by his or her
10
professional licensing board. A woman upon whom
11
an abortion is performed or induced in violation
12
of this section shall not be prosecuted for a
13
conspiracy to violate the provisions of this
14
section.
15
2. It shall be an affirmative defense for
16
any person alleged to have violated the
17
provisions of subsection 1 of this section that
18
the person performed or induced an abortion
19
because of a medical emergency. The defendant
20
shall have the burden of persuasion that the
21
defense is more probably true than not.
22
SB 699
130
3. Prosecution under this section shall
23
bar prosecution under section188.056, 188.057,
24
or 188.375 if prosecution under such sections
25
would violate the provisions of Amendment V to
26
the Constitution of the United States or Article
27
I, Section 19 of the Constitution of Missouri.
28
4. If any one or more provisions,
29
subsections, sentences, clauses, phrases, or
30
words of this section or the application thereof
31
to any person, circumstance, or period of
32
gestational age is found to be unenforceable,
33
unconstitutional, or invalid by a court of
34
competent jurisdiction, the same is hereby
35
declared to be severable and the balance of the
36
section shall remain effective notwithstanding
37
such unenforceability, unconstitutionality, or
38
invalidity. The general assembly hereby
39
declares that it would have passed this section,
40
and each provision, subsection, sentence,
41
clause, phrase, or word thereof, irrespective of
42
the fact that any one or more provisions,
43
subsections, sentences, clauses, phrases, or
44
words of the section, or the application of the
45
section to any person, circumstance, or period
46
of gestational age, would be declared
47
unenforceable, unconstitutional, or invalid.]
48
[188.060. All medical records, reports,
1
and other documents required to be kept under
2
sections 188.010 to 188.085 shall be maintained
3
in the permanent files of the abortion facility
4
or hospital in which the abortion was performed
5
for a period of seven years.]
6
[188.065. Any practitioner of medicine,
1
surgery, or nursing, or other health personnel
2
who shall willfully and knowingly do or assist
3
any action made unlawful by sections 188.010 to
4
188.085 shall be subject to having his license,
5
application for license, or authority to
6
practice his profession as a physician, surgeon,
7
or nurse in the state of Missouri rejected or
8
revoked by the appropriate state licensing
9
board.]
10
[188.070. Any physician or other person
1
who fails to maintain the confidentiality of any
2
records or reports required under sections
3
188.010 to 188.085 is guilty of a misdemeanor
4
and, upon conviction, shall be punished as
5
provided by law.]
6
[188.075. 1. Any person who contrary to
1
the provisions of sections 188.010 to 188.085
2
knowingly performs, induces, or aids in the
3
performance or inducing of any abortion or
4
knowingly fails to perform any action required
5
by sections 188.010 to 188.085 shall be guilty
6
of a class A misdemeanor, unless a different
7
SB 699
131
penalty is provided for in state law, and, upon
8
conviction, shall be punished as provided by law.
9
2. It shall be an affirmative defense for
10
any person alleged to have violated any
11
provision of this chapter that the person
12
performed an action or did not perform an action
13
because of a medical emergency. This
14
affirmative defense shall be available in
15
criminal, civil, and administrative actions or
16
proceedings. The defendant shall have the
17
burden of persuasion that the defense is more
18
probably true than not.
19
3. The attorney general shall have
20
concurrent original jurisdiction throughout the
21
state, along with each prosecuting attorney and
22
circuit attorney within their respective
23
jurisdictions, to commence actions for a
24
violation of any provision of this chapter, for
25
a violation of any state law on the use of
26
public funds for an abortion, or for a violation
27
of any state law which regulates an abortion
28
facility or a person who performs or induces an
29
abortion. The attorney general, or prosecuting
30
attorney or circuit attorney within their
31
respective jurisdictions, may seek injunctive or
32
other relief against any person who, or entity
33
which, is in violation of any provision of this
34
chapter, misuses public funds for an abortion,
35
or violates any state law which regulates an
36
abortion facility or a person who performs or
37
induces an abortion.]
38
[188.080. Any person who is not a
1
physician who performs or induces or attempts to
2
perform or induce an abortion on another is
3
guilty of a class B felony, and, upon
4
conviction, shall be punished as provided by
5
law. Any physician performing or inducing an
6
abortion who does not have clinical privileges
7
at a hospital which offers obstetrical or
8
gynecological care located within thirty miles
9
of the location at which the abortion is
10
performed or induced shall be guilty of a class
11
A misdemeanor, and, upon conviction shall be
12
punished as provided by law.]
13
[188.100. Unless the language or context
1
clearly indicates a different meaning is
2
intended, the following words or phrases for the
3
purposes of sections 188.100 to 188.120 shall
4
mean:
5
(1) "Employer", the state, or any
6
political or civil subdivision thereof, or any
7
person employing two or more persons within the
8
state, and any person acting as an agent of the
9
employer;
10
(2) "Participate in abortion", to perform,
11
assist in, refer for, promote, procure, or
12
SB 699
132
counsel a woman to have an abortion not
13
necessary to save the life of the mother; or to
14
undergo an abortion;
15
(3) "Person" includes one or more
16
individuals, partnerships, associations,
17
organizations, corporations, legal
18
representatives, trustees, trustees in
19
bankruptcy, receivers, or other organized groups
20
of persons.]
21
[188.105. 1. It shall be unlawful:
1
(1) For an employer:
2
(a) To fail or refuse to hire or to
3
discharge any individual, or otherwise to
4
discriminate against any individual with respect
5
to his or her compensation, terms, conditions,
6
or privileges of employment, because of such
7
individual's refusal to participate in abortion;
8
(b) To limit, segregate, or classify his,
9
her, or its employees or applicants for
10
employment in any way which would deprive or
11
tend to deprive any individual of employment
12
opportunities or otherwise adversely affect his
13
or her status as an employee, because of such
14
individual's refusal to participate in abortion;
15
(c) To discharge, expel, or otherwise
16
discriminate against any person because he or
17
she has opposed any practices forbidden under
18
sections 188.100 to 188.120 or because he or she
19
has filed a complaint, testified, or assisted in
20
any legal proceeding under sections 188.100 to
21
188.120;
22
(2) For any person, whether an employer or
23
employee, or not, to aid, abet, incite, compel,
24
or coerce the doing of any of the acts forbidden
25
under sections 188.100 to 188.120, or to attempt
26
to do so.
27
2. Notwithstanding any other provision of
28
sections 188.100 to 188.120, the acts proscribed
29
in subsection 1 of this section shall not be
30
unlawful if there can be demonstrated an
31
inability to reasonably accommodate an
32
individual's refusal to participate in abortion
33
without undue hardship on the conduct of that
34
particular business or enterprise, or in those
35
certain instances where participation in
36
abortion is a bona fide occupational
37
qualification reasonably necessary to the normal
38
operation of that particular business or
39
enterprise.
40
3. Nothing contained in sections 188.100
41
to 188.120 shall be interpreted to require any
42
employer to grant preferential treatment to any
43
individual because of such individual's refusal
44
to participate in abortion.]
45
[188.110. 1. No public or private
1
college, university or hospital shall
2
SB 699
133
discriminate against any person for refusal to
3
participate in abortion.
4
2. No applicant, student, teacher, or
5
employee of any school shall be required to pay
6
any fees that would in whole or in part fund an
7
abortion for any other applicant, student,
8
teacher, or employee of that school, if the
9
individual required to pay the fee gives written
10
notice to the proper school authorities that it
11
would be in violation of his or her conscience
12
or beliefs to pay for or fund abortions. The
13
school may require the individual to pay that
14
part of the fees not funding abortions, if the
15
school makes reasonable precautions and gives
16
reasonable assurance that the fees that are paid
17
are segregated from any fund for the payment of
18
abortions.]
19
[188.115. If any provision of sections
1
188.100 to 188.120 is found by a court of
2
competent jurisdiction to be invalid or
3
unconstitutional as applied to a specific person
4
or class of persons, the provisions of sections
5
188.100 to 188.120 shall remain in full force
6
and effect as to every other person or class of
7
persons who is otherwise covered under these
8
sections.]
9
[188.120. Any individual injured by any
1
person, association, corporation, or entity by
2
reason of any action prohibited by sections
3
188.100 to 188.120, as now or hereafter amended,
4
may commence a civil cause of action against the
5
person, association, corporation, or entity who
6
caused the injury, and shall recover treble
7
damages, including pain and suffering, sustained
8
by such individual, the costs of the suit and
9
reasonable attorney's fees.]
10
[188.160. 1. Every hospital, abortion
1
facility, pathology lab, medical research
2
entity, and any other facility involved in
3
abortion shall establish and implement a written
4
policy relating to the protections for employees
5
who disclose information concerning actual,
6
potential, or alleged violations of applicable
7
federal or state laws or administrative rules,
8
regulations, or standards.
9
2. The department of health and senior
10
services is authorized to adopt rules,
11
regulations, and standards regarding the
12
establishment and implementation of policies
13
created under this section. Any rule or portion
14
of a rule, as that term is defined in section
15
536.010, that is created under the authority
16
delegated in this section shall become effective
17
only if it complies with and is subject to all
18
of the provisions of chapter 536 and, if
19
SB 699
134
applicable, section 536.028. This section and
20
chapter 536 are nonseverable and if any of the
21
powers vested with the general assembly pursuant
22
to chapter 536 to review, to delay the effective
23
date, or to disapprove and annul a rule are
24
subsequently held unconstitutional, then the
25
grant of rulemaking authority and any rule
26
proposed or adopted after October 24, 2017,
27
shall be invalid and void.]
28
[188.200. As used in sections 188.200 to
1
188.220, the following terms mean:
2
(1) "Public employee", any person employed
3
by this state or any agency or political
4
subdivision thereof;
5
(2) "Public facility", any public
6
institution, public facility, public equipment,
7
or any physical asset owned, leased, or
8
controlled by this state or any agency or
9
political subdivisions thereof;
10
(3) "Public funds", any funds received or
11
controlled by this state or any agency or
12
political subdivision thereof, including, but
13
not limited to, funds derived from federal,
14
state or local taxes, gifts or grants from any
15
source, public or private, federal grants or
16
payments, or intergovernmental transfers.]
17
[188.205. It shall be unlawful for any
1
public funds to be expended for the purpose of
2
performing or assisting an abortion, not
3
necessary to save the life of the mother, or for
4
the purpose of encouraging or counseling a woman
5
to have an abortion not necessary to save her
6
life.]
7
[188.210. It shall be unlawful for any
1
public employee within the scope of his
2
employment to perform or assist an abortion, not
3
necessary to save the life of the mother. It
4
shall be unlawful for a doctor, nurse or other
5
health care personnel, a social worker, a
6
counselor or persons of similar occupation who
7
is a public employee within the scope of his
8
public employment to encourage or counsel a
9
woman to have an abortion not necessary to save
10
her life.]
11
[188.215. It shall be unlawful for any
1
public facility to be used for the purpose of
2
performing or assisting an abortion not
3
necessary to save the life of the mother or for
4
the purpose of encouraging or counseling a woman
5
to have an abortion not necessary to save her
6
life.]
7
[188.220. Any taxpayer of this state or
1
its political subdivisions shall have standing
2
to bring suit in a circuit court of proper venue
3
SB 699
135
to enforce the provisions of sections 188.200 to
4
188.215.]
5
[188.230. Nothing in this act is intended
1
to authorize anyone other than a physician to
2
perform an abortion.]
3
[188.250. 1. No person shall
1
intentionally cause, aid, or assist a minor to
2
obtain an abortion without the consent or
3
consents required by section 188.028.
4
2. A person who violates subsection 1 of
5
this section shall be civilly liable to the
6
minor and to the person or persons required to
7
give the consent or consents under section
8
188.028. A court may award damages to the
9
person or persons adversely affected by a
10
violation of subsection 1 of this section,
11
including compensation for emotional injury
12
without the need for personal presence at the
13
act or event, and the court may further award
14
attorneys' fees, litigation costs, and punitive
15
damages. Any adult who engages in or consents
16
to another person engaging in a sex act with a
17
minor in violation of the provisions of chapter
18
566, 567, 568, or 573 which results in the
19
minor's pregnancy shall not be awarded damages
20
under this section.
21
3. It shall not be a defense to a claim
22
brought under this section that the abortion was
23
performed or induced pursuant to consent to the
24
abortion given in a manner that is otherwise
25
lawful in the state or place where the abortion
26
was performed or induced.
27
4. An unemancipated minor does not have
28
capacity to consent to any action in violation
29
of this section or section 188.028.
30
5. A court may enjoin conduct that would
31
be in violation of this section upon petition by
32
the attorney general, a prosecuting or circuit
33
attorney, or any person adversely affected or
34
who reasonably may be adversely affected by such
35
conduct, upon a showing that such conduct:
36
(1) Is reasonably anticipated to occur in
37
the future; or
38
(2) Has occurred in the past, whether with
39
the same minor or others, and that it is not
40
unreasonable to expect that such conduct will be
41
repeated.]
42
[188.325. 1. There is hereby established
1
the "Missouri Alternatives to Abortion Services
2
Program" which shall be administered by a state
3
agency or agencies, as designated by
4
appropriations to such or each agency. The
5
alternatives to abortion services program shall
6
consist of services or counseling to pregnant
7
women and continuing for one year after birth to
8
SB 699
136
assist women in carrying their unborn children
9
to term instead of having abortions, and to
10
assist women in caring for their dependent
11
children or placing their children for adoption.
12
2. Services provided under the
13
alternatives to abortion program shall include
14
but not be limited to the following:
15
(1) Prenatal care;
16
(2) Medical and mental health care;
17
(3) Parenting skills;
18
(4) Drug and alcohol testing and treatment;
19
(5) Child care, and newborn and infant
20
care;
21
(6) Housing and utilities;
22
(7) Educational services;
23
(8) Food, clothing, and supplies relating
24
to pregnancy, newborn care, and parenting;
25
(9) Adoption assistance;
26
(10) Job training and placement;
27
(11) Establishing and promoting
28
responsible paternity;
29
(12) Ultrasound services;
30
(13) Case management;
31
(14) Domestic abuse protection; and
32
(15) Transportation.
33
3. Actual provision and delivery of
34
services and counseling shall be dependent on
35
client needs and not otherwise prioritized by
36
the agency or agencies administering the
37
program. Services and counseling shall be
38
available only during pregnancy and continuing
39
for one year after birth, and shall exclude any
40
family planning services. The agency or
41
agencies administering the program may contract
42
with other public or private agencies or
43
entities to provide the services or counseling
44
on behalf of the agency or agencies
45
administering the program. Such other public or
46
private agencies or entities may provide
47
additional services or counseling, or services
48
or counseling for more than one year after
49
birth, that are not funded under the
50
alternatives to abortion services program, as
51
long as such services or counseling are not
52
inconsistent with the provisions of this
53
section. Contractors for the alternatives to
54
abortion services program may also be
55
contractors for the alternatives to abortion
56
public awareness program established in section
57
188.335.
58
4. The agency or agencies administering
59
the program shall to the greatest extent
60
possible supplement and match moneys
61
appropriated for the alternatives to abortion
62
services program with federal and other public
63
moneys and with private moneys. The agency or
64
agencies administering the program shall
65
SB 699
137
prioritize such additional federal, other
66
public, and private moneys so that they are used
67
preferentially for the alternatives to abortion
68
services program and the alternatives to
69
abortion public awareness program.
70
5. The alternatives to abortion services
71
program and the moneys expended under this
72
section shall not be used to perform or induce,
73
assist in the performing or inducing of or refer
74
for abortions. Moneys expended under this
75
section shall not be granted to organizations or
76
affiliates of organizations that perform or
77
induce, assist in the performing or inducing of
78
or refer for abortions.]
79
[188.335. 1. There is hereby established
1
the "Missouri Alternatives to Abortion Public
2
Awareness Program" which shall be administered
3
by a state agency or agencies, as designated by
4
appropriations to such or each agency.
5
2. The purpose of the alternatives to
6
abortion public awareness program is to help
7
pregnant women at risk for having abortions to
8
be made aware of the alternatives to abortion
9
agencies located and alternatives to abortion
10
services available to them in their local
11
communities. The alternatives to abortion
12
public awareness program shall include the
13
development and promotion of a website which
14
provides a geographically indexed list of
15
alternatives to abortion agencies as well as
16
contractors for the alternatives to abortion
17
services program established in section 188.325.
18
As used in this section, "alternatives to
19
abortion agencies" means agencies exempt from
20
income taxation pursuant to the United States
21
Internal Revenue Code that offer alternatives to
22
abortion services as defined within section
23
188.325, including but not limited to maternity
24
homes, pregnancy resource centers, and agencies
25
commonly known and referred to as crisis
26
pregnancy centers. The alternatives to abortion
27
public awareness program may also include but
28
need not be limited to the use of television,
29
radio, outdoor advertising, newspapers,
30
magazines, and other print media, and the
31
internet to provide information on these
32
alternatives to abortion agencies and services.
33
The state agency or agencies administering the
34
alternatives to abortion public awareness
35
program are encouraged to give first preference
36
to contracting with private agencies or
37
entities, which are exempt from income taxation
38
pursuant to the United States Internal Revenue
39
Code, to conduct the alternatives to abortion
40
public awareness program. Contractors for the
41
alternatives to abortion public awareness
42
SB 699
138
program may also be contractors for the
43
alternatives to abortion services program
44
established in section 188.325.
45
3. The agency or agencies administering
46
the program shall to the greatest extent
47
possible supplement and match moneys
48
appropriated for the alternatives to abortion
49
public awareness program with federal and other
50
public moneys and with private moneys. The
51
agency or agencies administering the program
52
shall prioritize such additional federal, other
53
public, and private moneys so that they are used
54
preferentially for the alternatives to abortion
55
public awareness program and the alternatives to
56
abortion services program.
57
4. The alternatives to abortion public
58
awareness program and the moneys expended under
59
this section shall not be used to perform or
60
induce, assist in the performing or inducing of
61
or refer for abortions. Moneys expended under
62
this section shall not be granted to
63
organizations or affiliates of organizations
64
that perform or induce, assist in the performing
65
or inducing of or refer for abortions.]
66
[188.375. 1. This section shall be known
1
and may be cited as the "Late-Term Pain-Capable
2
Unborn Child Protection Act".
3
2. As used in this section, the phrase
4
"late-term pain-capable unborn child" shall mean
5
an unborn child at twenty weeks gestational age
6
or later.
7
3. Notwithstanding any other provision of
8
law to the contrary, no abortion shall be
9
performed or induced upon a woman carrying a
10
late-term pain-capable unborn child, except in
11
cases of medical emergency. Any person who
12
knowingly performs or induces an abortion of a
13
late-term pain-capable unborn child in violation
14
of this subsection shall be guilty of a class B
15
felony, as well as subject to suspension or
16
revocation of his or her professional license by
17
his or her professional licensing board. A
18
woman upon whom an abortion is performed or
19
induced in violation of this subsection shall
20
not be prosecuted for a conspiracy to violate
21
the provisions of this subsection.
22
4. It shall be an affirmative defense for
23
any person alleged to have violated the
24
provisions of subsection 3 of this section that
25
the person performed or induced an abortion
26
because of a medical emergency. The defendant
27
shall have the burden of persuasion that the
28
defense is more probably true than not.
29
5. Prosecution under subsection 3 of this
30
section shall bar prosecution under
31
section188.056, 188.057, or 188.058 if
32
SB 699
139
prosecution under such sections would violate
33
the provisions of Amendment V to the
34
Constitution of the United States or Article I,
35
Section 19 of the Constitution of Missouri.
36
6. When in cases of medical emergency a
37
physician performs or induces an abortion upon a
38
woman in her third trimester carrying a late-
39
term pain-capable unborn child, the physician
40
shall utilize the available method or technique
41
of abortion most likely to preserve the life or
42
health of the unborn child. In cases where the
43
method or technique of abortion most likely to
44
preserve the life or health of the unborn child
45
would present a greater risk to the life or
46
health of the woman than another legally
47
permitted and available method or technique, the
48
physician may utilize such other method or
49
technique. In all cases where the physician
50
performs or induces an abortion upon a woman
51
during her third trimester carrying a late-term
52
pain-capable unborn child, the physician shall
53
certify in writing the available method or
54
techniques considered and the reasons for
55
choosing the method or technique employed.
56
7. When in cases of medical emergency a
57
physician performs or induces an abortion upon a
58
woman during her third trimester carrying a late-
59
term pain-capable unborn child, there shall be
60
in attendance a physician other than the
61
physician performing or inducing the abortion
62
who shall take control of and provide immediate
63
medical care for a child born as a result of the
64
abortion.
65
8. Any physician who knowingly violates
66
any of the provisions of subsection 6 or 7 of
67
this section shall be guilty of a class D
68
felony, as well as subject to suspension or
69
revocation of his or her professional license by
70
his or her professional licensing board. A
71
woman upon whom an abortion is performed or
72
induced in violation of subsection 6 or 7 of
73
this section shall not be prosecuted for a
74
conspiracy to violate the provisions of those
75
subsections.
76
9. If any one or more provisions,
77
subsections, sentences, clauses, phrases, or
78
words of this section or the application thereof
79
to any person, circumstance, or period of
80
gestational age is found to be unenforceable,
81
unconstitutional, or invalid by a court of
82
competent jurisdiction, the same is hereby
83
declared to be severable and the balance of the
84
section shall remain effective notwithstanding
85
such unenforceability, unconstitutionality, or
86
invalidity. The general assembly hereby
87
declares that it would have passed this section,
88
and each provision, subsection, sentence,
89
SB 699
140
clause, phrase, or word thereof, irrespective of
90
the fact that any one or more provisions,
91
subsections, sentences, clauses, phrases, or
92
words of the section, or the application of the
93
section to any person, circumstance, or period
94
of gestational age, would be declared
95
unenforceable, unconstitutional, or invalid.]
96
[194.390. Nothing in sections 194.375 to
1
194.390 shall be construed to prohibit a woman's
2
ability to obtain a legal abortion.]
3
[208.655. No funds used to pay for
1
insurance or for services pursuant to sections
2
208.631 to 208.657 may be expended to encourage,
3
counsel or refer for abortion unless the
4
abortion is done to save the life of the mother
5
or if the unborn child is the result of rape or
6
incest. No funds may be paid pursuant to
7
sections 208.631 to 208.657 to any person or
8
organization that performs abortions or counsels
9
or refers for abortion unless the abortion is
10
done to save the life of the mother or if the
11
unborn child is the result of rape or incest.]
12
[334.245. 1. Notwithstanding any other
1
provision of law to the contrary that may allow
2
a person to provide services relating to
3
pregnancy, including prenatal, delivery, and
4
postpartum services, no person other than a
5
licensed physician is authorized to perform or
6
induce an abortion.
7
2. Any person who violates the provisions
8
of this section is guilty of a class B felony.]
9
[376.805. 1. No health insurance
1
contracts, plans, or policies delivered or
2
issued for delivery in the state shall provide
3
coverage for elective abortions except by an
4
optional rider for which there must be paid an
5
additional premium. For purposes of this
6
section, an "elective abortion" means an
7
abortion for any reason other than a spontaneous
8
abortion or to prevent the death of the female
9
upon whom the abortion is performed.
10
2. Subsection 1 of this section shall be
11
applicable to all contracts, plans or policies
12
of:
13
(1) All health insurers subject to this
14
chapter; and
15
(2) All nonprofit hospital, medical,
16
surgical, dental, and health service
17
corporations subject to chapter 354; and
18
(3) All health maintenance organizations.
19
3. No health insurance exchange
20
established within this state or any health
21
insurance exchange administered by the federal
22
government or its agencies within this state
23
shall offer health insurance contracts, plans,
24
SB 699
141
or policies that provide coverage for elective
25
abortions, nor shall any health insurance
26
exchange operating within this state offer
27
coverage for elective abortions through the
28
purchase of an optional rider.
29
4. This section shall be applicable only
30
to contracts, plans or policies written, issued,
31
renewed or revised after September 28, 1983.
32
For the purposes of this subsection, if new
33
premiums are charged for a contract, plan or
34
policy, it shall be determined to be a new
35
contract, plan or policy.]
36
[565.300. 1. This section shall be known
1
and may be cited as the "Infant's Protection
2
Act".
3
2. As used in this section, and only in
4
this section, the following terms shall mean:
5
(1) "Born", complete separation of an
6
intact child from the mother regardless of
7
whether the umbilical cord is cut or the
8
placenta detached;
9
(2) "Living infant", a human child, born
10
or partially born, who is alive, as determined
11
in accordance with the usual and customary
12
standards of medical practice and is not dead as
13
determined pursuant to section 194.005, relating
14
to the determination of the occurrence of death,
15
and has not attained the age of thirty days post
16
birth;
17
(3) "Partially born", partial separation
18
of a child from the mother with the child's head
19
intact with the torso. If vaginally delivered,
20
a child is partially separated from the mother
21
when the head in a cephalic presentation, or any
22
part of the torso above the navel in a breech
23
presentation, is outside the mother's external
24
cervical os. If delivered abdominally, a child
25
is partially separated from the mother when the
26
child's head in a cephalic presentation, or any
27
part of the torso above the navel in a breech
28
presentation, is outside the mother's external
29
abdominal wall.
30
3. A person commits the offense of
31
infanticide if he or she causes the death of a
32
living infant with the purpose to cause said
33
death by an overt act performed when the infant
34
is partially born or born.
35
4. The offense of infanticide is a class A
36
felony.
37
5. A physician using procedures consistent
38
with the usual and customary standards of
39
medical practice to save the life of the mother
40
during pregnancy or birth or to save the life of
41
any unborn or partially born child of the same
42
pregnancy shall not be criminally responsible
43
under this section. In no event shall the
44
SB 699
142
mother be criminally responsible pursuant to
45
this section for the acts of the physician if
46
the physician is not held criminally responsible
47
pursuant to this section.
48
6. This section shall not apply to any
49
person who performs or attempts to perform a
50
legal abortion if the act that causes the death
51
is performed prior to the child being partially
52
born, even though the death of the child occurs
53
as a result of the abortion after the child is
54
partially born.
55
7. Only that person who performs the overt
56
act required under subsection 3 of this section
57
shall be culpable under this section, unless a
58
person, with the purpose of committing
59
infanticide, does any act which is a substantial
60
step towards the commission of the offense which
61
results in the death of the living infant. A
62
"substantial step" is conduct which is strongly
63
corroborative of the firmness of the actor's
64
purpose to complete the commission of the
65
offense.
66
8. Nothing in this section shall be
67
interpreted to exclude the defenses otherwise
68
available to any person under the law including
69
defenses provided pursuant to chapters 562 and
70
563.]
71
[574.200. 1. A person commits the offense
1
of interference with medical assistance if he or
2
she, while serving in his or her capacity as an
3
employee of an abortion facility:
4
(1) Knowingly orders or requests medical
5
personnel to deviate from any applicable
6
standard of care or ordinary practice while
7
providing medical assistance to a patient for
8
reasons unrelated to the patient's health or
9
welfare; or
10
(2) Knowingly attempts to prevent medical
11
personnel from providing medical assistance to a
12
patient in accordance with all applicable
13
standards of care or ordinary practice for
14
reasons unrelated to the patient's health or
15
welfare.
16
2. The offense of interference with
17
medical assistance is a class A misdemeanor.
18
3. For purposes of this section, the term
19
"medical personnel" shall include, but not be
20
limited to, the following:
21
(1) Physicians and surgeons licensed under
22
chapter 334;
23
(2) Nurses licensed under chapter 335;
24
(3) Emergency medical services personnel
25
as defined in section 190.600; or
26
(4) Any person operating under the
27
supervision of such medical personnel.]
28
SB 699
143
Section B. Any federal act, law, treaty, decision,
1
order, rule, or regulation that purports to supersede, stay,
2
or overrule section A of this act is in violation of the
3
Constitution of the state of Missouri and the Constitution
4
of the United States and is therefore void. The state of
5
Missouri and its political subdivisions, and agents thereof,
6
are not required to enter an appearance, special or
7
otherwise, in any federal suit challenging this act.
8
Section C. Because immediate action is necessary to
1
protect the unborn children in the state of Missouri,
2
section A of this act is deemed necessary for the immediate
3
preservation of the public health, welfare, peace, and
4
safety, and is hereby declared to be an emergency act within
5
the meaning of the constitution, and section A of this act
6
shall be in full force and effect upon its passage and
7
approval.
8